Development proposed is:- Removal of chimneys and demolition of existing shed. Erection of a single storey rear extension. Alterations to enlarge the existing single storey projection on the west side by extending it at the front and adding a first floor over. Alterations to the existing single storey garage on east side by provision of first floor above. The addition of a two-storey projecting bay on the front elevation. Alterations to the front porch and
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Extensions
Ecology & Biodiversity
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 21 February 2018
by Clive Tokley MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 09 March 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/G2245/D/17/3187933
Glebe House, Ash Road, Hartley, Longfield, DA3 7DT.
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act
1990 against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr K Bhatti against the decision of Sevenoaks District
Council.
The application ref SE/17/02398/HOUSE, dated 26 July 2017, was refused by
notice dated 25 September 2017.
The development proposed is:- Removal of chimneys and demolition of existing
shed. Erection of a single storey rear extension. Alterations to enlarge the
existing single storey projection on the west side by extending it at the front
and adding a first floor over. Alterations to the existing single storey garage on
east side by provision of first floor above. The addition of a two-storey
projecting bay on the front elevation. Alterations to the front porch and
remodelling of the existing front bay. Erection of a detached double garage.
Decision
1. As regards the extensions and alterations to the dwellinghouse - the appeal is
dismissed.
2. As regards the detached double garage only - the appeal is allowed and
planning permission is granted for the erection of a detached double garage at
Glebe House, Ash Road, Hartley, Longfield, DA3 7DT in accordance with the
terms of the application Ref SE/17/02398/HOUSE, dated 26 July 2017 subject
to the following conditions:
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than 3 years from
the date of this decision.
2) The materials to be used in the construction of the external surfaces of the
development hereby permitted shall match those used in the existing
building.
3) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with
the following approved plans: 20 and 27 Rev B.
Main Issues
3. The main issues are: -
a. Whether the proposal would be inappropriate development in the Green
Belt having regard to the Development Plan and the National Planning
Policy Framework (The Framework).
Appeal Decision APP/G2245/D/17/3187933
2
b. The effect of the proposal on the openness of the Green Belt.
c. If the proposal is inappropriate development whether there are any other
considerations that clearly outweigh the harm to the Green Belt due to
inappropriateness and any other harm and whether very special
circumstances exist to justify the granting of permission.
Reasons
Inappropriate development
4. The Framework indicates that within Green Belts inappropriate development is,
by definition, harmful and should not be approved except in very special
circumstances. The construction of new buildings is normally inappropriate
development; however in Paragraph 89 the Framework identifies a range of
developments which may not be inappropriate. These exceptions include a
specific provision for the enlargement of a building.
5. Bullet point 3 of Paragraph 89 indicates that the extension or alteration of a
building; provided that it does not result in disproportionate additions over and
above the size of the original building, may not be inappropriate. “Original” is
defined by the Framework as a building as it existed on 1 July 1948 or, if
constructed after that date, as it was originally built.
6. The Framework does not provide any quantitative guidance as to what would
amount to a disproportionate addition; however Policy GB1 of the Council’s
Allocations and Development Management Plan 2015 (ADMP) – “Limited
Extensions to Dwellings in the Green Belt” sets out a number of criteria against
which extensions are to be assessed. Criterion c) indicates that extensions will
be permitted if clear evidence is provided to show that the total floor-space of
the proposal, together with any previous extensions, alterations and
outbuildings would not result in an increase of more than 50% above the floor-
space of the ‘original’ dwelling (measured externally) including outbuildings
within 5m of the existing building.
7. The officer report indicates that when added to existing extensions the proposal
would result in an increase in floorspace of about 120% as compared with the
original dwelling. The appellant does not agree with the Council’s calculations;
however the appellant accepts that the proposal would exceed the 50%
increase set out in Policy GB1 and states that the addition would be
inappropriate development.
8. Within an area of restraint on development, and taking account of the ADMP,
(which post-dates the Framework) I consider that an increase in size of in
excess of 50% would be disproportionate to the original dwelling. Therefore on
this issue I have no reason to disagree with the Council and the appellant that
the proposal would be inappropriate development in the Green Belt.
9. Policy GB3 of the ADMP indicates that outbuildings located more than 5m from
a dwelling will be permitted provided that a number of criteria are satisfied.
The proposed garage would be 5m from the house and the Council indicates
that those criteria would be met. I have no reason to take a different view and
I therefore conclude that the garage would not be inappropriate development.
Appeal Decision APP/G2245/D/17/3187933
3
Openness
10. Any above ground building would have some effect on openness. The proposal
would add volume to the house at both first floor and ground floor with
elements of the extensions at the front and rear and on both sides. The
increase in bulk of the house would detract from openness and would therefore
offend against one of the essential characteristics of Green Belts.
11. An assessment of “inappropriateness” implicitly takes account of any effect on
openness; therefore whilst the garage would result in an additional building it
would not unacceptably detract from openness. I set out my conclusions on the
garage at the end of this decision.
Other considerations
12. The appellant has identified a number of extensions that could be carried out to
the dwelling as “permitted development” (PD) without the need for planning
permission from the Council. These include single storey side and rear
extensions and a rear dormer window that are the subject of a Certificate of
Lawfulness. The appellant indicates that the alternative PD development would
result in an increase in floorspace of about 41 sq m more than the appeal
proposal. The appellant also indicates that a garden shed at the side of the
house would be removed.
13. The Council agrees with the appellant’s figure but points out that about 50sq m
of the additional useable floorspace would be accommodated in the roof space.
I note the points made by the Council about the relationship between volume
and floorspace when considering loft conversions and I acknowledge that in
such circumstances floorspace is not always a good proxy for volume.
Nevertheless, for the purposes of assessing the “size” of an extension Policy
GB1 specifically includes the habitable floorspace created by the addition of
dormer windows and I can find no reason to adopt a different approach. When
assessed against Policy GB1 the PD alternative, or ”fall-back”, would result in a
greater increase in floorspace than the appeal proposal. Based on the
appellant’s figures the difference would amount about to about 10% of the
gross floorspace.
14. The increase in habitable floorspace from the PD loft conversion would be
proportionately less than the additional volume of the dormer but conversely
the hipped roofs of parts of the proposal would result in a proportionately
greater volume than floorspace. Neither the Council nor the appellant has
calculated the volume of the proposal as compared with the possible PD
alternative. In my view volume is a better quantitative determinant of the
effect of a proposal on openness than floorspace and I consider that in this
respect the effect of the proposal and the fall-back on openness would be
broadly similar.
15. The house is set back from the road and it is partly screened on all sides by
trees and hedges. The upper part of the ground floor, the first floor and roof at
the front of the house can be seen above the fence from the adjacent footpath
and the first floor and roof are glimpsed from the road. The additional bulk
arising from the first-floor side extensions and front extension would be seen
from the front and their effect on openness would be apparent. The front
extension and north side extension would also be seen from the site entrance.
The end of the rear dormer included in the fall-back would be visible from the
Appeal Decision APP/G2245/D/17/3187933
4
site entrance but it would be much less bulky than the front and side
extensions. The site entrance would also allow views of the single-storey rear
extensions; the depth of the fall-back extension would be apparent beyond the
existing rear extension but the appeal proposal, being closer to the entrance
would appear bulkier and more prominent.
16. The appeal proposal would be less extensive than the single-storey extensions
that could potentially result from a PD alternative; however, when compared
with the appeal proposal, I consider that the use of the term “sprawling” to
describe the fall-back is an overstatement. I consider that whilst the overall
volume and floorspace of the proposal would be broadly equivalent to the fall-
back the bulk of the appeal proposal would be more prominently positioned and
would have a greater effect on the perception of openness than the fall-back.
17. The officer report refers to a planning statement that accompanied the
application in which the appellant indicates that the PD alternative would have
practical shortcomings and that it would not meet the needs and aspirations of
the appellant to provide first floor accommodation. I do not have a copy of that
statement; however the appellant’s appeal document indicates that if the fall-
back is the only way of achieving the additional accommodation the benefits to
him and his family would outweigh the inconveniences.
18. The appellant points out that if permission is granted it would be possible to
impose a planning condition removing PD rights for any further extensions or
outbuildings which safeguard the site from additional PD buildings. The list of
conditions submitted by the Council incudes a condition (condition 2) that
would have that effect.
19. Such a condition would only come into effect once the permission has been
implemented. Therefore it would not prevent the implementation of permitted
development rights before the development was commenced. This could only
be achieved by means of a planning obligation in which the appellant covenants
to forgo relevant permitted development rights immediately upon the issue of
the planning permission. The Council draws attention to this in its appeal
documents but the appellant makes no comment and no planning obligation
has been made. Therefore the proposal before me has no mechanism for
preventing the implementation of the fall-back development or part of it in
advance of the appeal proposal.
Green Belt balance
Extensions
20. I have concluded that the house extensions would be inappropriate
development in the Green Belt and that they would detract from openness. The
potential fall-back alternative, through the conversion of the loft, would create
more floorspace. Whilst the volumes of the two alternatives would be broadly
similar I consider that the massing of the additional volume arising from the
appeal proposal would result in a greater perception of loss of openness as
compared with the fall-back. I give some weight to the design of the proposal
which by integrating the existing flat-roofed side additions is to be preferred to
the PD fall-back. The removal of the garden shed would result in a small
increase in openness but I gave this limited weight.
Appeal Decision APP/G2245/D/17/3187933
5
21. I have had regard to the other considerations raised by the appellant and I find
that the fall-back would be less harmful to the perceived openness of the Green
Belt but would be of a poorer design. Taking account of the importance of
openness in the Green Belt the benefit of the better design of the proposal
would be outweighed by the harm to perceived openness.
22. The submission of the planning application and the making of this appeal is
evidence enough to demonstrate that the appeal proposal is the appellant’s
preferred option for providing additional space for his extended family. The
appellant has reservations about the fall-back and there is no certainty that he
would carry it out. The decision as to whether to proceed on the basis of the
fall-back would be a matter for the appellant but I have no reason to conclude
that he would not.
23. The fall-back would give the appellant the opportunity to create more
floorspace than the appeal proposal but this is moderated by the more harmful
effect of the appeal proposal on openness. When balancing the material
considerations I give moderate weight to the potential to extend the house as
indicated by the appellant and the ability to impose a condition removing post-
development “PD rights”. However these considerations are not sufficient
clearly to overcome the substantial weight to given to any harm to the Green
Belt as indicated in the Framework. I therefore find that very special
circumstances do not exist.
24. In the absence of very special circumstances inappropriate development is not
justified. The proposal would conflict with Policy GB1 of the Allocations and
Development Management Plan 2015 and with the Policy for Green Belts set
out in the Framework.
The garage
25. The garage would not be inappropriate development. It would be situated on
an area of lawn which supports a number of conifers next to a high close-
boarded boundary fence. Beyond the fence is a margin of low bushes alongside
the public footpath that leads to a local wildlife site. The County Council
Ecological advice service indicates that the proposal would have no significant
impacts upon the local wildlife so long as there no would be no additional
lighting, appropriate buffer zones and protective measures. The Kent Wildlife
Trust indicates concern that the garage could damage trees along the eastern
boundary of the property.
26. I saw at my site visit that the main body of the wildlife site lies to the east of
the footpath and to the south of the site. The only trees affected by the garage
would be the conifers within the appeal site and I consider that the
construction of the garage, within the bounds of the appeal site, would have no
adverse effect on the ecological value of the wildlife site. I therefore consider
that an approved construction method statement as indicated in the Council’s
list of conditions is unnecessary. The appeal site is not currently subject to any
control over external lighting and any lighting attached to the garage would
most likely be directed away from the wildlife site towards the house. I
consider that in these circumstances control over lighting associated with the
garage is unnecessary.
Appeal Decision APP/G2245/D/17/3187933
6
Conclusions
27. I have concluded that the proposed house extensions would be inappropriate
development in the Green Belt and that they would detract from openness. I
have concluded that the other considerations set out by the appellant in
support of the proposal do not clearly outweigh the harm to the Green Belt due
to inappropriateness and the effect on openness and that very special
circumstances necessary to justify the granting of permission do not exist. I
therefore conclude that as regards the extensions the appeal should not
succeed.
28. I have concluded that as regards the garage the appeal should succeed. I have
therefore granted permission subject to the normal conditions governing
commencement and identifying the approved drawings. In order to ensure a
satisfactory appearance I have imposed a condition requiring that the external
materials of the garage should match those of the house.
Clive Tokley
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.