Extend house to the south to provide additional living and bed spaces
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Character & Appearance
Residential Amenity
Open Space
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 19 December 2017
by G P Jones BSc (Hons) MA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 8 January 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/B1225/D/17/3187351
10 Northport Drive, Wareham, Dorset BH20 4DR
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs A Elcombe against the decision of Purbeck District
Council.
The application Ref 6/2017/0435, dated 2 August 2017, was refused by notice dated 29
September 2017.
The development proposed is extend house to the south to provide additional living and
bed spaces.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed
Procedural matter
2. I have used in the banner heading the description of development as provided
on the application form even though this differs from that given on the
Council’s decision notice.
Main Issues
3. The main issues are:
the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of the area; and
the effect of the proposal on the living conditions of the occupiers of no. 42
Northport Drive.
Reasons
Character and appearance
4. The appeal property lies in a prominent location on the southern end of an
‘island’ of bungalows that are sited on an area of higher ground within the
overall street scene. Although there are a variety of architectural styles within
the area, this island of bungalows comprises dwellings that are generally of a
simple and restrained design and this forms a distinct characteristic within the
immediate vicinity of the appeal site. The appeal property occupies a
reasonably spacious corner plot and is oriented with its ridge line running
perpendicular to the bungalows immediately to the north, comprising nos. 12
to 18. In addition, the appeal property differs in design from these bungalows
to the north, which have a high degree of similarity in terms of their design,
scale and massing. Although the proposed extension would be two storeys in
Appeal Decision APP/B1225/D/17/3187351
2
height, with a lower ground floor, due to the topography of the site the ridge
line of the extension would sit below that of the existing building.
5. The existing end elevation of the appeal property comprises the main pitched
roof of the bungalow with an attached conservatory that has a monopitch roof
and a brick outer elevation. This has given rise to a southern end elevation
that in effect appears as a one and a half pitched roof and is to a degree
incongruous within the surrounding street scene and does not relate well to the
roof form of the rest of the appeal dwelling. This has been remarked upon in
the consultation response from the South West Design Review Panel and I
concur with the views of the Panel in this regard. Therefore the proposed
extension would provide an overall improvement to the appearance of the
south-west elevation, although this would be tempered by the provision of a
large dormer window that would appear incongruous.
6. However, the extended dwelling would be sited in an elevated and prominent
location, when viewed from the south-west, and would create a significantly
larger property than the bungalows to the north and in particular to no. 42 that
lies adjacent to the east. The proposal would extend the building line well
beyond the front elevation of no. 42 and thus would appear over-dominant in
relation to this other dwelling. Also, the extended appeal property would
occupy much of the existing open space of the corner plot and thus would
detract from the spacious setting of the junction with the road. The extended
dwelling would be at odds with the nearby dwellings that are better
proportioned in terms of the amount of open space surrounding each of the
buildings. In addition, the extension would not be stepped in from the front
elevation and thus would reinforce the overall sense of scale and mass of the
building rather than appearing as a subordinate extension.
7. Furthermore, I consider that the installation of a boundary wall along part of
the western and all of the south-western boundaries, and a boundary fence of
up to 1.8m in height between nos. 10 and 42, would be out of keeping with
what is generally an open plan estate. However, I have not been presented
with any substantive evidence that a wall and fence could not be erected under
permitted development rights and this therefore reduces the weight that I
attach to this consideration.
8. Overall I consider that by virtue of its large scale, positioning and somewhat
complicated design the extended dwelling would give rise to a building that
would appear overly-dominant within the street scene and thereby would be
detrimentally out of keeping with the overall character and appearance of the
area. As such the proposal would be contrary to paragraphs 17, 56, 57 and 58
of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework), Policy D of the
Purbeck Local Plan Part 1 (LP1), adopted November 2012, and the Purbeck
District Design Guide Supplementary Planning Document (SPD), adopted
January 2014, particularly paragraphs 18, 20, 105, 106. This policy, SPD and
guidance require that new development is of a high quality design that relates
in scale and form to neighbouring buildings and positively integrates with its
surroundings.
Living conditions
9. The detached bungalow of no. 42 Northport Drive abuts the south-eastern
boundary of the appeal property. The window of no. 42 closest to the rear of
the appeal property serves a reasonably small bedroom and is the only window
Appeal Decision APP/B1225/D/17/3187351
3
serving this room. Further to the south-east is the main living room of no. 42.
This is a dual aspect room that is served by a large window on the front
elevation and also a clear glazed door to the rear.
10. The existing south-western end elevation of the appeal property is currently in
line with the frontage of no. 42. The proposed extension would bring the
building line significantly further to the south-west, well beyond the front
elevation of the adjacent detached bungalow of no. 42 and close to the front
bedroom of this property. In addition no. 42 is set down in relation to the
appeal property and this would further exacerbate the overbearing effect of the
proposed extension on this dwelling.
11. In addition, it would be close to the bedroom window and thus would reduce
the levels of daylight and at times sunlight enjoyed in this room. I have not
been presented with a sunlight and daylight assessment to conclusively
demonstrate that the proposal would be acceptable in this regard. Therefore
whilst I consider that the proposal would be unacceptable in relation to the
front bedroom, the impact on light received in the living room of no. 42 would
be acceptable.
12. Due to the scale of the proposed extension, the distance and positioning
between the two properties, the relationship in terms of ground levels and the
layout of no. 42 it is my view that the proposed extension would give rise to an
unacceptable effect on the living conditions enjoyed by the occupiers of no. 42
in terms of appearing overbearing and loss of light. The appellant has referred
to the potential to erect a 2m high fence along the common boundary with no.
42. However, even if such a fence were to be erected it would be a different
feature and smaller in scale overall than the proposal that is before me and
therefore I accord it very little weight.
13. As such the proposal would be contrary to paragraph 17 of the Framework, LP1
Policy D and paragraphs 33 and 39 of the SPD. Taken together, this guidance,
SPD and Policy seek, among other things, to ensure that development avoids
overshadowing, is not overbearing and positively integrates with its
surroundings and secures a good standard of amenity for all existing and future
occupants of land and buildings.
Planning balance and conclusion
14. The proposed extension would provide future-proofed additional living space,
obscure the existing end elevation and would entail a limited boost to the local
economy through the construction work required. However, I consider that the
proposal would be of a scale and design that would have an unacceptable effect
on the character and appearance of the area and it would give rise to a
significant detrimental effect on the living conditions enjoyed by the occupiers
of no. 42.
15. I attach considerable weight to these impacts that I have identified and which
would significantly and demonstrably outweigh the limited benefits. For these
reasons, and having regard to all other matters raised, I conclude the appeal
should be dismissed.
GP Jones
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.