Loft conversion including construction of a rear dormer window (including outrigger) and two front rooflights
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 6 February 2018
by J D Westbrook BSc(hons) MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 16 February 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/E5330/D/17/3187204
1 Mauritius Road, London, SE10 0EH
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr Justin Dean against the decision of the Council of the Royal
Borough of Greenwich.
The application Ref 16/4014/F, dated 2 December 2016, was refused by notice dated
11 August 2017.
The development proposed is described as a loft conversion including construction of a
rear dormer window (including outrigger) and two front rooflights.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matter
2. Applications have been made simultaneously for similar developments at both
Nos 1 and 3 Mauritius Road. Both have been refused by the Council and both
are the subject of an appeal which I have before me. I therefore have access
to the details of both proposals and I have taken into account the potential for
both to be constructed. I have dealt with each case on its individual merits but
have noted the relationship between the two proposals and the properties
concerned.
Main Issues
3. The main issues in this case are the effects of the proposed dormers on:
The character and appearance of the area around Mauritius Road, and
The living conditions of the occupiers of No 3 Mauritius Road by way of
privacy and outlook.
Reasons
4. No 1 is a two-storey, end-terraced house, situated on a corner plot on the
south side of Mauritius Road, at its junction with Christchurch Way. Mauritius
Road largely comprises terraced houses of similar design, although the appeal
property has been more recently re-built following war damage. It therefore
has a different window pattern and certain different design features from the
other houses on the road, though it reflects certain other key elements of their
design, such as the roof line and a rear outrigger with a mono-pitch roof.
Appeal Decision APP/E5330/D/17/3187204
2
5. The proposed development would involve the conversion of the loft to living
space. This would entail the construction of a mansard roof to replace the
mono-pitch of the existing outrigger, and a further mansard roof on the
existing rear roof slope. There would be dormer windows projecting from each
of the mansard roof elements, and a new window in the rear elevation at
second floor level. The overall roof ridge would be increased in height by
around 110mm, and the side elevation at the rear of the house increased by
around 750mm. There would also be two rooflights inserted into the front roof
slope. There are no objections from the Council to the rooflights, and I concur
with this perspective.
Character and appearance
6. The proposed development would be prominent in the view from Chichester
Way. Whilst the increase in height of the ridge and side elevation would not be
great, the overall impact would be to increase the bulk of the rear outrigger,
such that, when viewed from the side and rear, it would give the appearance of
a three-storey house having a largely flat roof with dormer windows. Policy
DH(a) of the Council’s Local Plan: Core Strategy (LP) indicates that “Flat roofs
will not be accepted on side or rear extensions when they would be visible
from the public highway”. It goes on to note that “All new roof extensions
should be designed to respect the scale and character of the host building,
the street scene and the surrounding area”.
7. The Council’s Residential Extensions, Basements and Conversions Guidance
(SPD) adds to this policy by indicating that in achieving adequate headroom,
the new form of a roof could give a house a top heavy look, damaging the
character of the house and the street. In addition it notes that mansard roofs
will only be appropriate where they are already part of the character of the
street scene or where they would not be harmful to the appearance of the
house.
8. In this case, the proposal would effectively create a flat roof to the
outrigger that would be highly visible from Chichester Way, albeit with a
70 degree mansard slope to the east side facing away from the road.
Moreover, it would appear out of scale and character with the existing
house and with the houses further along Mauritius Road, by virtue of
creating a bulky second-floor element that would lose the mono-pitch
element to the outrigger. The rear outrigger would be some 750mm higher
than existing and would become a dominant feature, creating a top heavy
appearance to the house. Finally, mansard roofs are not part of the
character of the street scene, and the proposed roof alterations would
appear out of place in the view along the backs of the houses on the road.
9. The appellant refers to a Certificate of Lawful Development for an L-shaped
rear dormer at No 43 Mauritius Road. However, this relates to a loft
conversion that meets permitted development criteria and which is some
distance from No 1. I accept that there is a fallback position at the appeal
property with regard to permitted development rights, but these rights do
not include any increase in height over that of the existing roof. At the time
of my visit, there was no evidence of rear dormer developments along the
street in the vicinity of the appeal property.
Appeal Decision APP/E5330/D/17/3187204
3
10. Finally, the appellant notes the existence of modern buildings in the vicinity
of the appeal site, with regard to which the appeal property would not
appear out of character. I have some sympathy with this perspective, but,
in this case, the key view runs along the backs of the houses on Mauritius
Street, and the proposal would appear significantly out of character within
this view.
11. In conclusion on this issue, therefore, I find that the proposed development
would be harmful to the character and appearance of the area around
Mauritius Street. It would, on this basis, conflict with Policies DH1 and
DH(a) of the LP, and with the SPD, which require development to positively
contribute to the improvement of the built environment and to respect the
scale and character of the host building and its surroundings.
Living conditions
12. The element of the loft conversion that would be within the extended roof
above the rear outrigger would have two windows. One of these windows
would face southwards to the rear, and the other would be in the dormer
extension within the new mansard roof. The latter would face the side
elevation of No 3 Mauritius Road.
13. The Council contends that the proposals would result in harm to the living
conditions of the occupiers of No 3 Mauritius Road by virtue of overlooking
(should the side window be clear-glazed), and by virtue of overshadowing and
an overbeating appearance caused by the increased height and bulk of the new
mansard roof. I consider that the issue of overlooking could be dealt with in
this case by way of a suitable condition relating to the use of obscure glazing
and non-opening windows. I have no details relating to the impact of the
proposed mansard roof on sunlight or daylight, but it would appear that the
only windows in the side elevation of No 3 that would be affected by the
proposals serve non-habitable rooms. However, the houses on this side of the
road have only small back gardens and the increased height and bulk of the
proposed mansard roof above the outrigger would result in a somewhat
overbearing appearance from the rear of No 3. On this basis I find that the
roof alterations would have a detrimental impact on the outlook from No 3.
14. On this issue, therefore, I find that there would be a harmful impact on the
living conditions of the occupiers of No 3 by way of outlook. It would, on this
basis, conflict with Policy DH(b) of the LP and with guidance in the SPD, both of
which require that new development should not result in unacceptable loss of
residential amenity to neighbouring properties.
Conclusion
15. I find that the proposal would result in harm to the living conditions of the
occupiers of No 3 Mauritius Road by way of outlook, and that it would be
significantly harmful to the character and appearance of the area around
Mauritius Road. Accordingly, I dismiss the appeal.
J D Westbrook
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.