Erection of detached pitched roof garage including storage and personal workshop in roof space
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Rural Impact
Character & Appearance
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 23 November 2017
by A J Mageean BA (Hons) BPl PhD MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 19th December 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/R0660/D/17/3187108
New House, Lea Forge Trout Farm, London Road, Walgherton CW5 7LF
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs R Wiggins against the decision of Cheshire East
Council.
The application Ref 17/4056N, dated 7 August 2017, was refused by notice dated
2 October 2017.
The development proposed is erection of detached pitched roof garage including storage
and personal workshop in roof space.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
2. The main issue is the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of
the Open Countryside.
Reasons
3. The appeal site is located outside of an identified settlement and is therefore
within Open Countryside. The Cheshire East Local Plan Strategy 2017 (CELP)
Policy PG 6 states that the key objective of this Policy is the preservation of the
Countryside, including its scenic qualities, and places restrictions on
development. Exceptions to this include extensions of existing dwellings where
the extension is not disproportionate to the original dwelling, and for
development that is essential for the expansion or redevelopment of an
existing business. Similarly saved Policy RES.11 of the Crewe and Nantwich
Replacement Local Plan 2011 (CNLP) states that development within the
curtilage of a dwelling should respect the setting, scale, form and materials of
the original dwelling, and that in the Open Countryside the original dwelling
must remain as the dominant element with the extension subordinate to it.
4. The Council’s Extensions and Householder Development: Supplementary
Planning Document (SPD) further details that garages or outbuildings should
not be sited forward of the existing dwelling, should be modest in size and
height and must appear subordinate or ancillary to the main dwelling (3.23).
More specifically, in the Open Countryside extensions should blend in with the
landscape rather than making a statement (3.26). Whilst the appellants
contend that the current proposal is a free standing garage rather than an
Appeal Decision APP/R0660/D/17/3187108
2
extension, as a garage extends the built form of a property the principle of
effective integration is equally applicable to such cases.
5. The appeal property is a modest dwelling located within a large irregularly
shaped plot. Extant approvals for the extension of the existing dwelling have
not yet been fully implemented. It is clear that these approvals have been
made on the basis of the Open Countryside location of this dwelling. As such I
note the conclusion of the previous appeal Inspector that as a result of these
proposals the volume of the dwelling would not be doubled and that it would
remain the dominant element1.
6. The proposed quadruple garage would have a footprint of around 14.1m by
8.1m. It would also have a first floor workshop and storage space. Whilst the
appellants state that it would be subordinate in floor area, it would nonetheless
be the same height as the main dwelling. Therefore in terms of scale this
would appear as a substantial structure in relation to the dwelling, even taking
into consideration the dwelling’s extended form. As such it would be a
disproportionate addition which would fail to achieve the required modesty of
appearance and subordinate relationship with the host dwelling.
7. These concerns would be exacerbated by the prominent location of the garage
to the north west of the host dwelling. Whilst I appreciate that the level
ground at this point may be easier to build on than elsewhere in the plot, in
this position the garage would be in front of the house and therefore
conspicuous in views from both the access lane and the rising land associated
with the public right of way to the north west. Even though there is some
vegetation around the plot this would not be sufficient to screen the garage.
The result would be an increase in the prominence of built form on this plot
which would be unduly visible within the local landscape.
8. The appellants refer to this proposed location creating a courtyard effect with
the existing buildings. However, in this location the garage would spread the
extent of built form across the site, particularly noting the presence of
structures to the east of the dwelling, the status of which is not clear. Security
concerns in relation to maintaining visibility of the access road from the main
house are also mentioned, though it does not appear that other possible
locations for a garage have been fully explored.
9. The fact that the garage has been designed to reflect the proposed finish of the
host dwelling does not overcome concerns about the size and location of this
proposal. The appellants also refer to compliance with those aspects of the
National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) which require that
planning decisions should not impose particular architectural styles, noting that
high quality and inclusive design goes beyond aesthetic considerations.
However also of relevance is the requirement at paragraph 17 that the intrinsic
character and beauty of the countryside be recognised in planning decisions.
10. Whilst I understand that the appellants wish to have space for the storage and
maintenance of boating equipment, various types of motorised garden
equipment and domestic paraphernalia, these personal rather than business
requirements do not justify such a large addition. Nor do they indicate that
this scheme represents sustainable development.
1 APP/R0660/W/16/3156174 & 3156173.
Appeal Decision APP/R0660/D/17/3187108
3
11. I accept that a garage constructed on higher ground behind the principle
elevation of the host dwelling may well be permitted development. Whilst such
locations could be more visible than that currently proposed, there would be
size restrictions on such a structure which would reduce the degree of visual
intrusion. The appellants also refer to the presence of other large properties in
the locality. However this point does not negate the fact that ancillary
structures such as this are required to be modest in height and overall size.
12. Finally, I note the appellants’ view that the Council has not worked proactively
to secure a planning approval in this case. However, this point does not
overcome the concerns identified. Nor does the suggestion of a condition
requiring that the use of the proposed garage be ancillary to the dwelling.
13. For these reasons I conclude that the proposal would have a detrimental effect
on the character and appearance of the Open Countryside. It would therefore
conflict with the relevant aspects of CELP Policy PG 6 and SE 1, CNLP saved
Policy RES.11 and the SPD which, taken together, seek to protect the character
of the Open Countryside by ensuring that new development makes a positive
contribution to its surroundings, and that ancillary buildings are not
disproportionate in relation to existing dwellings.
Conclusion
14. The proposal would not accord with the development plan taken as a whole and
there are no other material considerations to outweigh this finding. Therefore,
for the reasons given above, the appeal is dismissed.
AJ Mageean
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.