Erection of a first floor over converted garage and erection of a rear roof extension involving increasing the ridge line

📊

See the success rate & inspector analytics

Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.

Sign Up Free

Technical Issues Heatmap

Extensions
Residential Amenity
Heritage & Conservation

Inspector’s Reasoning

Appeal Decision Site visit made on 27 November 2017 by Patrick Whelan BA(Hons) Dip Arch MA MSc ARB RIBA RTPI an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government Decision date: 13th December 2017 Appeal Ref: APP/T5720/D/17/3187140 27 Westcoombe Avenue, West Wimbledon, London SW20 0RQ  The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against a refusal to grant planning permission.  The appeal is made by Nicholas Naidu against the decision of the Council of the London Borough of Merton.  The application Ref 17/P0544, dated 30 January 2017, was refused by notice dated 26 July 2017.  The development proposed is the erection of a first floor over converted garage and erection of a rear roof extension involving increasing the ridge line. Decision 1. The appeal is dismissed. Procedural Matters 2. The agent has confirmed that the appeal should proceed in the name of Mr & Mrs Murphy. For clarity and succinctness, the description of development has been taken from the Council’s decision notice. Main Issues 3. The main issues are:  whether the proposed development would preserve or enhance the character or appearance of the Westcoombe Avenue Conservation Area (CA); and,  its effect on the living conditions of the occupiers of 25 Westcoombe Avenue, with particular regard to light and outlook. Reasons The character or appearance of the CA 4. The pattern of development in the CA is distinctive for its spacious, inter-war suburban layout of pairs of 2-storey houses with enclosed, planted front gardens and long back gardens, maintaining gaps between adjoining pairs of houses. This section has a distinctive townscape of half-timbered houses with brick bases, and includes oriel windows, double-storey, half-gabled bays and hipped roofs with central chimneys. Appeal Decision APP/T5720/D/17/3187140 2 5. The closure of the remaining side gap at first floor level would create a terracing effect with the house next door, and undermine the spacious character of the CA. The eaves overhang towards the side boundary would also appear to be uncharacteristically short, at odds with the order of the townscape in this section of the CA. 6. The Council’s CA Design Guide 1995 illustrates that side extensions should be set back 1.5m from the front building line and that their ridges are set down from the main ridge, much like the extension on the other half of this pair of houses. Without the reduction in mass and prominence such a device achieves, the proposed side extension would disrupt the balance across this pair of houses. Some houses have developed right up to the side boundary and departed from the design guidance. However, there are numerous examples of more sensitive extensions which retain the overall order of form and space in the CA. The closure of the side gap and the lack of subservience of the side extension would harm the characteristic order of form in the townscape of the CA and the distinctive arrangement of its houses. 7. The roofscape of the CA is characterised by pitched roofs, with hipped ends. The flat roof form of the proposed box dormer, combined with its length, would undermine the order in the roofscape of the pair of houses. I appreciate that the main roof would be fully hipped at the front. However, the dormer would dominate the rear roofscape and would make the rear elevation appear top heavy and at odds with the townscape of the CA. Together with the truncated roof over the splayed side extension, the effect of the roof development would be to diminish the spaciousness above eaves level which is a characteristic of the skyline in the CA. 8. I have taken into account the plot arrangement of the neighbouring houses and the prominence of the side elevation of No 25. However, the stepping-back of an extension has more to do with retaining a hierarchy of mass in the house than preventing a terracing effect, or reducing the apparent mass of a neighbouring building. Far from being a missing tooth, the remaining gap to No 25 reflects what is an intrinsic element of the spatial character of the CA. Filling it completely would bring no visual benefit, but effectively change two pairs of houses into a terrace of four, thereby undermining the spatial character of the CA. 9. For the reasons set out above, the proposed development would harm the character of the host building and fail to preserve the appearance of the CA in accordance with the requirements of section 72(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990, as amended, the special attention to which, the Courts have determined, I am required to give considerable importance and weight. 10. It would be in conflict with policies 7.4, 7.6, 7.8 of the London Plan 2017 (LP), policy CS14 of the Core Strategy 2011, and policies DMD3 and DMD4 of the Sites and Policies Plan 2014 (SPP). Together, these require development to preserve or enhance the significance of a heritage asset, to respect the space between buildings, and to ensure dormers respect the surrounding context without dominating the roof profile. 11. The development would be at odds too with paragraphs 58 and 132 of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework). These advise that developments should respond to local character, and that when considering the Appeal Decision APP/T5720/D/17/3187140 3 impact of development on the significance of a designated heritage asset, great weight should be given to the asset’s conservation. While in the context of paragraphs 133 and 134 of the Framework I would, in relation to the CA as a whole, define the magnitude of the harm identified as less than substantial, there is no public benefit from the proposal sufficient to outweigh that harm. Living conditions of the occupiers of 25 Westcoombe Avenue 12. I have taken into account that the footprints of the houses stagger at this end of the street, and that the side extension would be splayed. However, it would project substantially beyond the rear wall of No 25, and at such proximity would result in a visually intrusive structure in the outlook of the occupiers of the first floor and ground floor rooms which are served by windows in the adjacent wall. Notwithstanding the splay of the proposed side extension, as a result of its height and proximity to the side boundary, it would have an overbearing sense of enclosure on the occupiers of No 25 when in the adjacent section of their garden, which incorporates a raised terrace with a sitting-out area. 13. Being to the south of No 25, the development may reduce these neighbours’ access to sunlight and daylight and introduce some overshadowing. However, given the form of the side extension and the displacement of the rear dormer, as well as the size of the garden at No 25, the degree of overshadowing and any loss of light would not be harmful. While the development would introduce additional rear windows, any additional overlooking would be no more than is commonly accepted between the suburban back gardens of adjoining houses, and not harmful. 14. I conclude on this issue that the proposed development would result in an unacceptable loss of outlook to the occupiers of 25 Westcoombe Avenue. It would be in conflict with LP policy 7.6, SPP policy DMD2 and one of the core planning principles of the Framework, which protect the amenity of the existing occupants of buildings. Conclusion 15. I have paid special attention to the desirability of preserving or enhancing the character or appearance of the CA as required by the Act, and considered the policies in the Development Plan and the Framework. I have also considered the additional living space which the proposed development would provide, and the other matters raised in evidence. However, none of these outweigh the harm that I have identified to the appearance of the CA and to the living conditions of the occupiers of 25 Westcoombe Avenue, for which reasons the appeal is dismissed. Patrick Whelan INSPECTOR
Expert Representation

Don't leave your appeal to chance.

Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.

Get Free Review How it works →