Erection of a new second floor within a mansard roof

📊

See the success rate & inspector analytics

Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.

Sign Up Free

Technical Issues Heatmap

Heritage & Conservation
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance

Inspector’s Reasoning

Appeal Decision Site visit made on 23 January 2018 by Graham M Garnham BA BPhil MRTPI an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State Decision date: 30 January 2018 Appeal Ref: APP/X5990/D/17/3186471 9 Chapel Side, London, W2 4LG  The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against a refusal to grant planning permission.  The appeal is made by Mr L Quinn against the decision of City of Westminster Council.  The application Ref 17/03030/FULL, dated 6 April 2017, was refused by notice dated 19 July 2017.  The development proposed is erection of a new second floor within a mansard roof. Decision 1. The appeal is dismissed. Procedural Matters 2. The drawings used as the basis for the local planning authority’s decision are listed on its decision notice. In his Statement, the appellant says that the angle of the proposed mansard roof was intended to “be identical to the 1989 appeal scheme” (page 17). I understand this to refer to an appeal, copied with his Statement, dated 1987, Ref T/APP/X5990/A/87/067771/P4. The appellant has made minor amendments on drawings 0554-A-2901 rev B and 2903 rev B, to that effect, and asked that I determine the appeal using them. The local planning authority has not objected. 3. I consider that the amendments would slightly reduce the volume of the roof, without increasing its width or height. Consequently, the interests of third parties to the rear and in Chapel Side would not be prejudiced by me taking these drawings into account. 4. The 1987 appeal decision, referenced above, is said by the appellant to be an important material consideration in favour of the proposal. The Council counters that it is not material and should be given no weight. In my view, the weight to be given varies according to the issue under consideration. As a result, I deal with its implications with respect to each main issue. Main Issues 5. I consider that these are the effects of the proposal on firstly, the character and appearance of the building and the Bayswater Conservation Area; and secondly, the living conditions of the occupiers of no.26 Chapel Side, with regard to outlook and privacy. Appeal Decision APP/X5990/D/17/3186471 2 Reasons 6. The property in question is a dwelling house, apparently vacant. It is small, with two floors of accommodation; of single aspect; and shares a rear party wall with much taller residential development fronting Palace Court. The replacement of a shallow pitched roof with a mansard form would provide an additional bedroom and bathroom. The works would also include extensive remodelling of the front elevation. The Council says they are not particularly appropriate, but also not considered as a reason for refusal in their own right. 7. The Council gave planning permission for a basement beneath the footprint of the building in 2016. The appellant’s Planning Design and Access Statement says that this scheme and the appeal proposal are “mutually exclusive” of each other. His Appeal Statement says the permission “has been implemented” (paragraph 1.8), but is not considered to have any relevance for the appeal. First main issue – effect on character and appearance 8. Chapel Side is a narrow cul-de-sac running in a roughly southerly direction from its access off Moscow Road. It is within the Bayswater Conservation Area, a large area of mainly residential 19th century development. I consider that its significance includes relative uniformity in grandness of scale and appearance, the use of stucco in the Italianate style, and a regular street layout. There are many mews across the area, with more modest buildings. I concur with the Conservation Area Audit (adopted as Supplementary Planning Guidance in 2000) that “these are absolutely essential to the character of the overall development. They offer a contrast of scale and style and at the same time are quiet havens from the bustle of the surrounding busy roads” (op cit, page 3). 9. Chapel Side is not named as a “Mews”. Nonetheless it was described by the 1987 Inspector as “a narrow but attractive mews cul-de-sac”. The appellant has not challenged the Council’s description of it as “a characterful cobbled narrow mews”, and has described his property as “a two-storey mid-terrace mews house”. A more recent Inspector afforded the terrace some historical significance as part of the visual record of development of the conservation area, and noted that the terrace had retained much of its original character (Ref APP/X5990/A/09/2093761 & APP/X5990/E/09/2093770, decision dated 28 April 2009). I agree with these descriptions. I consider that the heritage significance of the appeal site includes its contribution to the historic character and appearance of the short terrace of which it is part, and its role as an important and long-established part of a quiet side road that shares many of the qualities of the mews that are such a valued part of the conservation area. 10. The present facade of no.9 contains relatively modern windows and an off- centre front door. It is not clear from the brickwork how far this arrangement is original. The proposal to create a symmetrical arrangement around a central door, with vertically oriented windows with brick arch soldier details, would reflect such details on the similar houses either side. However, I consider that the introduction of a third, central first floor window, and in particular the added mansard roof with three windows, would significantly alter both the appearance and character of the building. Rather than remaining as a small scale, modest mid-Victorian dwelling, it would suggest an aspiration towards a somewhat grander town house, notwithstanding its very shallow depth. The added height and bulk of the roof would be accentuated by the high party wall Appeal Decision APP/X5990/D/17/3186471 3 up-stands, that adjoining no.8 being particularly prominent in the street scene, approaching from the main road. 11. I consider that this effect would not be materially mitigated by the reduced angle of slope in the roof (paragraphs 2 & 3 above). Any gain from aligning the parapet with no.10 would be negated by taking it out of alignment with no.8. The house definitely needs sensitive refurbishment, but I find that the present proposal would, on balance, have a negative effect on its historic significance and contribution to the conservation area. 12. I could not see from the highway if works to excavate the basement had started (paragraph 7 above). The appellant has not offered any formal commitment not to implement the basement scheme. If I was to allow the proposed roof extension, both consents would run with the property, and could be implemented. The change in character to a significantly enlarged house would be compounded, albeit that the basement would be unlikely to affect the building’s appearance in the street scene. 13. My findings on the heritage issue differ from those of the 1987 Inspector. At that time, the Council did not object to an identical scheme on grounds of character and appearance: the sole main issue concerned living conditions. The Inspector accepted the appellant’s view that the scheme would be “a considerable improvement” to the front elevation which, in his view, would contribute to the enhancement of the conservation area. However, he did not set out the significant qualities of the conservation area and, while mentioning the District Plan, he did not detail any relevant policies in it. Current good practice normally takes a different approach to both these important matters. In addition, the decisions of both the previous Inspectors referred to predate the National Planning Policy Framework, which contains important policy on how to approach decisions in a conservation area. Thus I can give only limited weight to the approach taken in 1987 to addressing heritage interests. 14. The harm I have identified would rate as “less than substantial” in the terms of paragraph 134 of the Framework. As a result, it should be weighed against the public benefits of the proposal. This is not a matter explicitly addressed by the main parties, but it is a necessary part of my reasoning. The principal public benefit that occurs to me is bringing the property back into a productive use within the local housing market. However, I am not persuaded that this proposal is either the only or the best way of achieving this, in heritage terms. Consequently, I find that such benefit as I could identify would not overcome the great weight that is to be given to the conservation of heritage assets (paragraph 132 of the Framework). The assets here are a combination of the property itself, its central role in the terrace and its mews-type setting in the wider conservation area, as I have set out in paragraphs 8 – 11 above. 15. Overall and on balance, I conclude that the proposal would detract significantly from the character and appearance of the building, and would fail to preserve or enhance the heritage qualities and significance of the Bayswater Conservation Area. It would thereby fall short of several development plan policies that seek to achieve exemplary standards of design that will upgrade sensitively the historic environment; maintain the character, scale and other qualities of historic mews; and be in character with the building in question. These policies are Policies S25 and S28 in the Westminster City Plan (2016); Appeal Decision APP/X5990/D/17/3186471 4 and Policies DES 6, DES 9 & DES 1 in the City of Westminster Unitary Development Plan (2007) [UDP], and supporting text. Second main issue – effect on living conditions 16. The Council’s objection is the effect on the occupiers of no.26 opposite, but local residents nearby and to the rear have also objected. I was able to view the appeal site from within no.26, which also gave me better sight of the rear of no.24 Palace Court. 17. No.26 is one of a group of four 3-storey houses which, according to the 1987 Inspector, “were built in the last 10 years” (i.e., after 1977). The top floor is set back over an open terrace, which looks over and down upon the appeal site. I estimate that this terrace, and the rooms leading onto it, would be above the level of the mansard roof and overlook its windows. Windows on the first floor at no.26 would be roughly level with the new upper floor windows at the appeal site. There would clearly be an effect on outlook and privacy. However, in this respect, I agree with the 1987 Inspector that the impact on no.26 and adjoining properties would not be significantly harmful, bearing in mind the special character of a mews, which is typically narrower than a modern street and has front elevations only quite short distances apart. 18. The rear of the appeal sites abuts the rear of 24 Palace Court, which is a very substantial mansion block with accommodation over many floors. The closest openings appear to be of an open stair case, while the pattern of external pipework suggests that the nearest windows are not to habitable rooms as usually understood. There are other windows below the height of no.9, mainly to the south west of it and further away. In this relationship, I consider that the proposal would not materially harm living conditions in these apartments, by virtue of loss of daylight, sunlight or outlook. Concerns about loss of privacy and security have not been backed up with a clear description as to how this could come about, given the absence of any rear openings in the new roof. Thus I consider that the living conditions of residents in Palace Court would not be materially harmed. 19. I conclude that the proposal would not give rise to material harm to the living conditions of the occupiers of no.26 Chapel Side, with regard to outlook and privacy, or to other residents nearby. There would be no conflict with City Plan Policy S29 or UDP Policy ENV 13 which, among other things, seek to secure a healthy and safe environment and avoid a significant increase in the sense of enclosure or overlooking. Overall conclusion 20. Overall I conclude that the lack of harm with respect to living conditions would not outweigh the significant harm to heritage assets, to which great weight is to be given. 21. Therefore on balance, planning permission should be withheld, and I dismiss the appeal. G Garnham INSPECTOR
Expert Representation

Don't leave your appeal to chance.

Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.

Get Free Review How it works →