Two storey side extension; shed /hot tub building, raised from granted permitted development; swimming pool and decking raised in level from granted permitted development
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Extensions
Flood Risk
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 13 March 2018
by Rory MacLeod BA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 27 March 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/Z3635/D/17/3186267
Willowhayne, Pharaoh’s Island, Shepperton TW17 9LN
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr Andrew Martin against the decision of Spelthorne Borough
Council.
The application Ref 17/00813/HOU, dated 31 May 2017, was refused by notice dated
26 July 2017.
The development proposed is two storey side extension; shed /hot tub building, raised
from granted permitted development; swimming pool and decking raised in level from
granted permitted development.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues are (a) whether the proposal would constitute inappropriate
development in the Green Belt, (b) the effect of the proposal on the openness
of the Green Belt, (c) the effect of the proposal on the character and
appearance of the area, (d) the effect of the proposal on flood risk
management and (e) if it is inappropriate development, whether the harm by
reason of inappropriateness, and any other harm, is clearly outweighed by
other considerations, so as to amount to the very special circumstances
necessary to justify the development.
Reasons
3. The appeal relates to a detached house on the northern side of Pharoah’s
Island within the River Thames. The house is set in a relatively wide plot within
a residential area which is a designated Plotlands Area. The site is located in
the Green Belt and Flood Zone 3b.
4. The proposal is to construct a two storey extension on the eastern side of the
house within the wide side garden to this side. To the rear of this there would
be a swimming pool set within a raised terrace and alongside this an
outbuilding comprising a hot tub and pool changing area. The swimming pool
and outbuilding formed part of a recently approved application for a certificate
of lawfulness (ref. 16/01977/CPD), but would be raised to a higher level within
the appeal proposal.
Appeal Decision APP/Z3635/D/17/3186267
2
Whether inappropriate development
5. The National Planning Policy Framework (The Framework) at paragraph 89
states that the construction of new buildings in the Green Belt should be
regarded as inappropriate development unless it accords with cited exceptions.
One of these is “the extension or alteration of a building provided that it does
not result in disproportionate additions over and above the size of the original
building”. According to the appellant’s figures, the area of the existing house is
71 sqm and the area of the proposed extension would be 69 sqm. The
outbuilding would be located about 5 metres from the extension and would
result in an additional 40 sqm of floor area. The extension would occupy
virtually the same footprint as the house and together with the outbuilding
would result in a significant addition to overall floor area.
6. The Framework refers to “size” and so it is necessary to also consider the
massing of the development. The extension would have a shallow pitched
ridged roof some 11m in length and 6.94m high; its height would be almost the
same as that of the existing dwelling at 7.14m according to the submitted
plans. The outbuilding would be single storey but with a relatively high ridged
roof at 4.38m on the plans due to the raising of the building above ground
level. In respect of massing, the extension and outbuilding would result in
substantial additions.
7. Policy GB1 of the Spelthorne Local Plan (2001) Saved Policies and Proposals
(2007) (LP) is a general policy opposing development that would conflict with
the purposes of the Green Belt. It pre-dates the Framework and does not list
all exceptions to inappropriate development set out at paragraph 89, but has a
similar provision in relation to extensions enabling “limited extension, alteration
or replacement of existing dwellings” to be approved. Policy EN2 of the LP
requires the extension of dwellings in the Green Belt to not significantly change
the scale of the original building, regardless of the size of the plot.
8. In my judgement the increases in both floor area and massing compared to the
original building would result in disproportionate additions over and above the
size of the original building in relation to the Framework. The increases would
be more than limited in scale in relation to policies GB1 and EN2. The proposal
would therefore amount to inappropriate development. Paragraph 87 of The
Framework affirms that inappropriate development is by definition harmful to
the Green Belt and should not be approved except in very special
circumstances.
Openness
9. The Framework states at paragraph 79 that “the fundamental aim of Green Belt
policy is to prevent urban sprawl by keeping land permanently open”. The
extension and outbuilding would result in a substantial increase in built mass at
the site. The submitted plans indicate that two outbuildings have recently been
demolished to the western side of the dwelling. Even if an allowance is made
for these there would still be a significant increase in built mass arising from
the proposal. Having regard to its height and length, the extension would be a
prominent feature when viewed from the communal garden to the rear of the
site and from the north bank of the river. Overall, my findings are that the
proposal would have a harmful effect on the openness of the Green Belt. There
would also be conflict with policy GB1 that seeks to maintain the openness of
the Green Belt.
Appeal Decision APP/Z3635/D/17/3186267
3
Character and appearance
10. Pharaoh’s Island is a designated Plotland Area with a distinctive character of
modestly sized, single storey buildings with low profile roofs. Willowhayne is
unusual in that it was built with two storeys and with a different design
approach to typical Plotland dwellings. The external materials and fenestration
for the proposed extension would be sympathetic to the design of the original
building but the extension would be of a scale disproportionate to that of the
existing dwelling. The enlarged house would also be significantly wider and
higher than Isis and Nada the adjacent dwellings and compared to other
plotland dwellings nearby.
11. The appellant has referred to other two storey dwellings on the island that
depart from the predominant plotland character. I noticed the two storey
dwelling Sphinx visible from the site at the time of my visit, but this is in a
relatively isolated position at the tip of the island. By contrast, the proposal
would be perceived in association with the much smaller plotland houses
alongside. There would remain gaps to the side boundaries greater than on
most nearby plotland dwellings, as Willowhayne occupies a particularly wide
site, but the proposal would still appear as an incongruous and overly dominant
structure by reason of its size. The proposal would thereby have a harmful
effect on the character and appearance of the area.
12. It would conflict with policy EN2 of the LP which in relation to Plotland Areas
requires extensions to be compatible in size with traditional plotland dwellings
and with the scale of adjoining properties. There would also be conflict with
policy EN1 of the LP that requires proposals to make a positive impact upon the
street scene in which they are situated, paying due regard to the scale, height,
and proportions, and with the Council’s Supplementary Planning Document on
design that requires two storey side extensions to not exceed two-thirds of the
width of the host dwelling.
Flooding
13. The site is within Flood Zone 3b, the highest graded zone, where there is a
greater than 1:20 chance of flooding. The zone serves as a functional floodplain
in areas of fast moving water. The Council’s records indicate that in the most
recent floods in 2014, the island was inundated with very fast flowing water
along the alignment of the river channel and across the island.
14. The extension and outbuilding would both be raised above ground level to allow
the flow and storage of flood water. The appellant has indicated that these
would be built above the heights recommended for Flood Zone 3b in 2016. A
flood risk assessment has been submitted but this does not include details of
flood levels or of flood proofing or resilience techniques as recommended by
the Environment Agency.
15. Policy LO1 of the LP seeks to reduce flood risk by various measures including
by “maintaining flood storage capacity within Flood Zone 3 by refusing any
form of development on undeveloped sites which reduces flood storage
capacity or impedes the flow of flood water”, and by “maintaining the
effectiveness of the more frequently flooded area (Zone 3b) of the floodplain to
both store water and allow the movement of fast flowing water by not
permitting any additional development including extensions”. Notwithstanding
the raising of floor levels, the proposal would introduce significant areas of new
Appeal Decision APP/Z3635/D/17/3186267
4
buildings within Flood Zone 3b that would have an adverse effect on flood risk
management and which would conflict with policy LO1.
Other considerations
16. The appellant has presented a permitted development fallback position in
relation to the certificate of lawfulness granted by the Council (ref.
16/01977/CPD). This relates to a single storey extension to both sides of the
dwelling, a single storey rear extension, dormer windows and the erection of 3
outbuildings. The appellant has calculated the total area of the lawful
development to be 224 sqm as opposed to 144 sqm for the appeal proposal. In
relation to the impact on the Green Belt, the lawful development would have a
much greater floor area, but the elements would all be single storey. The
appellant contends that the mass of the two storey extension would have a
lesser impact on the openness of the Green Belt as the site is on a bend in the
river and the building is seen for a far greater time in side elevation from the
towpath than from a “square on” front elevation. I have not been provided with
comparative volume calculations for the lawful development and the proposal
but it is my judgement that the height, mass and visibility of the proposed two
storey side extension would have a greater impact on the openness of the
Green Belt than the single storey extensions, outbuildings and dormers.
17. In relation to flooding, the lawful development includes a greater area of
buildings at ground floor level than the appeal proposal, potentially reducing
the site’s capability in relation to the flow and storage of flood water. The
raised height of the proposed two storey side extension and outbuilding would
address this issue to some degree and would be a significantly better
alternative. The appellant has indicated intent to proceed with the lawful
development should the appeal be dismissed. I consider that there is a high
probability that some or all of these works would take place in these
circumstances. Having regard to this probability and to the effect of the lawful
development on the Green Belt and on flood risk management, I attach
significant weight to the lawful development fallback.
Conclusion
18. The proposal would be inappropriate development in the Green Belt. There
would be loss of openness particularly in relation to the bulk of the two storey
side extension. The Framework establishes that substantial weight should be
given to any harm to the Green Belt. In addition the proposal would result in
harm to the character and appearance of the surrounding area and to flood risk
management. I attach additional weight to these factors.
19. On the other hand, I have given significant weight to the lawful development as
a permitted development fallback position. But this consideration does not
clearly outweigh the totality of the harm arising from the proposal.
Consequently, very special circumstances to justify the approval of
inappropriate development do not exist. The proposal would also conflict with
relevant development plan policies in relation to the Green Belt.
20. I have taken into account the representations on the proposal including a letter
of support, but this does not lead me to a different conclusion. I have no
reason to disagree with the Council’s findings that there would not be a
material impact on the living conditions of the occupiers of adjacent dwellings.
Appeal Decision APP/Z3635/D/17/3186267
5
21. For the reasons set out above, and having regard to all matters raised, my
conclusion is that the appeal should be dismissed.
Rory MacLeod
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.