Side and rear 2 storey extension to provide better bedroom and living space
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Rural Impact
Character & Appearance
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 23 November 2017
by A J Mageean BA (Hons) BPl PhD MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 3rd January 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/R0660/D/17/3185433
114 Broad Lane, Stapeley CW5 7QW
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr Theobald against the decision of Cheshire East Council.
The application Ref 17/2471N, dated 8 May 2017, was refused by notice dated
13 July 2017.
The development proposed is side and rear 2 storey extension to provide better
bedroom and living space.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matters
2. Following the Council’s decision in this case the Cheshire East Local Plan (CELP)
2017 has been adopted. However, the emerging plan is referred to in the
Council’s reason for refusal, and as the policies seeking to protect the Open
Countryside and relating to design matters remain similar, neither party has
been prejudiced by this change in policy circumstances.
3. Whilst the Council’s reason for refusal and officer report refer to Policy PG 5 of
the CELP, it appears that the correct reference is Policy PG 6.
Main Issue
4. The main issue is the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of
the Open Countryside.
Reasons
5. The appeal property is a semi-detached dwelling located within the area
designated as Open Countryside. Saved Policy RES.11 of the Crewe and
Nantwich Replacement Local Plan 2011 (CNLP) states that in the Open
Countryside the original dwelling must remain as the dominant element with the
extension subordinate to it. Specifically the supporting text to this Policy states
that the extension must not result in the creation of a dwelling that is double or
more than double the size of the original dwelling. Similarly CELP Policy PG 6
relates to the protection of the Open Countryside, and restrictions are placed on
development. Exceptions to this include extensions to existing dwellings where
the extension is not disproportionate to the original dwelling.
Appeal Decision APP/R0660/D/17/3185433
2
6. The Council also makes reference to CELP Policies SD.2 and SE.1 which require
the design of new development to contribute positively to local character,
identity and sense of place. Whilst the emerging Stapeley & Batherton
Neighbourhood Plan (emerging NP) is not yet adopted and therefore does not
carry the same status as the adopted development plan, Policy GS 6 of this
document is consistent with the above policies in requiring design in Open
Countryside locations to enhance the character and appearance of the existing
building and surrounding area.
7. In the present case the original dwelling has already been substantially
extended with a two storey addition to the side of what was originally a small
‘two up two down’ cottage. This increase has more than doubled the size of the
original dwelling. I do accept, however, that as this extension has for the most
part respected the simple design characteristics of the cottage, continuing the
roof form and basic window details, it retains some element of its original
character. As Broad Lane is a through-route with limited pavement, this
property is most often viewed by passing vehicles and as such the south east
approach is the most common view of this dwelling for passers-by. In this view
the modest gable profile of this property, with its plain appearance and
chimney, has been retained. In this respect the existing extension does not
appear disproportionate.
8. The proposed two storey addition would further extend the frontage of the
dwelling. It would also extend out to the rear above the existing single storey
element, with the creation of a rear facing gable. Additionally there would be
first floor windows in the side elevation and the external view of the chimney
breast would be lost. Taken together, the impact of these additions would be to
significantly erode what remains of the character and appearance of the original
cottage. I accept that when viewed directly from the front the extended
property would retain the scale of a terraced row of farmworkers cottages, and
that in this view the dwelling, along with its semi-detached partner, would
retain something of a traditional appearance. As such the unbalancing of this
pair would not in itself cause unacceptable harm.
9. However, of specific concern would be the alteration to the modest appearance
of the south eastern view of the side elevation, in which the rear facing gable
would be visible from the lane. This would be extended from just below the full
ridge height of the main roof adding uncharacteristic bulk to this profile. Whilst
there is some vegetation screening this view, at the time of my site visit when
the deciduous trees were without leaf, there was clear visibility of this elevation.
10.In reaching this view I have noted that the partner cottage has been
considerably extended, including a substantial rear addition which is clearly
visible to those travelling from the north west along the lane. I also note that in
the Council’s officer report relating to the present case it is suggested that a
rear extension would be less harmful than that presently proposed. However, I
am not aware of the full circumstances of the extension to the adjoining
cottage. Furthermore, I must judge the present scheme on the basis of the
policy currently in place and the scheme before me.
11.Similarly I have noted the variety of extensions to properties further along
Broad Lane, to the north west of the appeal site. These demonstrate a variety
of design approaches, and I accept that in some cases their original character
may be difficult to decipher. However, it remains that in accordance with the
Appeal Decision APP/R0660/D/17/3185433
3
National Planning Policy Framework and the local design policies identified
above, it is important to seek high quality design that responds to local
character and context.
12.I have some sympathy with the fact that the proposals seek to improve the
standard of accommodation for the appellant’s young family, noting that the
height in the bedrooms is restricted by the low pitch of the roof and low eaves,
and that the scheme proposed seeks to increase the size of existing rooms
rather than add significantly to their number. However such considerations do
not override the conflict with policy, nor would the use of locally sourced
materials, or the fact that the Parish Council have not objected to this scheme.
13.For these reasons I conclude that the proposal would have a detrimental effect
on the character and appearance of the Open Countryside. As such it would
conflict with CNLP saved Policy RES.11 and CELP Policy PG 6 in relation to the
restrictions on development in the Open Countryside. It would also conflict with
CELP Policies SD.2 and SE.1, and the emerging NP Policy GS 6, which together
require a high standard of design which responds to local character.
Conclusion
14.The proposal would not accord with the development plan taken as a whole and
there are no other material considerations to outweigh this finding. So, for the
reasons given above, the appeal is dismissed.
AJ Mageean
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.