Demolition of existing garage and construction of new ancillary 1½ storey detached building
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Enforcement
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 31 October 2017
by Mark Dakeyne BA (Hons) MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 15 November 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/R0660/D/17/3184831
Astle Hall, Holmes Chapel Road, Chelford, Cheshire SK11 9AQ
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr Christopher Caunce against the decision of Cheshire East
Council.
The application Ref 17/1814M, dated 24 March 2017, was refused by notice dated
28 June 2017.
The development proposed is demolition of existing garage and construction of new
ancillary 1½ storey detached building.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues are:
(1) whether the proposal would be inappropriate development in the Green Belt
having regard to the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) and
any relevant development plan policies;
(2) the effect on the character and appearance of the area; and,
(3) if the development is inappropriate would the harm by reason of
inappropriateness and any other harm be clearly outweighed by other
considerations so as to amount to the very special circumstances required to
justify the development.
Reasons
Inappropriate development
3. The appeal property lies within the Green Belt. Paragraph 89 of the Framework
states that the construction of new buildings in the Green Belt should be
regarded as inappropriate development unless it is one of six specified
exceptions. The detached building would be close to the main dwelling and
would represent a normal domestic adjunct to it. Therefore, although
outbuildings are not specifically referred to in paragraph 89, the proposal
should be considered as an extension to the dwelling. Thus, the exception that
needs to be considered in this case is ‘the extension or alteration of a building
provided that it does not result in disproportionate additions over and above
the size of the original building’.
4. Astle Hall has been previously extended with single and two storey additions
built in the 1990’s and a recently constructed orangery. Although the new
Appeal Decision APP/R0660/D/17/3184831
2
building would replace a three bay garage and would be of similar height, it
would have a larger footprint and volume than the existing. Taken together
with previous works the proposal would result in disproportionate additions
over and above the size of the original building.
5. The building would be cut into the ground as it slopes away from the house
which would reduce its apparent bulk. The building would not be readily visible
from Holmes Chapel Road or Peover Lane due to intervening buildings and
vegetation and the lie of the land. However, despite its limited visual impact,
the proposal would increase the quantum of development on the site and lead
to some loss of Green Belt openness.
6. Having regard to the above I conclude that the building would represent a
disproportionate extension over and above the size of the original building and
as a result would constitute inappropriate development in the Green Belt
having regard to the Framework.
7. Policy GC12 of the Macclesfield Borough Local Plan (MBLP) indicates that
domestic buildings in the curtilage may be treated as an exception to the 30%
floorspace limitation on extensions included in the policy. However, I note that
the policy applies to the countryside generally and not just the Green Belt. No
such exception exists within Policy PG 3 of the Cheshire East Local Plan
Strategy 2010-2030 (adopted 27 July 2017) (CELPS) which is specific to the
Green Belt and reflects the terms of the Framework. Therefore, Policy PG 3
should be given full weight whereas Policy GC12 and by association Policy GC1
are less consistent with the Framework and should carry reduced weight.
Character and appearance
8. The design of the building and its materials would reflect that of the existing
house. The building would be sited within the confines of the formal garden
and would benefit from natural screening within and around the periphery of
the garden. Its scale would not be out of context with the existing hall and
other buildings within the group. As a result the building would not materially
detract from the historic parkland surrounding the building group or the rural
character and appearance of the area.
9. Accordingly the effect on the character and appearance of the area would be
acceptable and there would be compliance with Policies BE2 and DC2 of the
MBLP and Policies SD 2, SE 1 and SE 7 of the CELPS as the proposal would not
adversely affect the historic fabric, would respect the architectural features of
the building and would be of a design sensitive to the nearby heritage assets.
Other considerations
10. A lawful development certificate (LDC) was issued in September 2017 for a
detached building to form a games room and swimming pool. This building is
shown on the plans accompanying the application for the LDC as lying to the
north of the hall, a short distance to the east of the existing three bay garage.
11. Based on the evidence before me it would be possible to build both the
proposal before me and the outbuilding subject to the LDC. There is no
suggestion that the LDC would be given up. Moreover, no binding mechanism
such as a legal undertaking is in place to ‘revoke’ the LDC. A condition could
not be used to prevent a legally authorised development being implemented.
As a result if the appeal was allowed both the LDC scheme and the current
Appeal Decision APP/R0660/D/17/3184831
3
proposal could be carried out. In combination the buildings would lead to a
greater quantum of buildings on the site. Therefore, I only give the existence
of the LDC, described by the appellant as a ‘fallback position’, limited weight.
12. The other appeal decisions referred to by the appellant do not appear to be
directly comparable with the proposal before me and so carry limited weight.
The case in Denton1 related to a new dwelling in the Green Belt where there
was the realistic fallback position of planning permission for a dwelling. In
relation to the Guildford case2 there is no indication that previous extensions
had been added to the ‘original building’ formed by amalgamated cottages.
13. The appeal site lies within the outer zone of the Jodrell Bank operational area
where the cumulative impact of development can lead to increased interference
with the operation of the telescope. However, the building would be used for
purposes ancillary to the existing house rather than as a separate dwelling and
would replace another ancillary building. Therefore, there would be unlikely to
be a material increase in activity on the overall site of the type that would lead
to more interference. As a result no conflict with Policy GC14 of the MBLP and
Policy SE 14 of the CELPS would arise.
Conclusions
14. The Framework indicates that inappropriate development is, by definition,
harmful to the Green Belt and should not be approved except in very special
circumstances. Substantial weight should be given to the harm to the Green
Belt. Very special circumstances will not exist unless the harm to the Green
Belt and any other harm are clearly outweighed by other considerations.
I have not found any other material harm. The effect on the character and
appearance of the area is a neutral consideration.
15. The limited weights that I give to both the fallback position and the other
appeal decisions would not clearly outweigh the substantial weight to be given
to Green Belt harm by reason of inappropriate development. Therefore, the
very special circumstances necessary to justify the development have not been
demonstrated. There would be conflict with Policy PG 3 of the CELPS as a
result
16. For the above reasons the appeal should be dismissed.
Mark Dakeyne
INSPECTOR
1 Appeal decision ref: APP/G4240/W/15/3081724 dated 23 November 2015
2 Appeal decision ref: APP/Y3615/D/14/2229440 dated 26 January 2015
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.