Erection of a first floor rear extension to add an additional bedroom; new front porch and door and alterations to fenestration including new roof lights

📊

See the success rate & inspector analytics

Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.

Sign Up Free

Technical Issues Heatmap

Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Extensions

Inspector’s Reasoning

Appeal Decision Site visit made on 6 December 2017 by John Dowsett MA DipURP DipUD MRTPI an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government Decision date: 22nd January 2018 Appeal Ref: APP/L5810/D/17/3183335 4 Blue Anchor Alley, Richmond TW9 2PJ  The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against a refusal to grant planning permission.  The appeal is made by Ms Dawn Menear against the decision of the Council of the London Borough of Richmond-upon-Thames.  The application Ref: 17/2168/HOT, dated 31 May 2017, was refused by notice dated 20 July 2017.  The development proposed is the erection of a first floor rear extension to add an additional bedroom; new front porch and door and alterations to fenestration including new roof lights. Decision 1. The appeal is dismissed. Procedural matter 2. The description of the proposal used by the Council on the decision notice more accurately sets out the development proposed and I note that the appellant has also adopted this on the appeal form. I have, therefore, used this for the purposes of the appeal. Main Issue 3. The main issue in this appeal is the effect of the proposed development on the character and appearance of the existing building and that of the Kew Foot Road Conservation Area. Reasons 4. The planning application proposed a first floor rear extension and the Council’s objections are limited to the effect that this extension would have. The application also included proposals for a new canopy supported by gallows brackets over the front doorway, replacement of the front door itself, the replacement of the first floor window on the front elevation with a new sash window, and the insertion of a roof light into each of the front and rear roof slopes. I note that the Council have not raised any particular objection to these elements of the proposal, and from what I have read and from what I saw when I visited the site, I have no reason to reach a different conclusion with regard to these. Appeal Decision APP/L5810/D/17/3183335 2 5. Taken together, Policy CP7 of the Richmond on Thames Core Strategy 2009 (Core Strategy) and Policy DM DC1 of the Richmond on Thames Development Management Policies 2011 (DMP) seek to protect buildings and areas of recognised historic interest from inappropriate development, expect new development to recognise local character, and for new development to be based on an understanding of the sites context and character, including the character of the particular street. DMP Policy DM HD1 seeks to preserve or enhance conservation areas. Policy DM HD3 expects Buildings of Townscape Merit to be protected and that alterations to them should be based on an accurate understanding of the building’s significance, and to respect the architectural character of the original building. Further advice on Buildings of Townscape Merit is set out in the Council’s Buildings of Townscape Merit Supplementary Planning Document adopted in May 2015 (the SPD). This sets out that the Council will endeavour to protect the character and setting of all Buildings of Townscape Merit through negotiation of a sympathetic scheme, as far as possible treating proposals for works to or close to them as if they were listed buildings. 6. Reference is also made in the reason for refusal to Policies LP1, LP3 and LP4 of the emerging local plan. As these emerging policies have not yet been adopted and thus may still be subject to change, I give only very limited weight to them. 7. Section 72 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 requires that in making decisions on planning applications and appeals within a Conservation Area, special attention is paid to the desirability of preserving or enhancing the character and appearance of the area. In addition, Paragraph 132 of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) requires when considering the impact of a proposed development on the significance of a designated heritage asset, great weight should be given to the asset’s conservation. Paragraph 135 of the Framework states that the effect of an application on the significance of a non-designated heritage asset should be taken into account in determining an application and requires that a balanced judgement be undertaken, having regard to the scale of any harm and the significance of the heritage asset. 8. The appeal building is a small, traditionally constructed, two storey, house located on a narrow pedestrian walkway linking Kew Road to Lower Mortlake Road. From the evidence, this was originally one half of a pair of semi- detached houses, however, as a result of subsequent development on Blue Anchor Alley it now reads as part of a short terrace of buildings, although the neighbouring property at New House is separated from the appeal building by a narrow gap. The building line of this group of buildings is staggered with numbers 4 and 5 sitting forward of the neighbouring properties. The appeal building has previously been extended to the rear with a ground floor extension which is mirrored by a similar extension on number 5. 9. The appeal building lies within the Kew Foot Road Conservation Area and is locally listed as a Building of Townscape Merit and, as such, is in its own right a non-designated heritage asset. The appellant’s Heritage Statement included in the evidence identifies that Blue Anchor Alley contributes to the significance of the conservation area as it retains some of the former rural character and village scale of the area before it was heavily urbanised and provides a contrast to the grander buildings on Kew Road. The Heritage Statement also identifies Appeal Decision APP/L5810/D/17/3183335 3 that the appeal building was one of the earliest buildings on Blue Anchor Alley, when it started to change from a pathway to a residential street, and provided the scale and form for the buildings that followed alongside and opposite. 10. The proposed rear extension would be a flat roofed projection at first floor level extending approximately 1.6 metres from the main rear wall and would have a width of approximately 3.3 metres. Numbers 4 and 5 Blue Anchor Alley are set forward of the properties to either side resulting in a recessed rear section to the group which forms a visually pleasing architectural composition. The proposed extension would align with the rear elevation of new house and partly infill this recess disrupting the current symmetry of the group. The flat roof of the proposed extension, whilst not breaking the eaves line of the main house, would result in a sharp contrast with the roof planes of the hipped roofs of the main house and its neighbours and would not sit comfortably alongside them. 11. Although extension in itself is relatively modest in size, the main house is not large and has a narrow plan. The extension would occupy a significant proportion of the first floor rear elevation of building. The proposed extension would also result in the loss of the original arched window head over the first floor rear window. Whilst the proposed window in the end elevation of the extension is of similar proportions to the original window, as the extension does not cover the full plan width of the house, the position of the window relative to the end wall and its corresponding window on the rear wall of number five would be altered. As a result, in combination with the earlier ground floor extension, much of the original architectural character of rear elevation of the building would be lost. The resulting increase in size of the appeal building as a result of the existing and proposed extensions would be harmful to its identified significance as a building which established the scale and form of the other dwellings on the street. 12. I accept that there would be no views of the extension from the public highway, nonetheless the interior of the perimeter block is still within conservation area and townscape is not solely limited to elements visible in the public domain. When I visited the site I saw that there would be some views of the rear of the group from the rear gardens of neighbouring properties and from the rear of dwellings on Kew Road. There would also be some views from the communal open space area to the rear of the appeal building in the interior of the block although these would be partly screened by trees. 13. I have noted the previous Inspectors decision1 in respect of earlier proposals for a first floor rear extension and that the current proposal has been amended to no longer break through the eaves of the house. However, the current proposal would affect the symmetry of the group of buildings and the original house. Although the policies cited in the reason for refusal do not specifically require that symmetry be retained in group of buildings, the previous Inspector found that this would not justify a proposed rear extension that would be visually detrimental to the character and appearance of the existing property and the overall terrace. I would concur with this conclusion. 14. Whilst the appellant considers that the key difference in favour of the current proposal is that the eaves line of the main house is no longer being broken, the massing of building and group is an equally important factor. The appellant suggests that the symmetry in the group is fortuitous rather than designed. 1 Appeal references APP/L5810/D/16/3166352 and APP/L5810/D/16/3166354 Appeal Decision APP/L5810/D/17/3183335 4 However, the appellant’s Heritage Statement notes that New House was added to the group in 1980’s. The design features of this building and the similarities to number 6 and 7 Blue Anchor Alley suggests that the siting of this house was a conscious design decision that has resulted in the present built form of the group. 15. A number of previous appeal decisions have been brought to my attention by the appellant. I do not have the full details of these and so cannot be certain that the circumstances are the same as the case before me. I note that in the main these decisions pre-date the adoption of the Framework and Council’s SPD. I have had regard to the points highlighted in these but, due to the different policy context, give only limited weight to them. 16. My attention has also been drawn to a recent planning decision at 5 Lower Mortlake Road. I was able to see this property when I visited the site and the works had been completed. I accept that this is a much more visible location that the appeal site, however, it is also a very different scheme to the appeal proposal. The existing building was much larger than the appeal building and the extensions have been designed in a manner that integrates the new elements with the older fabric of the building. Within this context, I do not consider it is analogous to the case before me. 17. When I visited the site I also saw the extensions to the rear of the Café Matthiae that are referred to by the appellant. Whilst these are indeed large, they are attached to a building which is itself of a larger scale and which adjoins similar, larger scale, buildings. These have a different character and scale from the group of buildings that incorporate the appeal building. 18. Although the conservation of Buildings of Townscape Merit should not be conflated with the high level of protection that is afforded to statutory Listed Buildings, the Planning Practice Guidance notes that non-designated heritage assets have a degree of significance meriting consideration in planning decisions and that only a minority of buildings have enough heritage interest for their significance to be a material consideration in the planning process. Within this context it is necessary to apply a greater weight to the conservation of Buildings of Townscape Merit than to other buildings, particularly those located within conservation areas. 19. I find that the appeal proposal would cause harm to the character and appearance of the existing building and the conservation area and hence to their significance. Due to the relative lack of visibility of the appeal proposal, this would be limited to a relatively small area and, as such, would amount to less than substantial harm. Where a development proposal would lead to less than substantial harm to the significance of a designated heritage asset Paragraph 134 of the Framework requires that this harm should be weighed against the public benefits of the proposal. Paragraph 135 also requires that in respect of non-designated heritage assets a balanced judgement is undertaken having regard to the scale of any harm and the significance of the heritage asset. 20. The appellant has not identified any public benefits from the appeal proposal. The appeal building is a small house and I saw when I visited the site that its current internal configuration has open staircase in the centre of the ground floor space and that there is downstairs bathroom with the bedrooms on the first floor. The appeal proposal would allow for internal reconfiguration of the Appeal Decision APP/L5810/D/17/3183335 5 house to reposition the staircase to a less awkward location and relocate the bathroom to the first floor creating a larger, more uniform, space at ground level. In this case the benefit would be to the living conditions of the occupiers of the appeal property and would be a primarily private benefit. Indirectly, the appeal proposal may assist in securing the longer term use of the building as a dwelling by providing a more convenient form of internal accommodation and an additional, three bedroom, dwelling in the housing stock. There is, however, no substantive evidence before me that in its current configuration the building has a restricted lifespan as a dwelling or that there are no alternative solutions to reconfigure the interior. As such I give only limited weight to the benefits of the proposal. 21. Given these limited benefits, and taking into account the great weight that the Framework requires to be given to the conservation of heritage assets, I consider that the benefits do not outweigh the harm that would be caused by the proposed development. 22. I conclude that the proposed development would cause harm to the character and appearance of the existing building and that of the Kew Foot Road Conservation Area. It would be contrary to the relevant requirements of Policy CP7 of the Core Strategy and Policies DM DC1, DM HD1 and DM HD3 of the DMP. Conclusion 23. For the above reasons, and having regard to all other matters raised, I therefore conclude that the appeal should be dismissed. John Dowsett INSPECTOR
Expert Representation

Don't leave your appeal to chance.

Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.

Get Free Review How it works →