Erection of a fence and automatic sliding gate to the front boundary of the property
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Highways & Transport
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 4 December 2017
by Alexander Walker MPlan MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 19 December 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/J1535/D/17/3183211
The Edge, 7 Ongar Road, Lambourne, Romford RM4 1UB
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr James Lincoln against the decision of Epping Forest District
Council.
The application Ref PL/EPF/0322/17, dated 2 February 2017, was refused by notice
dated 8 June 2017.
The development proposed is the erection of a fence and automatic sliding gate to the
front boundary of the property.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matters
2. At the time of my site visit the proposed fence and gate had already been
erected. Therefore I have considered the proposal on the basis that it seeks
permission for the retention of the existing fence and gate.
Main Issues
3. The main issues are whether the proposal preserves or enhances the character
or appearance of the Abridge Conservation Area; the effect of the proposal on
the setting of the grade II listed building, Roding House; and, the effect of the
proposal on highway safety.
Reasons
Abridge Conservation Area
4. Section 72(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act
1990 states that special attention shall be paid to the desirability of preserving
or enhancing the character or appearance of Conservation Areas. This is
reflected in paragraph 132 of the National Planning Policy Framework (the
Framework), which states that when considering the impact of a proposed
development on the significance of a designated heritage asset, great weight
should be given to the asset’s conservation.
5. The appeal property is located within the Abridge Conservation Area (the CA).
The CA comprises a variety of building designs and styles from a range of
periods. It has a rural character to it despite the busy A113 running through
the northern part of the village. Properties along this stretch of the A113,
Ongar Road, generally have low boundary fences, walls and hedges with the
Appeal Decision APP/J1535/D/17/3183211
2
road and have open driveways. Furthermore, existing fences are typically
picket style fencing or wrought iron railings, which have a high degree of visual
permeability. Overall, the front boundary treatments make an important
positive contribution to the character of the area.
6. The appeal property is a relatively modern bungalow set back from the road.
The fence and the gate that are the subject of the appeal extend long the
boundary with the back of the adjacent footway. Both the fence and gate
comprise a vertical timber panel inset within a metal frame with a decorative
metal detail on top. I note that the boundary with No.9 Ongar Road comprises
a similar fence, although the panel closest to the footway is lower than the
remainder of the fence and gate.
7. The solid design of the fence and gate, with no visual permeability, is in marked
contrast to the prevailing open and softer boundary treatments found along this
stretch of the road. This is exacerbated by the height of the fence, which
emphasises its prominence. Whilst I note that there is a high boundary fence
and wall, including a hedge, directly opposite the appeal site, the wrought iron
railings provide a significant degree of visual permeability and the hedge
provides a softer appearance. Overall, the proposal appears incongruous in the
streetscene and significantly erodes the openness of the area. I do not consider
that painting the fence and gate would overcome this harm.
8. I find therefore that the proposal fails to preserve or enhance the character or
appearance of the CA. As such, it fails to comply with Policies HC6 and HC7 of
the Epping Forest District Local Plan (LP), which state that development should
be sympathetic to the character and appearance of the Conservation Area and
the Council will not grant planning permission for any development which could
be detrimental to the character, appearance or setting of the Conservation Area.
Listed Building
9. The appeal property is adjacent to Roding House, a grade II listed building.
Roding House is a late medieval dwelling dating back to the 16th century and
has been extended and altered since. It is situated further forward of the
prevailing building line of the neighbouring properties to the east, including the
appeal property, with the front elevation abutting the back of the footway. As a
result, the building is prominent within the streetscene.
10. Immediately to the east of the listed building, the boundary treatment with the
road comprises a low timber picket fence with trees and shrubs planted behind
it. The appeal property is approximately 20 metres from the listed building
itself. However, the fence that is the subject of this appeal adjoins the fence of
the listed building and is very much read in the context of the setting of the
listed building.
11. As a result of its height and solid design, the appeal fence and gate is very
prominent in the streetscene and dominates the boundary of the listed building.
As I have found above, the fence and gate erode the openness of the CA. For
the same reasons, it also erodes the openness of the setting of the listed
building.
12. I find therefore that the proposal would significantly harm the setting of the
listed building, contrary to Policy HC12 of the LP, which states that the Council
Appeal Decision APP/J1535/D/17/3183211
3
will not grant planning permission for development which could adversely affect
the setting of a listed building.
Highway Safety
13. Due to the height of the fence and its solid design, visibility to the west of the
existing property and neighbouring property, No.9 Ongar Road, is restricted.
Ongar Road is a busy road and there is a bend in it further to the west. I find
that the lack of visibility represents an unacceptable risk to highway safety as
drivers exiting No.9, or the appeal property, would not have clear views of
oncoming traffic to the west. I note that the existing trees and shrubs to the
west of the site already obstruct visibility to some extent. However, I do not
consider that restricting visibility even further is acceptable.
14. Furthermore, were the gate to be closed there is insufficient space between the
gate and the road to enable a car to be parked off the road whilst the gate is
opened. This would result in the car having to wait in the road whilst the gate is
opened, which would restrict the free-flow of traffic.
15. I have had regard to the appellant’s contention that a condition could be
imposed requiring the gate to remain open during the day. He argues that it
would only be closed when the he arrives home from work. However, there
may be an instance during the evening when it needs to be opened to allow
access for a car, for example if a guest or delivery was made once the gates
have been shut. This could still result in traffic waiting in the road. Overall, I
am not satisfied that this would represent a suitable form of mitigation.
16. With regard to the proposed use of a safety mirror, there is no evidence to
indicate that it would be placed on land in the appellant’s ownership, and
therefore could not be the subject of a condition. Moreover, I am not satisfied
that this would be suitable mitigation against the lack of visibility.
17. I find therefore, that the proposal represents severe harm to highway safety
and therefore is contrary to Policy ST4 of the LP, which seeks to ensure that
development will not be detrimental to highway safety.
Conclusion
18. Paragraph 134 of the Framework confirms that where a development proposal
would lead to less than substantial harm to the significance of a designated
heritage asset, this harm should be weighed against the public benefits of the
proposal, including securing its optimal viable use. I have had regard to the
appellant’s argument that the fence and gate is required as his car has been
stolen on three occasions. However, I do not consider that the need to provide
security outweighs the harm the fence and gate has to the CA or the setting of
the listed building, or indeed represents a public benefit. Whilst the harm to the
significance of the CA would be less then substantial, I do not find that there is
any public benefit identified that would outweigh this harm.
19. For the reasons given above, having regard to all matters raised, the appeal is
dismissed.
Alexander Walker
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.