Demolition of existing conservatory and erection of 2- storey side extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 11 December 2017
by V Lucas LLB MCD MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 4th January 2018.
Appeal Ref: APP/A0665/D/17/3183140
29 Ashwood Court, Chester, CH2 3FD
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr Peter Fisk against the decision of Cheshire West & Chester
Council.
The application Ref 17/01771/FUL, dated 12 March 2017, was refused by notice dated
14 June 2017.
The development proposed is demolition of existing conservatory and erection of 2-
storey side extension.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues are:
The effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of the area;
and
The effect of the proposal on the living conditions of neighbouring
occupants at 22 Chestnut Close, with particular regard to outlook.
Reasons
Character and appearance
3. No. 29 is an end of terrace dwelling that is part of a group of three. The
dwellings are two storey in height and are similar in appearance. The appeal
dwelling has a single storey element that was originally constructed as a
garage and has since been converted to living accommodation and also a side
conservatory. The dwelling at the opposite end of the group has a single
storey garage. Both the side elements at No. 29 and the dwelling on the
opposite end of the group are set back from the main front elevations of the
properties by a considerable distance. This gives the group of dwellings a neat
and well balance appearance overall.
4. The appeal property is situated on a small development of other dwellings that
appear to have been constructed at the same time. Whilst there is some
variety in the type of dwellings, such as detached and semi-detached
properties, all are constructed in similar brick, are two storey in height and
have design features such as contrasting brick underneath the window
openings and a porch roof over the front door. These elements ensure that
Appeal Decision APP/A0665/D/17/3183140
2
there is a consistency in built form and design to the appearance of dwellings in
the streetscene and this defines the character of the area. During the site visit
I did not observe any examples of two storey side extensions in close proximity
to the appeal dwelling.
5. The development proposed would see the demolition of the existing
conservatory at No. 29 and the construction of a two storey side extension.
The proposed front elevation of the dwelling would be set back slightly behind
the main front elevation. The maximum ridge height of the proposal would be
set below that of the roof of the main dwelling and a small dormer gable would
be inserted above the first floor windows on both the front and rear elevations.
The plans show that the proposal would be constructed in materials to match
those of the original dwelling.
6. The width of the proposed extension would be approximately 5.23m which
would be a substantial increase when compared with the width of the original
dwelling which is approximately 4.5m. Whilst there is some dispute between
the parties as to the exact increase in floor space as a consequence of the
proposal, the width of the appeal dwelling would double in size as a
consequence of the proposal. I acknowledge that the existing side element
already adds width to the main part of the dwelling. However due to it being
single storey in height it is not seen as unduly dominant when viewed alongside
the main dwelling. The considerable increase in width of the dwelling at first
floor level as a result of the proposal would result in a significant increase in
bulk and scale and would be seen as an unduly dominant feature in the
streetscene that would unbalance the appearance of No. 29 itself and the group
of three terraced dwellings as a whole. This would be detrimental to the
overall character and appearance of the streetscene.
7. I acknowledge that design elements such as the use of a set back from the
main front elevation, a lower roof ridge height and the use of matching
materials in the proposed extension would help to ensure that the proposal
remained visually subservient to the main dwelling. However, the harm that
would occur as a consequence of the scale of the proposal does outweigh these
other considerations.
8. Accordingly, I conclude on this main issue that the proposal would be harmful
to the character and appearance of the area. The proposal would therefore
conflict with retained policy H08 of the Chester District Local Plan (CD LP) and
the House Extensions SPD (SPD) which together seek to ensure that extension
proposals are in keeping with the scale and character of the existing dwelling;
and that extensions should be of a scale that ensures they remain subordinate
to the original dwellinghouse. The proposal would also conflict with paragraph
17 of the National Planning Policy Framework (Framework) which states that
planning should always seek to always seek to secure high quality design.
Living conditions
9. No. 22 Chestnut Close is situated at the head of a cul de sac on an adjacent to
the appeal property. The dwelling is on a corner plot and its garden is situated
to the side of the property. The side boundary of the garden runs along that of
No. 29’s. There is a fence in place with vegetation on either side of the
boundary. In the case of No. 22’s this takes the form of a neatly trimmed
hedge. There is a patio next to the side elevation of the dwelling and a seating
area immediately adjacent to the shared boundary with No. 29.
Appeal Decision APP/A0665/D/17/3183140
3
10. The side elevation of No. 29 is visible from the garden of No. 22 along with the
roof of the converted garage and side conservatory. However being single
storey in height these side elements are mostly screened from view by the
existing boundary treatment. The rear and other side boundary of No. 22’s
garden enjoy an open outlook looking towards the sky over the hedging that
lines the boundaries.
11. The proposed two storey side extension would be positioned between 1.2m and
1.8m away from the side boundary with No. 22’s garden. The side elevation of
the proposal would be approximately 4.35m and would run for approximately
8.79m along the side boundary of No. 22’s garden. Due to the height and
length of the proposal along with its proximity to the boundary, views from the
garden would be dominated by a high, brick elevation that due to its length
would give the garden a dark and gloomy feel and this would be significantly
harmful to the living conditions of that property with raged to outlook.
12. Whilst the proposal may be acceptable in terms of its effect on sunlight (due to
orientation) and privacy (as no widows are propose din the side elevation)
these considerations do not overcome the harm that I have identified.
13. Accordingly, I conclude on this main issue that the proposal would be harmful
to the living conditions of the occupants at No. 22 Chestnut Close, with
particular regard to outlook. The proposal would therefore conflict with policy
SOC5 of the Cheshire West and Chester Local Plan (Part One), policy HO8 of
the CD LP, and the SPD which together seek to ensure that development does
not give rise to significant adverse impacts on quality of life including
residential amenity, that extension proposals would not be detrimental to the
amenities of nearby existing residential properties; and that the effect upon
neighbours (including loss of outlook) shall be applied. The proposal would
also conflict with paragraph 17 of the Framework which states that planning
should always seek to secure a good standard of amenity for all existing
occupants of land and buildings.
Other Matters
14. I note the appellant’s reference to the original application for No. 29 to be
constructed having been refuse by the Council and subsequently allowed on
appeal1. However, I have determined this appeal proposal on its own merits.
For the same reason, whilst the appellant has referred to other properties in
the area that have been extended, my determination of this appeal has been
based on an assessment of the appeal dwelling itself and its close context.
15. Whilst parking and access may be acceptable, a lack of harm in these respects
is a neutral matter that does not outweigh the harm that I have identified.
Conclusion
16. For the reasons given above, I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
V Lucas
Inspector
1 T/APP/X0605/A/95/257259/P8 Decision date:1996
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.