Single storey side a rear extension to garage to create habitable annexed accommodation
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Character & Appearance
Conversion/Use
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 31 October 2017
by H Baugh-Jones BA(Hons) DipLA MA CMLI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 29 November 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/X0415/D/17/3182957
Hethercroft, Narcot Lane, Chalfont St Peter SL9 8TR
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mrs J Martindale against the decision of Chiltern District Council.
The application Ref CH/2017/1179/FA, dated 22 June 2017, was refused by notice
dated 21 August 2017.
The development proposed is single storey side a rear extension to garage to create
habitable annexed accommodation.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matters
2. The description of development given in the heading above is taken from the
appeal form and is the one used in the Council’s decision notice. I have
adopted this description as it more accurately describes the proposed
development.
3. There is dispute between the parties over whether a planning condition or a
legal agreement is required to ensure the appeal building could not be used as
a dwelling independent of the main house. I wrote to the parties in the
interests of exploring the potential use of a condition to address this matter
and refer to this in the main body of my decision below. I have also reflected it
in the main issues.
Main Issues
4. The site lies within the Green Belt. The main issues in this appeal are (i)
whether the proposal would be inappropriate development in the Green Belt
having regard to the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) and
any relevant development plan policies; (ii) whether any harm by reason of
inappropriateness including loss of openness and whether there is a suitable
mechanism for preventing the building being used as a separate dwelling and
whether there would be harm to the character and appearance of the area,
would be clearly outweighed by other considerations; and (iii) if so, would this
amount to the very special circumstances required to justify the proposal.
Appeal Decision APP/X0415/D/17/3182957
2
Reasons
Whether the proposal would be inappropriate development in the Green Belt
5. The proposal comprises the demolition of an existing timber shed attached to
the rear of a detached double width garage and its replacement with a larger
brick-built structure. The existing garage would be extended to match the
width of this building.
6. Policy GB2 of the Chiltern District Local Plan (1997 consolidated in 2007 and
2011) (LP) lists exceptions whereby development is not considered to be
inappropriate in the Green Belt. These include the limited extension or
alteration of a building in accordance with other development plan policies
including policy GB15.
7. LP Policy GB15 permits the construction or extension of non-habitable ancillary
buildings within domestic curtilages provided they are small and subordinate in
scale to the original building. Given that the proposal in part comprises a
granny annexe, I consider it would fall within the realm of providing habitable
accommodation and so would not accord with LP policy GB15 or by extension
GB2.
8. In the case of self-contained residential annexes, LP policy GB13 sets out that
they will be permitted but in most cases they should be in the form of an
extension to the exiting dwelling with internal access between the two.
However, it also provides for the permission of an annexe in a building
detached from the main dwelling where it involves the conversion of a suitable
existing outbuilding of substantial construction and modest size without the
need for significant extension or any replacement building for the outbuilding to
be converted.
9. The parties are in dispute over whether the timber shed is of ‘substantial
construction’. Therefore, the assessment of whether the proposal accords or
conflicts with LP policy GB13 depends on which side of the line the shed falls
i.e. whether is it of substantial construction or not. At my site visit, I observed
that it appeared to be of sound construction and was well attached to the
garage. It has a permanence and I am satisfied that it the shed is of
substantial construction.
10. Notwithstanding any of this, the Framework says that the construction of new
buildings is inappropriate in the Green Belt unless in accordance with specific
exceptions. The third bullet point in paragraph 89 of the Framework states that
the one of the exceptions is the extension or alteration of a building provided
that it does not result in disproportionate additions over and above the size of
the original building. The appellant has confirmed that the shed is an addition
to the rear of the garage. As such, it does not form part of the original building.
Furthermore, in my view, the degree of separation between the outbuilding and
the main house is such that it would be unreasonable to consider the proposal
as an extension to the main house.
11. The proposal would substantially increase the size of the original building,
which in my view would result in a disproportionate addition to it. I therefore
consider the proposal to be inappropriate development in the Green Belt and
thereby in conflict with Framework paragraph 89.
Appeal Decision APP/X0415/D/17/3182957
3
Openness of the Green Belt
12. I have already found that the timber shed does not form part of the original
building. However, I cannot ignore its existence and that it affects the
openness of the Green Belt in much the same way as a substantial part of the
proposed extension would. In the absence of any evidence that the shed is not
a lawful building, I have taken its existence into account in my considerations
on openness.
13. The fundamental aim of Green Belt policy is to keep land permanently open;
the essential characteristics of Green Belts are their openness and their
permanence. The proposal would demolish the shed and replace it with a
building of similar depth. Overall, the completed building would be about 1.5m
wider than the combined existing garage and shed. In my view, when taking
into account the garage and shed as a whole, this would represent a very
modest increase in the building’s overall size.
14. The appellant has stated that the proposed building would be the only ancillary
building within the site. However, at my site visit I observed an outbuilding
next to the site’s southern boundary and that two other chalet type buildings
within the property grounds. They are substantial and appear to have a
permanency about them. I consider they represent a significant spread of built
form across the site and there is nothing before me to indicate that any of
them will be removed as part of the proposal.
15. Therefore, although the appeal scheme would not in isolation have anything
more than a limited effect on openness, the overall cumulative effects when
taking into account the other buildings would result in an unacceptable
diminution on the openness of the Green Belt and the purposes of including
land within it. Thus the proposal would run counter to the Framework.
Whether there is a suitable mechanism for preventing the building being used as a
separate dwelling
16. In addition to retaining part of the outbuilding as a garage, the proposed
development would comprise a granny annexe within which the plans1 show an
open plan sitting and dining area. There would also be a bathroom
incorporating a shower and WC, with the remainder of the space within the
building providing a gym.
17. LP policy GB13 also seeks to ensure that there is a reasonable means of
preventing an annexe from being occupied as a separate dwelling unit. This is
in general accordance with the Framework given that there is no provision
within paragraph 89 for such a building in the Green Belt under any of the
exceptions listed.
18. For planning purposes, the building would fall within Use Class C32 and a
change of use from an independent residential annexe to a dwelling would not
amount to development3. With the facilities proposed and given the building’s
separation from the main house along with the potential for it to be accessed
independently, the building could be used either as an annexe or a separate
dwelling. Accordingly, given the building’s separation from the main house, it
1 Drawing No. HM/AC/17, labelled ‘Extension to Existing Outbuilding’
2 Of The Town and Country Planning (Use Classes) Order 1987
3 As set out in Section 55(2)(f) of The Town and Country Planning Act 1990
Appeal Decision APP/X0415/D/17/3182957
4
would not be sufficiently functionally tied to the main house to prevent it from
being sold off to provide a separate dwelling.
19. In considering appeals on sites in Cranbrook4 and Chesham5, the respective
Inspectors found that a planning condition would not be appropriate to prevent
the creation of a separate dwelling. I recognise that each application and
appeal should be determined on its own merits. Furthermore, I also note what
the Framework and Planning Practice Guidance say about the use of planning
conditions over planning obligations. However, I consider the circumstances in
those cases to be sufficiently similar to those in this appeal to provide a
convincing argument for the need for a legal agreement to prevent the use of
the building as a separate dwelling.
20. In addition to all of this, the appellant argues that a ‘ten-year rule’ applies in
respect of breaches of condition. However, the Courts have judged that the
local planning authority would need to take enforcement action within four
years in order to seek remedy of a breach. The implications of this are that if
the breach of the condition was not detected within the relevant period, the
Council could do nothing to prevent the building’s use as a stand-alone dwelling
after four years. To my mind, this underpins the need for a legal agreement
over the use of a condition.
21. I do not have a legal agreement before me and in its absence, the proposal
conflicts with the objectives of LP policy GB13 and the Framework.
Character and appearance
22. The western site boundary is formed by a fence next to and along which are
dotted a number of mature trees. Accordingly the existing garage/shed cannot
be seen from the road over the fence and only the upper part of the main
dwelling’s roof can be seen. There is a substantial hedgerow running along the
northern site boundary and there are no views over it into the site from the
footpath on the other side that runs parallel to it.
23. Accordingly, given that the proposed building would be only very marginally
higher in part, compared to the shed, the appeal scheme would not result in
any significant visual harm thereby being in accordance with the criteria in LP
policy GC1 aimed at promoting high standards of design. It would also accord
with policy CS20 of the Core Strategy for Chiltern District (2011) that seeks a
high quality of design which reflects and respects the character of the
surrounding area and local distinctiveness. It would also accord with the overall
objectives in the Council’s Residential Extensions and Householder
Development Supplementary Planning Document (2013).
Other considerations
24. It is not entirely clear from the available evidence whether the appellant
considers the suggested permitted development fallback position to comprise a
consideration that might weigh in favour of the proposal. However, I have
already substantively addressed this matter above. No other considerations
have been put forward by the appellant in support of the scheme.
4 Ref APP/M2270/D/17/3166923
5 APP/X0415/C/09/2119363
Appeal Decision APP/X0415/D/17/3182957
5
Conclusion
25. I have found that the proposal would constitute inappropriate development in
the Green Belt and would cumulatively adversely affect its openness. I have
also found that there is no suitable mechanism in place to prevent the
building’s use as a stand-alone dwelling. Although I have not found that the
proposal would result in harm to the area’s character and appearance, these
other harms must be given substantial weight. There are no other
considerations in this case to clearly outweigh the harm that I have identified.
Consequently, the very special circumstances necessary to justify the
development do not exist.
26. For the above reasons and having had regard to all other matters raised, the
appeal does not succeed.
Hayden Baugh-Jones
Inspector
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.