For the erection of single storey ground floor rear extension, creation of staircase for access from ground floor to garden level and walkway for access from first floor to garden. Roof alterations incorporating rear dormer, front and rear rooflights. Revised fenestration and alterations to boundary wall with other associated works
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Extensions
Residential Amenity
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 5 December 2017
by Mr C J Tivey BSc (Hons) BPl MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 14 December 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/Q1445/D/17/3180614
83 Roundhill Crescent, Brighton BN2 3GP
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr Tom Musicka against the decision of Brighton & Hove City
Council.
The application Ref BH2016/06071, dated 11 November 2016, was refused by notice
dated 15 June 2017.
The development proposed is for the erection of single storey ground floor rear
extension, creation of staircase for access from ground floor to garden level and
walkway for access from first floor to garden. Roof alterations incorporating rear
dormer, front and rear rooflights. Revised fenestration and alterations to boundary wall
with other associated works.
Decision
1. I dismiss the appeal.
Application for Costs
2. An application for costs has been made by the appellant and is the subject of a
separate decision.
Procedural Matters
3. The appellant stated that it was their belief that the drawings submitted by
them were misread or misunderstood by the Council, as no increase in the
height of the side or rear boundary walls to the garden was proposed.
Consequently the appellant has submitted two additional drawings with the
appeal, with references BS.01.1 and BS.01.2. Whilst not made explicit, it
appears that these were submitted to replace those drawings which were
determined by the Council labelled ‘Proposed_East _North _Elevations’ and
‘Proposed _South, _West, _Elevations’ respectively.
4. These latter two drawings quite clearly show an increase in the height of the
rear garden boundary treatments when compared to the existing elevations.
However, in the absence of any formal re-consultation on the revised drawings,
I consider that third parties would be prejudiced if I were to accept these as
they would not have had an opportunity to comment upon them. Therefore I
cannot accept them as revised plans to this appeal.
5. In addition the Council appear to have amended the description of proposed
works from that included within the planning application form to that which I
Appeal Decision APP/Q1445/D/17/3180614
2
have included in the banner heading above. I consider this revised description
to be more accurate and concise and therefore I have determined the appeal on
this basis.
Main Issues
6. The main issues are whether the proposal would preserve or enhance the
character or appearance of the Roundhill Conservation Area; and the effect it
would have upon the living conditions of the occupants of 81 and 85 Roundhill
Crescent, with specific reference to outlook.
Reasons
7. The appeal site is situated within the Roundhill Conservation Area which is
subject to an Article 4 (2) Direction, which amongst other things, controls
alterations of roofs fronting a highway. The appeal dwelling comprises a three
storey terraced house within a well conserved street, with largely unaltered
front and rear roof planes. There are a handful of examples where rooflights
and dormer windows have been inserted within the wider locality, although
these do not form the prevailing character of development within the locality.
Further, I have been provided with no planning history on these and in any
event, each case must be assessed on its own merits.
8. The Roundhill Conservation Area Character Statement (CACS) highlights that
the curves and contours of streets like Roundhill Crescent are especially
attractive, to which I would agree. It also highlights that the insertion of
unsympathetic dormers and other alterations carried out under Permitted
Development Rights took place prior to the year 2000 and the introduction of
the Article 4 Direction.
9. Furthermore, the Council’s Supplementary Planning Document Design Guide for
Extensions and Alterations adopted 20 June 2013 (SPD12), where concerning
roof extensions and alterations, stipulates that many streets in Brighton and
Hove are composed of uniform terraces, the rhythm and continuity of the
rooflines of which are often a key visible element within the street scene, which
I find to be the case here.
10. SPD12 states that rooflights should be located discreetly such that they are not
readily visible from the street and where a terrace within a Conservation Area
remains unaltered, rooflights on the front roof slopes will be considered
unacceptable. I found that the rear roof slope of the appeal property is also
clearly visible from Ashdown Road and in combination with the proposed front
rooflights, the rear dormer and single rooflight on the rear elevation would also
detract from the current largely unbroken roofscape along the terrace. I
therefore find that the proposal would fail to preserve the character and
appearance of the Conservation Area.
11. I accept that the proposed alterations to the rear ground floor of the appeal
dwelling are not visible from the highway and the Council raises no issue with
respect to that aspect of the proposal; I have no substantive reason to come to
a different conclusion on this. The detrimental impacts of the proposal in
respect to the cumulative number and inclusion of proposed openings,
including the dormer, are purely centred upon the works to the main roof.
Appeal Decision APP/Q1445/D/17/3180614
3
12. Notwithstanding that I accept that the proposal would improve the internal
living accommodation of no 83, I conclude that the proposal would give rise to
less than substantial harm to the significance of the designated heritage asset
and that there are no public benefits that outweigh this harm. The proposal is
contrary to Policy HE6 of the Brighton & Hove Local Plan (Retained Policies
March 2016) (BHLP) and Policy CP15 of the Brighton & Hove City Plan Part One
(2016) (BHCP) which as well as ensuring that they meet the statutory tests,
require proposals for development within Conservation Areas to show a
consistently high standard of design and detailing, and to demonstrate no
harmful impact on townscape and roofscape.
Living Conditions
13. Notwithstanding the submission of revised drawings (which I have not
accepted) with the appeal documentation, a comparison of the existing and
proposed elevational drawings quite clearly show an increase in the boundary
treatment to both sides of the garden. Whilst I understand from the appellant
that it is not their intention to do this, nonetheless, for the reasons I gave
above, I can only determine the appeal based upon the plans that were before
the Council at the time it made its decision.
14. The rear garden to 85 Roundhill Crescent is at a significantly lower level than
that of the main garden of no 83 which is terraced and much closer to first
floor level. Any increase in the existing brick wall and fence along the eastern
boundary would have a demonstrable overbearing effect that would further
reduce outlook from the rear elevation of the neighbouring property, as well as
from its conservatory and rear garden. The boundary treatment to the west
and shared with 81 Roundhill Crescent is of a similar height, although the rear
garden to that dwelling is also terraced and not dissimilar to that of the appeal
site. Therefore, I conclude that the increase in height of the boundary
treatment in that location would not materially detract from the outlook from
no 81.
15. On this matter, I therefore conclude that the proposal would result in a
significantly enclosing and overbearing impact to the occupants of 85 Roundhill
Crescent and would be contrary to BHLP Policies QD14 and QD27 which
stipulate that planning permission for any development will not be granted
where it would cause loss of amenity to adjacent residents, taking into account,
amongst other things, how overbearing a proposal will be. In addition, the
proposal also conflicts with one of the core planning principles of the
Framework which is to always seek to secure high quality design and a good
standard of amenity for all existing and future occupants of land and buildings.
Conclusion
16. For the reasons given above and having regard to all other matters raised, I
conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
C J Tivey
INSPECTOR
£
Costs decision section
Costs Decision
Site visit made on 5 December 2017
by Mr C J Tivey BSc (Hons) BPl MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 14 December 2017
Costs application in relation to Appeal Ref: APP/Q1445/D/17/3180614
Land at 83 Roundhill Crescent, Brighton BN2 3GP
The application is made under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, sections 78,
322 and Schedule 6, and the Local Government Act 1972, section 250(5).
The application is made by Mr Tom Musicka for a full award of costs against Brighton &
Hove City Council.
The appeal was against the refusal of planning permission for the erection of a single
storey ground floor rear extension, creation of staircase for access from ground floor to
garden level and walkway for access from first floor to garden. Roof alterations
incorporating rear dormer, front and rear rooflights. Revised fenestration and
alterations to boundary wall with other associated works.
Decision
1. The application for an award of costs is refused.
Reasons
2. The Planning Practice Guidance (PPG) states that parties in planning appeals
normally meet their own expenses and that all parties are expected to behave
reasonably to support an efficient and timely process. However, where a party
has behaved unreasonably, and this has directly caused another party to incur
unnecessary wasted expense in the appeal process, they may be subject to an
award of costs. The PPG states that awards against a Local Planning Authority
may be either procedural or substantive.
3. The applicant has not stated why they consider that the Council has acted
unreasonably, they have simply sought to recoup the administration costs for
the submission of their appeal. I have been given no indication that the Council
has done anything but follow due process and therefore, I consider that the
Council has not behaved unreasonably from a procedural prospective such as
to warrant an award of costs against it.
4. With regard to substantive matters, I have found within my appeal decision
that planning permission should be refused, with the proposal being contrary to
both the Development Plan and the National Planning Policy Framework, in
addition to failing to meet the statutory test in respect of preserving or
enhancing the character or appearance of Conservation Areas.
5. The Council has substantiated, with evidence, its reasons for refusal and within
its statement supported their position with respect to the proposal’s impact
upon the character of the host building and the Designated Heritage Asset, as
Appeal Decision APP/Q1445/D/17/3180614
2
well as the living conditions of the occupants of both neighbouring residential
properties.
6. I consider that the Council’s reasons for refusal were precise and therefore I
find that unreasonable behaviour, resulting in unnecessary or wasted expense,
as described in the PPG, has not been demonstrated. The application for a full
award of costs is therefore refused.
C J Tivey
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.