WC/Store extension to ex garage
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Green Belt Policy
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 22 August 2017
by Louise Nurser BA (Hons) Dip UP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 4 September 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/Z4718/D/17/3179529
56 Lumb Lane, Almondbury, Huddersfield HD4 6SZ
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr A Ellis against the decision of Kirklees Metropolitan Borough
Council.
The application Ref 2017/62/90289/W, dated 23 January 2017, was refused by notice
dated 5 June 2017.
The development proposed is WC/Store extension to ex garage.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for WC/store
extension to existing garage at 56 Lumb Lane, Almondbury, Huddersfield HD4
6SZ in accordance with the terms of the application, Ref 2017/62/90289/W,
dated 23 January 2017, and the plans submitted with it, subject to the
following conditions:
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than 3 years
from the date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance
with the following approved plans: HD4.
3) No development shall commence until samples of the materials to be
used in the construction of the external surfaces of the extension hereby
permitted have been submitted to and approved in writing by the local
planning authority. Development shall be carried out in accordance with
the approved samples.
Main Issues
2. The main issues in this case are; 1) whether the proposal would be
inappropriate development in the Green Belt having regard to the National
Planning Policy Framework and any relevant development plan policies; 2) the
effect of the proposed development on the setting of the host property and no.
54 both of which are Grade 2 listed buildings; and 3) if it is inappropriate
development, whether the harm by reason of inappropriateness, and any other
harm, is clearly outweighed by other considerations, so as to amount to the
very special circumstances necessary to justify the development.
Appeal Decision APP/Z4718/D/17/3179529
2
Reasons
Whether inappropriate development
3. The Government attaches great importance to the Green Belt. The Framework
establishes within paragraph 89 that the construction of a new building as
inappropriate unless, amongst other things, it involves the extension of a
building. However, any such extension should not result in disproportionate
additions over and above the size of the original building.
4. This is reflected in saved Policy D11 of the Kirklees Unitary Development Plan
(UDP) 2007 which remains broadly consistent with the Framework.
5. The proposed extension to the garage would measure around 2.1 m, by 2.3 m
and would be around 2.9 m high. Its ridge line would be lower, the rear
elevation would be substantially narrower, and its width would be such that
taken as a whole, the extension would appear subservient to the garage
building and would therefore not be disproportionate.
6. I note the Council’s concerns relating to the cumulative impact of the proposed
extension, together with the garage and extensions which have already been
built on the appeal site. Nonetheless, I conclude that the small scale of the
extension is such that it would not result in disproportionate development. In
coming to this conclusion, I am aware of the circumstances of the previous
appeal on the site ( APP/Z4782/W/15/3028112) where the Inspector concluded
that even if he were to judge the appeal in the context of an extension to the
host dwelling rather than as a new building, that the significant scale of
development proposed would result in a disproportionate addition over and
above the size of the original dwelling.
7. However, the proposed development, the subject of that appeal, was
significantly larger than the permitted scheme1, including the garage which has
since been built. I note that the appeal proposal, albeit it is substantially
smaller than that which has been permitted, and would not project out to the
side, is to be built of stone and therefore would appear more solid.
Nonetheless, the smaller extension would have considerably less impact than
that permitted.
8. Consequently, as I have concluded that the appeal proposal would not be
disproportionate development, it would be not inappropriate within the Green
Belt. It would therefore accord with saved Policy D11 (UDP) and the policies of
the Framework in this regard. As such, there is no need for me to consider its
impact on openness.
Setting of the listed buildings
9. The appeal site is within the setting of numbers 56 and 54 Lumb Lane which
are both Grade 2 listed buildings. Section 66 (1) of the Planning (Listed
Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 (the Act) requires the decision
maker, in considering whether to grant planning permission for development
which affects the a listed building or it setting, to have regard to the desirability
of preserving the building or its setting or any features of special architectural
or historic interest.
1 2002/90073
Appeal Decision APP/Z4718/D/17/3179529
3
10. No 56 Lumb Lane is a two storey hammer dressed stone property with a
pitched stone roof. The main elevation facing Lumb Lane is defined by a strong
horizontal emphasis derived from the stone mullioned windows at ground and
first floor level. The two properties together with the stone garage which has
been built in materials to match no 56 Lumb Lane appear as an isolated
development within the open countryside.
11. From what I observed from my site visit, at which I took the opportunity to
view the site from a number of viewpoints, including from public footpath
HUD/166/10, the impact of the small extension to the garage would be to have
no harm to the visual setting of the listed building and due to its subservient
nature not result in cumulative harm.
12. I have come to this conclusion as the appeal proposal would be minor in scale,
is of a simple form consistent with the garage and listed buildings, and would
extend no farther back than the line of the rear of the two storey extension. In
addition, the garage and two listed buildings are set behind a stone wall which
due to the difference in levels between the fields which slope up behind the
property and the small area of amenity space behind the properties, would
partially screen the small extension to the garage which is to be built of
matching materials. Therefore, whilst clearly the extension will be visible from
some viewpoints, it will not adversely visually affect the setting of the listed
buildings.
13. Consideration of impact on setting should not be restricted to whether the
proposed development can be viewed from a public vantage point or has a
visual impact. However, there is nothing before me to suggest that the minor
extension would detract from the historic significance of the listed buildings.
14. Consequently, I conclude that the proposed extension, which would be minor in
scale, would cause no harm. As such it would be consistent with the Planning
Practice Guidance2 and would not be contrary to the objectives of saved
Policies BE1 and BE2 of the UDP, which require development to be of good
quality and be respectful of its surroundings, and paragraph 132 of the
Framework.
Conditions
15.For the avoidance of doubt and in the interests of proper planning I attach a
condition clarifying the plans approved. As the proposed development is within
the setting of two listed buildings it is vital that all external facing materials
used match the existing garage and neighbouring properties. Therefore, I have
imposed a condition requiring the approval of samples prior to construction.
Conclusion
16.For the reasons given above the appeal is allowed.
L. Nurser
INSPECTOR
2 Planning Practice Guidance ID: 18a-017-20140306
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.