To replace existing Georgian timber windows in cream for ‘A’ rated UPVc windows. New windows to be Georgian to match existing windows in cream
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Trees & Landscape
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 14 August 2017
by Sarah Housden BA (Hons) BPl MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 29 August 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/D2510/D/17/3179411
Fairview, Back Lane, Old Bolingbroke, Spilsby, Lincolnshire PE23 4HB
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mrs Samantha Jacklin against the decision of East Lindsey
District Council.
The application Ref S/018/00461/17, dated 21 February 2017, was refused by notice
dated 25 May 2017.
The development proposed is ‘to replace existing Georgian timber windows in cream for
‘A’ rated UPVc windows. New windows to be Georgian to match existing windows in
cream’.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
2. The main issue in this case is whether or not the proposed development would
preserve or enhance the character or appearance of the Old Bolingbroke
Conservation Area, having particular regard to the effect on the character and
appearance of the host dwelling.
Reasons
3. In the exercise of planning functions, the statutory test set out in s72(1) of the
Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 (the Act) is that
special attention shall be paid to the desirability of preserving or enhancing the
character or appearance of Conservation Areas. Paragraph 132 of the National
Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) advises that when considering the
impact of a proposed development on the significance of a designated heritage
asset, great weight should be given to the asset’s conservation.
4. The significance of the Old Bolingbroke Conservation Area derives from the
historic pattern of development with groups of traditional properties informally
grouped around road junctions and interspersed with open spaces. The mature
trees and setting of the village within the Wolds landscape contribute to its
verdant and rural character.
5. The appeal property is a detached red brick and pantile cottage. Although it
has a later two storey extension to the rear, the property retains its traditional
form and character and makes a positive contribution to the character and
appearance of the Conservation Area. When approaching along Back Lane
from the west, the only windows visible are the first floor windows in the rear
Appeal Decision APP/D2510/D/17/3179411
2
extension with the ground floor window screened by planting on the driveway
boundary. From the east, the property is screened by vegetation along the
common boundary with the adjoining field although this will inevitably be
sparser during the winter months. Due to its position close to the road
frontage, the front elevation of the cottage is only visible from close distances.
6. The existing windows in the rear elevation of the cottage and the extension are
modern timber cream coloured replacements with ‘Georgian’ style multiple
panes separated by narrow glazing bars and fitted flush with the wall opening.
They have one small top hung and side opening casements which are fitted
flush with the window frame. Some are in poor condition with areas of rot and
decay evident.
7. I acknowledge the Council’s point that the use of timber windows would be
more sympathetic to the historic integrity of the Conservation Area and that an
Article 4 Direction is in force to enable such changes in window material to be
controlled. However, there are a number of examples where uPVC units have
been installed on properties within the Conservation Area, some within front
elevations occupying a more prominent position than the appeal property.
Whilst the presence of modern materials elsewhere does not justify
development that would be harmful to the character or appearance of the
dwelling or the Conservation Area, the proposal must be assessed in relation to
the particular circumstances of the site.
8. The proposed replacement windows would be installed within the rear and side
elevations of the dwelling which do not occupy a prominent position within the
Conservation Area. Whilst constructed of timber, the existing windows are
later replacements which already have relatively thick frames creating a non-
traditional appearance. The colour of the existing windows would be matched
and the use of uPVC as a replacement material would not be readily noticeable
from the more distant vantage points at which the windows are viewed. For
these reasons, the use of uPVC would not be harmful to the character or
appearance of the dwelling or to the significance of the Old Bolingbroke
Conservation Area. I have come to this conclusion based on the particular
circumstances of the appeal property and the proposal before me.
9. Whilst this conclusion differs from my colleague Inspector’s decision at Knights
Farm1, in that case the windows had been installed in the front elevation of the
property in a more prominent location within the Conservation Area open to
wider public view. As such, the circumstances of that site are not comparable
with the case before me.
10. However, there are a number of discrepancies in the submitted plans. The
property has a small ‘L’ shaped lean-to and porch wrapping round the rear and
side elevations which is not shown on the elevation drawings. There is a side
window in this structure which is shown on the planning application form
drawing and ‘Reflections’ sales agreement dated 28 February 2017 as being
replaced. The number and position of the windows to be replaced is not
accurately recorded to enable the proposal to be fully assessed.
11. Whilst the appellant indicates that the window casements would have a flush
fitting, the section drawing demonstrates that the casement openings would
overlap the window frame rather than fitting flush with it, creating a more
1 Appeal Ref 3130425
Appeal Decision APP/D2510/D/17/3179411
3
bulky and prominent appearance. There is, however, no substantive detail as
to the proposed design of the window frames. The appellant indicates that
they would be a ‘like for like’ replacement but there are no detailed drawings to
demonstrate that this would be so and it is not possible to establish the profile
or thickness of the frames or glazing bars compared with the existing windows.
12. There are also discrepancies between the plans in the details of the opening
arrangements of the proposed windows. The position of the opening
casements shown on the planning application drawings and the ‘Reflections’
sales agreement differ, again hindering an accurate assessment of the impact
of the proposed windows on the character and appearance of the dwelling and
Conservation Area. The opening arrangements of the proposed windows are
also different from the existing windows which have a small and discreet top
opening light. On the basis of the information submitted with the appeal, it is
not possible to conclude that the design of the proposed units would be
acceptable in respect of profile and frame thickness, fitting details and opening
arrangements.
13. I have considered whether a condition could be imposed to require further
elevation plans and details of the proposed windows to be submitted to the
local planning authority. However, the design of the proposed units is
fundamental to an assessment of whether the character or appearance of the
Old Bolingbroke Conservation Area would be preserved or enhanced and
whether or not the statutory test in relation to Conservation Areas would be
met. In these circumstances, the use of a condition would not be reasonable
and would not meet the tests for conditions set out in the Framework and the
Planning Practice Guidance.
14. The Framework requires me to accord great weight to the conservation of
designated heritage assets. Based on the evidence before me, I conclude that
the proposed replacement windows would be harmful to the character and
appearance of the host dwelling and would fail to preserve or enhance the
character or appearance of the Old Bolingbroke Conservation Area. The
proposal would be contrary to Policy C1 of the East Lindsey Local Plan
Alteration (1999) which indicates that development in Conservation Areas will
only be permitted where it preserves or enhances its special character.
15. The impact of the proposal would be relatively localised and in my view the
harm to the Conservation Area would be less than substantial. Paragraph 134
of the Framework indicates that where a proposed development would lead to
less than substantial harm to the significance of a designated heritage asset,
the harm should be weighed against the public benefits of the proposal. The
replacement windows would offer improved thermal efficiency and reduced
maintenance for the occupiers. However, these benefits are largely private
rather than public and there are no other public benefits which would outweigh
the harm that would result.
16. For the reasons outlined above and having had regard to all of the matters
raised in this case, I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
Sarah Housden
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.