Two storey side extension and first floor rear extension Decision
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Residential Amenity
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 11 September 2017
by Peter D Biggers BSc Hons MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 26 September 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/W5780/D/17/3178849
34 Nightingale Lane, Wanstead, London E11 2HE.
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against
a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Vaia Ikonomou and Alex Wing against the decision of the London
Borough of Redbridge Council.
The application Ref 1704/17 dated 11 April 2017, was refused by notice dated
7 June 2017.
The development proposed is two storey side extension and first floor rear extension
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed
Procedural Matter
2. The appellants agreed to a request from the Council following submission of the
application to amend the description of development to clarify the nature of the
proposal. Accordingly I have taken that for the purposes of the description of
development for this decision letter.
Main Issues
3. The main issues in this case are the effect of the proposed development on the
character and appearance of the host dwelling and the surrounding area of
Nightingale Lane and whether the extension would have a detrimental impact on
the living conditions of present and future occupants of No 32 Nightingale Lane
and Nos 56-62 Wellesley Road in terms of proximity and outlook.
Reasons
4. Nightingale Lane, where the appeal site is located, is a residential street comprised
of a mix of dwelling styles with bungalows on the south/south east side of the road
opposite the appeal site and predominantly 2 storey dwellings including the appeal
property on the north/north-west side of the road. The dwellings on this side of the
road, although sharing common materials of brick, render, tile and slate, are
individual in style and the appeal property in particular is unique in its design,
being smaller in scale to its neighbours and standing gable end to the road.
5. The appeal property has the benefit of permission for a substantial ground floor
rear extension which is substantially complete and the proposal would extend over
part of this rear extension at first floor level.
6. The National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) seeks a high standard of
design in all development and requires proposals to take the opportunities
available to improve the character and quality of an area. Strategic Policy 3 of the
Appeal Decision APP/W5780/D/17/3178849
2
Core Strategy Development Plan Document and policy BD1 of the Borough Wide
Primary Policies Development Plan Document (BWPP) both require a high standard
of sustainable construction. The latter also requires development to contribute to
the distinctive character and amenity of the local area and to be of a style,
massing, scale and design appropriate to the locality and is therefore consistent
with the Framework. Specifically in respect of extensions, BWPP policy BD5 seeks
to ensure extensions to existing dwellings complement the character of the
building in terms of scale, style, form and materials and do not dominate.
7. The Council has also published detailed guidance –The Householder Design Guide
Supplementary Planning Document (SPD) to ensure householder development is
appropriate to the character and appearance of the property and the surrounding
area amongst other things. The SPD at section B2 and B3 sets out the criteria for
successful side and rear extensions.
8. I have been referred to the fact that both No 32 Nightingale Lane and a number of
properties in Wellesley Road facing the appeal site have large dormer roof
extensions which the appellant considers justifies the appeal proposal. I do not
have all the details before me to determine the circumstances of these extensions
and it is possible some have been built under permitted development rights. In
any event, particularly in respect of the roof extensions to No 32, they are not
examples of design that should necessarily be used to justify the scale and design
of other extensions and I will determine the extension at No 34 on its own merits.
Character and Appearance
9. The main house at No 34 has a very traditional character and appearance and is
small and compact in scale. Whilst the flat roof contemporary style of the current
ground floor rear extension works, with the original house prominent above it, I
am not persuaded that what is proposed for the first floor extension would work in
the same way. The timber clad, flat roof form at the higher level, even though it is
set back on the current rear extension, would dominate in an unattractive way and
be out of keeping with the character and appearance of the original house. I note
that the appellants wish to use timber cladding to improve the u values for the
extension but, even if this were changed to an alternative material, the scale and
mass of the first floor extension would significantly harm the attractive appearance
and proportions of the house from the rear.
10. Whilst I accept the view from the rear would be essentially a private one, the
extension would also be clearly visible from the street. Although the appellant
states there is no view from the street this is not accurate. There is a substantial
gap between the appeal property and no 64 Wellesley Road only occupied by
garaging and garden boundary fencing to the street. Thus, approaching along
Nightingale Lane from the direction of Wellesley Road, there would be a clear view
of both the side and rear extension above the fencing and garages. The mass and
scale of the timber-clad, flat roof extension would be obtrusive and the cumulative
effect of the every short pitched roof side extension with the side of the flat roof
rear extension would look incongruous and out of keeping with the character and
appearance of the main house and the surrounding area.
11. I am not satisfied that the criteria of BWPP policies BD1 and in particular BD5
would be met. For the reasons above the roof profile and materials of the rear first
floor extension would not be sympathetic to the existing dwelling, the form of
extension proposed would dominate the building and the whole would not
complement its character. The overall effect because of its visibility from the public
realm on Nightingale Lane would also fail to be compatible with and contribute to
Appeal Decision APP/W5780/D/17/3178849
3
the character and appearance of the surrounding locality required in policy BD1.
and the Framework.
12. I have considered whether elements of the proposal could be allowed in a split
decision. The pitched roof side extension in being set back from the frontage with
a lower ridge and generally of an acceptable size and scale would appear
subordinate to the dwelling and broadly in keeping with the character and
appearance of the frontage. However it would be functionally linked to the rest of
the proposed extension by virtue of the fact that it would be reliant on the flat roof
section of the rear extension to provide the stairway access to the first floor
accommodation. It is not therefore possible to consider a split decision in this case.
Living Conditions
13. In terms of the relationship to No 32 Nightingale Lane the proposed first floor rear
extension has been designed to a scale that would not conflict with the 45o rule.
The appellant’s design and access statement demonstrates that the extension
would not extend beyond the area enclosed by a line drawn at 45o horizontally
from the centre of either the first floor rear-facing bedroom window or the ground
floor dining room window. As far as can be ascertained from the drawings before
me, the extension would also not extend above a 45o line drawn upwards from the
centre of the ground floor dining room window. In any event this ground floor
window is already screened behind tall, dense shrubbery on the boundary between
the two properties. As such I am satisfied that the extension would not materially
impact on the light to or outlook from either of these windows. I accept that there
is an upper window in the rear extension to No 32 facing toward the proposed
extension but the appellant’s statement states that this is not a window to a
habitable room. I have no evidence before me to confirm or refute this but in any
event the proposed extension would be 5 metres from this window. Although there
is a corner window in the proposed extension facing in the direction of No 32 it is
proposed to obscure glaze the side elevation and could be conditioned as such
thereby avoiding any loss of privacy.
14. In respect of the properties in Wellesley Road, the rear gable of the offshoot
extensions to these properties and closest to the proposed extension are 17
metres away. There did not appear to be windows in these gable ends at first floor
level and any ground floor windows would look towards the extension through
boundary screening. Any outlook in this direction appeared to be largely limited to
the view from the rear-facing box dormers on Wellesley Road properties which are
further away, approximately 24 metres at their closest. I accept that there would
be some impact from the proposed extension on the rear garden areas to the
adjoining Wellesley Road properties closest to the boundary. However I am not
persuaded that given the separation afforded by outbuildings to Nos 60 and 62 and
trees and shrubs close to the boundary in the gardens of Nos 56 and 58that the
impact would be so overbearing as to warrant dismissing the appeal.
15. In respect of the potential impact on living conditions both for present and future
occupants of 32 Nightingale Lane and the Wellesley Road properties therefore I do
not consider that the proposal would conflict with BWPP policies BD1 and BD5 such
as to warrant dismissing the appeal.
Other Matters
16. I understand that the appellant is seeking to make sustainable and effective use of
an existing home and optimise the potential of the site, an objective which is
Appeal Decision APP/W5780/D/17/3178849
4
encouraged by the Framework. However I am not persuaded that this social
benefit that would be derived from building the rear and side extensions would
outweigh the harm to the character and appearance of the property and the
surrounding area that would be caused if I were to allow the appeal.
Conclusions
17. Notwithstanding my conclusions in respect of the potential impact on living
conditions I conclude that the harm to the character and appearance of the host
dwelling and the surroundings of Nightingale Lane would be unacceptable.
18. I have considered the matters before me and, for the reasons given above, the
appeal should be dismissed.
P. D. Biggers
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.