1. To restore pitched roof. 2. To elongate the windows on the first floor. 3. To infill the small balcony at rear using brick and opaque glass
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 10 October 2017
by Elizabeth Lawrence BTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 18 October 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/K5600/D/17/3178430
13 Child’s Place, London, SW5 9RX
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Miss Shelley-Anne Bartlett-Claircourt against the decision of the
Council of the Royal Borough of Kensington & Chelsea.
The application Ref PP/17/01218, dated 22 February 2017, was refused by notice dated
2 May 2017.
The development proposed is 1. To restore pitched roof. 2. To elongate the windows on
the first floor. 3. To infill the small balcony at rear using brick and opaque glass.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The first main reason is the effect of the proposal on the character and
appearance of the host building and the Earl’s Court Village Conservation
Area (ECVCA). The second main issue is the effect of the scheme on the
living conditions of the occupiers of nearby properties along Walgrave Road,
with particular regard to visual impact, daylight, sunlight and privacy.
Reasons
Character and appearance
3. Much of the ECVCA is characterised by narrow streets flanked by
predominantly modest sized two and three storey Georgian and Victorian
cottages, which either front onto or are located close to the pavements.
Collectively these features contribute to the village qualities of the
conservation area. In contrast the southeast part of the ECVCA is influenced
by more substantial Italianate terraces, which dominate the roads they front
onto. Whilst predominantly residential in character there are a number of
small retail and other commercial units within the conservation area.
4. The Appeal site is located in a prominent position at the head of Child’s
Place, which is a short, narrow cul-de-sac flanked by two and three storey
Nineteenth century terraces with their roofs hidden behind parapets. At the
Appeal Decision APP/K5600/D/17/3178430
2
eastern end of the road is a small terrace of modest two storey cottages with
shallow pitched slate roofs and opposite them is a brick faced three storey
dwelling with a mansard roof. Due to its height and pitch this roof is not
characteristic of Child’s Place, however it is discreetly located within the
street scene and nestled between the taller flank walls of the adjoining
buildings on either side.
5. Along with most of the dwellings in Child’s Place the Appeal dwelling is
identified in the ECVCA Appraisal (Feb 2017) as making a positive
contribution towards the character and appearance of the ECVCA. The
Appeal dwelling sits in a prominent position at the head of the cul-de-sac
and comprises a wide attached two storey dwelling with vertical timber sash
windows, a flat roof enclosed by a parapet and a painted white finish. It is
set back from the street behind a small front garden that is enclosed by a
low painted brick wall with railings on top.
6. Section 72 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act
1990 (LB&CA Act) requires that when assessing proposals for new
development within a conservation area, special attention shall be paid to
the desirability of preserving or enhancing its character or appearance.
7. Section 12 of the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) states that
when considering the impact of a development on the significance of a
designated heritage asset great weight should be given to its conservation.
Any harm requires clear and convincing justification, whilst opportunities for
new development in conservation areas should be sought. Where a proposal
would lead to less than substantial harm to a designated heritage asset, this
harm should be weighed against the public benefits of the proposal. Policy
CL3 of the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea Consolidated Local Plan
(Local Plan) 2015, reflects and is consistent with these requirements.
8. Regarding design the NPPF and policies CL1, CL2, CL6, CL8, CL9 and CL11 of
the Local Plan collectively seek to ensure that new development adds to the
quality of the area. Development should be of the highest architectural and
urban design, respond well to its context and where possible make a positive
contribution to the Borough’s visual character and appearance. Extensions
and alterations should be subordinate to and not harm the character or
appearance of the host building or groups of buildings. Roof extensions
should be architecturally sympathetic to the age and character of the host
and adjacent buildings.
9. It is clear from the detailing around the chimney on the Appeal dwelling that
at some stage the dwelling had a low shallow pitched roof. It is noted that
the Council has stated that in principle they would not object to the
reintroduction of a shallow pitched roof and I would not disagree with this
view. However, the proposed roof would have a pitch of around 45 degrees
and would project above and around the existing chimney and above the flat
roof of the attached dwelling. It would project in excess of two metres
above the existing parapet wall.
10. As a result of these factors the proposed roof would be out of scale and
would dominate the front elevation of the Appeal dwelling, detracting from
its modest cottage proportions and appearance. It would also be out of
keeping with the prevailing character and appearance of the street scene
Appeal Decision APP/K5600/D/17/3178430
3
where roofs are largely hidden behind parapet walls or shallow pitched and
modest in height.
11. The resultant harm that would be caused to the character and appearance of
the host dwelling and the street scene could not be satisfactorily dealt with
by condition. In addition, it would outweigh the benefits for the Appellant
which would result from the proposed new roof and additional enclosed
floorspace.
12. In principle the enclosure of the small upper floor terrace would not have a
material impact on the character and appearance of the host dwelling,
subject to its design detailing. However, no details been submitted for the
elevations of the enclosed balcony area. As indicated above the proposed
roof, which includes the area over the proposed balcony enclosure, would
cause unacceptable harm to the character and appearance of the host
dwelling. Bearing in mind the location of the dwelling within a conservation
area and in close proximity to the adjacent dwellings the design of the walls
of the enclosed balcony area is not a matter that could reasonably be dealt
with by condition.
13. The proposed alterations to the front first floor windows of the dwelling
would reflect and respect the siting, design, proportions and materials of the
host dwelling and the proposed Juliet balconies would be modest in form and
appearance. They would also be in keeping with the metal railings along the
top of the front boundary wall and found elsewhere within the conservation
area. Accordingly, this aspect of the proposal would preserve the character
and appearance of the host building, the group of buildings and the
conservation area as a whole. The Council has acknowledged that this
aspect of the scheme does not require planning permission and accordingly
there is no need to consider the appropriateness of issuing a split decision in
this instance.
14. I conclude on the first main issue that the proposed roof and rear balcony
would fail to preserve the character and appearance of the host dwelling, the
group of buildings and the ECVCA. It would detract from the significance of
the ECVCA and there are no identified public benefits which would outweigh
this harm. Accordingly, the scheme would conflict with policies CL1, CL2,
CL3, CL6, CL8, CL9 & CL11 of the Local Plan and the NPPF.
Living conditions
15. Policy CL5 of the Local Plan requires all development to ensure good living
conditions for the occupiers of new, existing and neighbouring buildings.
Good standards of daylight and sunlight should be achieved, reasonable
visual privacy is provided and there should be no harmful increase in the
sense of enclosure. The NPPF seeks to ensure a good standard of living for
all residents.
16. Due to its combined height, mass and proximity to the immediately adjacent
properties the proposed new pitched roof would dominate the outlook from
their upper floor windows and balconies. This would unacceptably increase
the sense of enclosure within the rear garden environment. The situation
would be exacerbated by the associated loss of daylight and sunlight within
the rooms and balconies affected.
Appeal Decision APP/K5600/D/17/3178430
4
17. In this respect the proposal would unacceptably harm the living conditions of
the occupiers of the adjoining and adjacent dwellings.
18. With regard to privacy it is noted that there is a considerable level of inter-
looking between the dwellings and a strong sense of communal living in the
immediate area. This is due the juxtaposition and close proximity of the
dwellings, together with the incidence of upper floor balconies and
conservatories. Within this environment, in principle, the enclosure of the
proposed balcony would be readily assimilated and any direct overlooking
with the adjoining dwelling could be dealt with by the use of stained or
obscure glazing.
19. I conclude on the second main issue that whilst the proposal need not result
in a material loss of privacy, the proposed new roof would be visually
overbearing for the occupiers of the adjoining and adjacent dwellings. As
such, the scheme would conflict with policy CL5 of the Local Plan and the
NPPF.
Conclusion
20. The conclusions on both main issues represent compelling reasons for
dismissing the Appeal.
Elizabeth Lawrence
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.