Re-modelling of existing bungalow to a two storey house with garage alterations, garden landscaping over existing hard standings, new vehicular access to Maplehurst Road and stopping up access from Maplehurst Close
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Highways & Transport
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 1 September 2017
by R J Maile BSc FRICS
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 25 September 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/B1415/D/17/3177825
12 Maplehurst Road, St Leonards-on-Sea, East Sussex, TN37 7NA.
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 again st
a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Ms Lorraine Ashby against the decision of Hastings Borough
Council.
The application ref: HS/FA/17/00099, dated 14 February 2017, was refused by notice
dated 27 April 2017.
The development proposed is re-modelling of existing bungalow to a two storey house
with garage alterations, garden landscaping over existing hard standings, new vehicular
access to Maplehurst Road and stopping up access from Maplehurst Close.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues in this case are:
a) The effect of the proposed alterations upon the character and appearance
of the host building and that of the surrounding area.
b) The impact of the scheme upon the living conditions of nearby residents.
c) Whether the proposed new access would adversely affect highway safety
and the free flow of traffic along Maplehurst Road.
Reasons
a) Effect upon character and appearance.
3. The subject property comprises a modest detached post-war bungalow that is
located at the junction of Maplehurst Road (A2100) and Maplehurst Close. To
the south and east is an estate of principally similar bungalows. The adjacent
dwelling at 14 Maplehurst Road is a detached bungalow also, but there are late
Victorian semi-detached and terraced cottages to the west on the opposite side
of Maplehurst Road.
4. The existing bungalow and attached garage are prominent in the street scene
given the sloping nature of the site.
Appeal Decision APP/B1415/D/17/3177825
2
5. The ambitious scheme before me would transform what is currently a modest,
two bedroom bungalow into a substantial five/six bedroom house with attached
garage and workshop. The garage/workshop would have a floor area of some
55m2.
6. Chapter 7 of the Framework1 focuses on issues of good design. Paragraph 60
states that planning policies and decisions should not attempt to impose
architectural styles or particular tastes and they should not stifle innovation,
originality or initiative through unsubstantiated requirements to conform to
certain development forms or styles. It is, however, proper to seek to promote
or reinforce local distinctiveness.
7. Likewise, Policy DM1 of the DMP2 seeks to protect and enhance local character.
Development should, amongst other matters, show an appreciation of the
surrounding neighbourhood’s historic context, height, massing and materials.
8. The existing small-scale bungalow is appropriate to its surroundings. However,
the scheme before me would create a tall, bulky dwelling that would be highly
visible in the street scene, particularly as viewed from Maplehurst Close where
the pavement is at a higher level. The height, massing and materials of the
re-modelled dwelling would also be at odds with the predominantly bungalow-
oriented development on the east side of Maplehurst Road and with the small
Victorian houses opposite.
9. For these reasons, I have found upon the first main issue that development as
proposed would be out of keeping with and harmful to the character and
appearance of the host building and that of the surrounding area, contrary to
national policy at Chapter 7 of the Framework and Policy DM1 of the DMP.
b) Impact upon living conditions.
10. Policy DM3 of the DMP requires development proposals to ensure that any
building reduces or avoids any adverse impact on the amenity of neighbouring
properties.
11. The two storey element of the scheme would represent a dominant structure as
viewed from the flank-facing windows of 14 Maplehurst Road. Furthermore the
new garage, which would immediately abut the common boundary with no. 14,
would be highly visible from and give rise to loss of sunlight and daylight to the
rear garden of that property.
12. The creation of a new vehicular access alongside the south boundary of no. 14
would reduce the privacy enjoyed by its occupants, although this could be
mitigated by the erection of a close boarded fence to a height of not less than
1.8m. However, the proposed north-facing bedroom window at first floor level
would undoubtedly allow overlooking of the flank windows of no. 14 and its
rear private garden area.
13. I therefore find on the second main issue that development as proposed would
adversely impact upon the living conditions of existing and future residents of
14 Maplehurst Road, contrary to the objectives of Policy DM3 of the DMP.
1 The National Planning Policy Framework.
2 Hastings Local Plan: Development Management Plan (adopted 23 September 2015).
Appeal Decision APP/B1415/D/17/3177825
3
c) Highway safety.
14. The subject property has an existing vehicular access to Maplehurst Close, that
in turn provides access to Maplehurst Road (A2100). The A2100 is part of the
strategic highway network and carries high volumes of traffic.
15. The scheme before me proposes the closure of the existing access and the
creation of a new access point directly onto the A2100. Policy T3 of the
Hastings Planning Strategy3 requires development to improve the safety of the
highway network, whilst Policy DM4 of the DMP requires safe access into the
development for all users.
16. The East Sussex County Council as Highway Authority has raised an objection
to the proposal on the basis that the new access would be only 18m from the
junction with Maplehurst Close. The existing driveway is some 30m from this
junction.
17. The principal concern is the possibility that a vehicle parked on the grass verge
section of the new access could impede visibility for vehicles emerging from
Maplehurst Close. I am nevertheless satisfied, having regard to the width of the
path, that vehicles emerging from the close would still obtain adequate visibility
from an x distance of 2.4m down Maplehurst Road. Moreover, I note that the
proposal includes off-street parking for at least six vehicles clear of the grass
verge. This factor will obviate the need for parking on the section of driveway
where it crosses the verge.
18. The existing vehicular access from Maplehurst Close is steep and there are no
on-site turning facilities. For this reason, the proposed means of access directly
onto Maplehurst Road is in many ways preferable and it would benefit from
good visibility in both directions.
19. In further support of my conclusions upon this issue I noted that many of the
houses opposite and the bungalows to the north in Maplehurst Road possess
parking spaces with direct access onto the A2100 and, in the case of the
houses, with no possibility of providing on-site turning facilities.
20. Accordingly, I find upon the third main issue that the amended access would
enhance highway safety, such that the scheme would meet the requirements of
Policy T3 of the Hastings Planning Strategy and Policy DM4 of the DMP.
Conclusion
21. Notwithstanding my conclusions above as to the acceptability of the proposed
new access onto Maplehurst Road, my findings in respect of the two principal
main issues are determinative. As such, I conclude that the appeal should fail.
R. J. Maile
INSPECTOR
3 Hastings Local Plan: The Hastings Planning Strategy 2011 – 2028 (adopted 19 February 2014).
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.