Conversion of a double garage and erection of a link extension and dormers to form an annex to the existing farmhouse
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Rural Impact
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 5 September 2017
by Michael Evans BA MA MPhil DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 12 October 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/X1545/D/17/3177683
The Elms, Lodge Road, Woodham Mortimer CM9 6SL
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr A Macmorland against the decision of Maldon District Council.
The application Ref HOUSE/MAL/16/01451 was refused by notice dated 21 March 2017.
The development proposed is the conversion of a double garage and erection of a link
extension and dormers to form an annex to the existing farmhouse.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for the conversion of a
double garage and erection of a link extension and dormers to form an annex to
the existing farmhouse, at The Elms, Lodge Road, Woodham Mortimer CM9 6SL,
in accordance with the terms of the application, Ref HOUSE/MAL/16/01451,
subject to the following conditions:
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than three years
from the date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with
the following approved plans: 001 revision C, 002 revision C, 003 revision C,
004 revision A, 005 revision C, 006 revision C, 007 revision C, 008 revision
C, 009 revision C, 010 revision C, 011 revision C, 012 revision C, 013
revision C, 014 revision C, 015 revision C and 016 revision C.
3) The materials to be used in the construction of the external surfaces of the
development hereby permitted shall match those used in the existing
building.
4) The development hereby permitted shall be occupied only as an annex for
purposes ancillary and in conjunction with the use of the existing property,
known as The Elms, as a single dwelling house and not as a separate or
independent unit of residential accommodation.
Application for Costs
2. An application for costs was made by the Appellant against Maldon District
Council. This application will be the subject of a separate decision.
Preliminary Matter
3. On the 21 July 2017 the Secretary of State for Communities and Local
Government wrote to the Council advising it that he had approved the Maldon
District Local Development Plan (2014-2029) (the MDLDP) further to
Appeal Decision APP/X1545/D/17/3177683
2
considering the examining Inspector’s report of 29 June 2017. The MDLDP now
forms part of the Council’s development plan and the policies in the Maldon
District Replacement Local Plan have been superseded. As a result the main
parties have been given the opportunity to comment on this matter.
Main issues
4. The main issues in this appeal are:
- The effect on the character and appearance of the host
dwelling and locality.
- Whether the proposed development would comprise an annex
or a separate independent dwelling unit, and if the latter,
whether it would be suitable for such occupation.
Reasons
Character and appearance
5. The appeal concerns a detached chalet style dwelling with an immediately
adjacent detached garage. The converted garage would be attached to the
dwelling by a fairly modest link and extended to the rear in the opposite
direction to Lodge Road with the roof being raised in height. However, the roof
would still be at an appreciably lower level than that of the existing dwelling.
The footprint would be a reasonably moderate proportion of that of the host
property.
6. Four dormer additions would be constructed in the roof of the development.
This would be the same number as those found on the main roof of the host
dwelling. Despite being on a smaller roof, the new dormer additions would be
relatively limited in size with reasonable space around them. As a result, they
would not significantly increase the bulk of the annex. The above factors would
result in the scale and bulk of the development being relatively modest by
comparison to the associated dwelling.
7. Together with the similar roof form, the dormer additions would reflect and be
compatible with the host property rather than suggest the presence of a
separate dwelling. The existing dwelling would retain its front door with there
also being front and rear doors into the link addition. Nevertheless, in my
experience it is not unusual for larger dwellings to have several entrances.
8. In these circumstances, rather than giving the impression of comprising an
additional dwelling, the development would appear as a linked and subordinate
extension, despite the amount of glazing. There would, in consequence, be no
visual conflict with the associated dwelling.
9. The dwelling is set in open countryside where development tends to be sporadic
in nature. There is a fairly large farm building to the opposite side of the
garage to the existing dwelling. In the context of these adjacent buildings the
reasonably modest additional bulk of the enlarged garage would not result in it
appearing unacceptably prominent or visually intrusive in the countryside. It is
therefore concluded that there would be no harm caused to either the character
and appearance of the host dwelling or the locality. Because of these factors
and the distance to it, the setting of the Grade Two Listed Building at Elms Farm
Barn would not be harmed.
Appeal Decision APP/X1545/D/17/3177683
3
10.Matters such as the development’s architectural style, height, size and scale
would be respectful of the local context, in accordance with MDLDP Policy D1.
There would be no conflict with the intention of Policy S8 that the intrinsic
character and beauty of the countryside should not be adversely impacted.
There would be compliance with the aims of Policy S1 to emphasise high quality
design and maintain rural character. The extensions and alterations would
maintain the character of the original building and surrounding area in
accordance with these intentions of Policy H4.
11.The core planning principles of the National Planning Policy Framework (The
Framework) that planning should seek to secure high quality design and take
account of the character of different areas would be satisfied.
Whether an annex or separate dwelling
12.It is intended that the Appellant's son would initially occupy the proposed
development with the Appellant remaining in the existing house. The two
families would swap after three years. The enlarged outbuilding would provide
accommodation on two floors. It would include a dining room/kitchen, utility
room and farm office on the ground floor, with a living room, bedroom and
bathroom on the upper level. The Council is concerned that because of its
scale and nature this accommodation would not have a dependent relationship
with the host property and be more akin to an independent dwelling than an
annex.
13.It is a matter of fact and degree as to whether the additional accommodation
would be occupied as an annex or an independent dwelling. When assessing
this, it is necessary to consider whether the accommodation could function as
an annex. It is not automatically the case that the presence of the necessary
accommodation for independent occupation within the proposed annex means it
would not, or could not, be occupied as ancillary to The Elms.
14.The link addition would comprise a shared lobby enabling access directly into
the host property up a flight of stairs, as well as into the annex itself. This
layout would enable occupiers of the annex to enter and leave the host dwelling
as they choose. The annex would be within the curtilage of The Elms and there
is no proposal to subdivide the property by erecting, for example, a fence or
wall that might erode the functional linkage between the proposed annex and
the main dwelling.
15.Occupiers of the annex and dwelling would share the existing access off Lodge
Road. To reach the annex vehicles and pedestrians would pass the front of the
host dwelling. This would result in significant potential for noise and
disturbance in this peaceful rural location, as well as a loss of privacy, if the
development were occupied as a separate dwelling. Due to all the above
factors, it seems to me that, although not impossible, independent occupation
of the annex by anyone other than a relative or guest of the occupants of The
Elms would be highly unlikely and undesirable.
16.Whilst the proposed annex would allow the Appellant's son to live
independently, he would be able to join the Appellant in the main house and
garden whenever they wished. In consequence, I consider that the proposed
annex would be located and occupied such that there would be an ancillary
functional linkage with the occupation of the existing dwelling. I therefore
Appeal Decision APP/X1545/D/17/3177683
4
conclude that the development would comprise an annex rather than a separate
dwelling.
17.MDLDP Policies S1 and H4 seek, among other things, to ensure that homes are
provided in sustainable locations and to minimise the need to travel, as well as
ensuring proximity to public transport and accessibility to local services and
facilities. Policy S8 seeks to restrict development in the countryside to specified
types. Government policy in paragraph 55 of the Framework is that new
isolated homes in the countryside should be avoided unless special
circumstances, such as those listed in the bullet points following paragraph 55
apply.
18.The Appellant has not sought to argue that a dwelling at the appeal site would
be other than contrary to these policies. I am satisfied that given the isolated
nature of the location in relation to matters such as public transport and
services and facilities a new dwelling would be in conflict with the above
policies.
19.However, a planning condition requiring ancillary occupation of the annex would
prevent these policy objectives being undermined, while also avoiding the living
conditions of the occupiers of the existing dwelling being detrimentally affected.
Such a condition is therefore reasonable and necessary and would ensure that
the independent occupation as a single dwelling unit could not lawfully occur
without the benefit of planning permission.
20.MDLDP Policy H3 is concerned with specially designed and / or managed
accommodation, tailored to a particular specialist need, such as those of the
elderly or disabled. In this case there is nothing to show that the development
would be specifically designed to meet such a need or managed on that basis.
Moreover, the absence of any detrimental effect means that the proposal is
acceptable anyway in this instance, regardless of any consideration of need.
Conclusion
21.Taking account of all other matters raised, there is no reason to reject the
proposal given the absence of harm and the appeal succeeds.
Conditions
22.In addition to that referred to above, a condition specifying the approved plans
is necessary to provide certainty. The facing materials used should match those
of the existing dwelling to protect its appearance.
M Evans
INSPECTOR
£
Costs decision section
Costs Decision
Site visit made on 5 September 2017
by Michael Evans BA MA MPhil DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date:
Costs application in relation to Appeal Ref: APP/X1545/D/17/3177683
The Elms, Lodge Road, Woodham Mortimer CM9 6SL
The application is made under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, sections 78,
322 and Schedule 6, and the Local Government Act 1972, section 250(5).
The application is made by Mr A Macmorland for a full award of costs against Maldon
District Council.
The appeal was made against the refusal of planning permission for the conversion of a
double garage and erection of a link extension and dormers to form an annex to the
existing farmhouse.
Decision
1. The application for an award of costs is refused.
Reasons
2. In paragraph 30 of the Planning Practice Guidance (PPG) concerning appeals it
is advised that where a party has behaved unreasonably, and this has directly
caused another party to incur unnecessary or wasted expense in the appeal
process, they may be subject to an award of costs.
3. There is disagreement between the Council and the Appellant as to whether
information regarding the justification for the development was provided with
the application. While this is noted I have not been provided with any evidence
to corroborate the Appellant's claim. Furthermore, in deciding whether the
development would comprise an independent dwelling the overriding
consideration was my assessment of the submitted drawings. I am not
therefore persuaded that costs should be awarded on this basis.
4. The development would have the same number of dormer additions as the main
house but on a smaller roof. Therefore the Council's raising of this as a concern
was reasonable. The Council's case in relation to the appearance of the
development as an additional dwelling also concerned the increased size of the
converted garage and new glazing. In my view, this provided a reasonable
basis for the claim regarding visual conflict with the host property.
5. Despite some confusion about the position in relation to views from Lodge Road,
the Council's report and reason for refusal indicate a clear concern about the
visibility of the development from the surrounding countryside. I see no reason
why this should be limited to views from public footpaths. Given the fairly
visible position of the development in the wider landscape and increased size of
the converted garage, I do not consider the Council's position unreasonable,
Costs Decision APP/X1545/D/17/3177683
2
despite reaching a different conclusion on the impact.
6. For these reasons, although I found the development acceptable, I consider that
the Council had reasonable grounds for rejecting the application. This is not
therefore a case where the first bullet point of Paragraph 49 of the PPG applies,
as the Council has not prevented or delayed development which should clearly
be permitted, having regard to its accordance with the development plan,
national policy and any other material considerations.
7. In consequence, it is concluded that unreasonable behaviour resulting in
unnecessary expense, as described in the PPG, has not been demonstrated and
a full award of costs is not justified.
M Evans
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.