Retrospective application for the erection of first floor rear conservatory (resubmission of 16/01233/HOUS)

📊

See the success rate & inspector analytics

Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.

Sign Up Free

Technical Issues Heatmap

Residential Amenity
Extensions
Character & Appearance

Inspector’s Reasoning

Appeal Decision Site visit made on 6 September 2017 by Gareth Wildgoose BSc (Hons) MSc MRTPI an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government Decision date: 20th September 2017 Appeal Ref: APP/P4225/D/17/3176987 36 Gowers Street, Rochdale, Lancs OL16 2LN  The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against a refusal to grant planning permission.  The appeal is made by Mr Mohammad Javid against the decision of Rochdale Metropolitan Borough Council.  The application Ref 17/00146/HOUS, dated 8 February 2017, was refused by notice dated 5 April 2017.  The development proposed is retrospective application for the erection of first floor rear conservatory (resubmission of 16/01233/HOUS). Decision 1. The appeal is dismissed. Main Issues 2. The main issues are:  the effect on the character and appearance of the host property and the area, and;  the effect on the living conditions of occupiers of Nos. 34 and 38 Gowers Street with particular regard to outlook and privacy. Reasons Character and appearance 3. Policy DM1 of the CS, amongst other things, requires that all development proposals, including extensions and alterations, demonstrate that they are of high quality design and take the opportunity to enhance the quality of the area. Policy P3 of the CS also seeks regard to matters such as scale, massing, height and materials of surrounding buildings and the area, and that buildings contribute positively to the townscape and are well proportioned. The interpretation of the policies is assisted by guidance within the Rochdale Guidelines & Standards for Residential Development SPD, adopted June 2016. The SPD requires that extensions and alterations should be in keeping with the host property and generally should be subservient to it. 4. No 36 is a bungalow sited within a row of similar properties on the southern side of Gowers Street. The bungalow has front and rear dormers and a single storey rear extension. At the time of my visit, a first floor rear conservatory and veranda / roof terrace had been completed above the single storey rear extension and adjoining the rear dormer. I observed that the veranda was Appeal Decision APP/P4225/D/17/3176987 2 bound by metal railings rather than a glazed handrail as proposed and that the rear conservatory roof was different to the shallow pitched roof indicated on the submitted plans. I determine this appeal on the basis of the development as proposed, and not the works as constructed. 5. Gowers Street has a varied character, including two storey terraced properties opposite and toward the junction with Weedon Street. Front and rear dormers and single storey rear extensions, including conservatories, are a common feature of both bungalows and two storey dwellings. However, the addition of a rear conservatory and associated veranda at first floor level introduces an unusual feature to the locality, as other conservatories are at ground floor level. The rear conservatory would link into the rear dormer with a shallow roof pitch. Nevertheless, the cumulative scale, bulk, depth and massing of built form would appear out of proportion and would subsume the rear elevation and roof of No 36. In addition, the visual contrast of glazed materials relative to the grey tiles of the rear dormer would appear awkward and out of place at the rear of the bungalow at first floor level. The resultant visual effect would be an incongruous, dominant and insubordinate addition to the rear elevation of the appeal property. 6. The presence of the River Roch beyond the rear boundary of the site and an associated tree line provides visual containment to that aspect. The conservatory and veranda also would not be viewed prominently along Gowers Street given their siting and the similar building lines of properties immediately adjacent. However, the rear roofscape of No 36 and surrounding bungalows is visible from a cul-de-sac that serves a group of bungalows located in a backland position further to the west. From that perspective and from private vantage points within the rear gardens of neighbouring properties, the conservatory at first floor level would be viewed as incongruous and out of place. Consequently, the proposal would have a significant harmful effect upon the character of the host property and the area. 7. I conclude that the development would significantly harm the character and appearance of the host property and the area. The proposal, therefore, conflicts with Policies DM1 and P3 of the CS, together with the associated guidance in the SPD. The policies are consistent with the core planning principle of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) which seeks to secure high quality design. Living conditions – neighbouring properties 8. Policy DM1 of the CS also requires that extensions and alterations demonstrate that they do not adversely affect the amenity of residents or users through visual intrusion, overbearing impact, overshadowing or loss of privacy. In addition, the SPD indicates that balconies and elevated terraces can result in adverse overlooking of neighbouring private garden areas or habitable room windows if they are located in close proximity to the boundary of the curtilage. 9. The first floor conservatory includes a veranda at the side which adjoins the shared boundary with the rear garden of No 38, an adjoining bungalow, with a resultant set in of the conservatory from the boundary at first floor level. Obscure glazing of the facing conservatory windows could be secured by condition to prevent direct overlooking of the rear garden of No 38. However, the use of the veranda would result in direct overlooking of the rear garden and views into the nearest ground floor window of No 38. The resultant loss of Appeal Decision APP/P4225/D/17/3176987 3 privacy to No 38 would be intrusive and harmful, with a detrimental impact upon the living conditions of occupiers of that property and the enjoyment of the rear garden. The harmful overlooking and loss of privacy to No 38 would not be prevented by the inclusion of an obscure glazed handrail. 10. The height of a handrail and the ground floor rear extension when taken together would be around 3.5m high and for a depth of approximately 3m immediately adjacent to the boundary. The overall height adjoining the boundary would be less than the conservatory and the glazing at first floor level would offer some light provision to prevent overshadowing. Nevertheless, the cumulative height and depth of built form and a veranda enclosure along the boundary would have an overbearing effect which would be significant upon the outlook from No 38. The proposal, therefore, would also harm the living conditions of occupiers of No 38 in that respect. 11. The first floor conservatory would be set in from the shared boundary with No 34, an adjacent bungalow. However, it would not accord with the requirements of the SPD as it would project beyond a 30 degree line drawn from a point 2.4m along the common boundary from the rear elevation of No 34. The southerly aspect of the rear elevation of No 34 and glazing of the conservatory would prevent significant overshadowing. Furthermore, facing windows could be obscure glazed to prevent a loss of privacy to windows in the rear elevation of No 34 and its rear garden. Nevertheless, the overbearing effect arising from the depth and height of built form in close proximity to the boundary would harm the outlook of No 34. Consequently, the proposal would have a harmful effect upon the living conditions of occupiers of No 34. 12. In reaching the above findings, I have taken into account that no objections were received from the occupiers of neighbouring properties. However, such matters are not considerations which outweigh the harm identified. 13. I conclude that the development would result in significant harm to the living conditions of occupiers of Nos. 34 and 38 Gowers Street. The proposal, therefore, conflicts with Policy DM1 of the CS, together with the associated guidance in the SPD. The policy is consistent with the core planning principle of the Framework which seeks a good standard of amenity for all existing and future occupiers of land and buildings. Other Matters 14. Policies H/11 and BE/2 of the Rochdale Unitary Development Plan were deleted upon adoption of the Rochdale Core Strategy (CS) in October 2016 which preceded the submission of the planning application. I, therefore, determine this appeal relative to the current development plan and its relevant policies. 15. Personal circumstances identified by the appellant do not outweigh the harm I have identified. The particular circumstances of the occupiers of No 36 may change over time whilst the development would be a permanent feature. Conclusion 16. For the reasons given above and taking all other matters into consideration, I conclude that this appeal should be dismissed. Gareth Wildgoose INSPECTOR
Expert Representation

Don't leave your appeal to chance.

Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.

Get Free Review How it works →