Erection of a single storey rear and side extension Decision
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 26 July 2017
by D J Barnes MBA BSc(Hons) DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 11 August 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/K3605/D/17/3176834
14 Downsview Close, Downside, Cobham KT11 3NS
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs M Mustoe against the decision of Elmbridge Borough
Council.
The application Ref 2017/0631, dated 24 February 2017, was refused by notice dated
28 April 2017.
The development proposed is the erection of a single storey rear and side extension
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. It is considered that the main issues are:
(a) Whether the proposal would be inappropriate development for the
purposes of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework)
and development plan policy;
(b) The effect of the development on the openness of the Green Belt and the
purposes for including land within it;
(c) The effect of the development on the visual amenity of the Green Belt
and character and appearance of the surrounding area; and
(d) If the development is inappropriate, whether the harm by reason of
inappropriateness, and any other harm, is clearly outweighed by other
considerations, so as to amount to the very special circumstances
necessary to justify the development.
Reasons
Whether the proposal would be inappropriate development for the purposes of
the Framework and development plan policy
3. The appeal property is a 2-storey semi-detached dwelling which has a single
storey rear addition and a roof extension. Although part of a collection of
dwellings fronting Downsview Close, the property is located within the Green
Belt. Policy DM18 of the Elmbridge Development Management Plan (DMP)
Appeal Decision APP/K3605/D/17/3176834
2
identifies that within the Green Belt extensions and alterations to a building will
be permitted provided they do not result in disproportionate additions over and
above the size of the original building. This policy is consistent with the
Framework’s approach. The Framework is silent about what scale of extension
or alteration would amount to a disproportionate addition.
4. Inclusive of the replacement of the existing single storey rear addition, the
Council has calculated that the proposed side and rear extensions would
increase the floorspace of the original building by more than 38%. However,
the criterion included in DMP Policy DM18 to assess whether a proposal results
in a disproportionate addition is that the original building is not increased by
more than 25% in volume and footprint.
5. The floorspace measurements indicate that the ground floor of the original
building was around 43sq m which would have generally equated to its
footprint. The footprint of the proposed extensions, inclusive of the existing
addition, is stated to be about 35sq m in the appellants’ evidence. The appeal
scheme would, therefore, represent an increase in the footprint of the original
building by around 81%.
6. Although no volume calculations have been provided, the Council claim that the
scale of the extensions, plus the roof alteration, would exceed the 25%
threshold identified in DMP Policy DM 8. The appellants do not dispute this
claim. A significant proportion of any increase in volume would be attributable
to the proposed single storey extensions, inclusive of the rear addition, rather
than just the roof alteration. This adds weight to concerns about the
cumulative scale of the existing and proposed alterations nd extensions.
7. Accordingly, principally by reason of the increase in footprint, the proposed
development would be a disproportionate addition to the original property and
it is, therefore, concluded that it would be inappropriate development in the
Green Belt and, as such, it would conflict with DMP Policy DM18 and the
Framework. Paragraphs 87 and 88 of the Framework state that inappropriate
development is, by definition, harmful to the Green Belt and should not be
approved except in very special circumstances and that substantial weight
should be attached to any harm to the Green Belt. Very special circumstances
will not exist unless the potential harm to the Green Belt by reason of
inappropriateness, and any other harm, is clearly outweighed by other
considerations. The question of any other harm and the other matters in this
case are now considered.
The effect of the development on the openness of the Green Belt and the
purposes for including land within it
8. Paragraph 79 of the Framework states that one of the essential characteristics
of Green Belts is their openness. DMP Policy DM18 requires extensions and
alterations not to have a materially greater impact on the openness of the
Green Belt. The proposed extensions would increase the bulk of the property.
The enlarged property would be seen from neighbouring gardens and there
would be some localised views from the road. For these reasons, it is
concluded that the appeal scheme would have an adverse effect on the
openness of the Green Belt and would conflict with DMP Policy DM18 and the
Framework but the degree of harm would be limited.
Appeal Decision APP/K3605/D/17/3176834
3
9. By reason of the appeal scheme being contained within the residential
curtilage, it is concluded that the proposed extensions would not conflict with
the purposes of the Green Belt as identified at paragraph 80 of the Framework,
in particular safeguarding the countryside from encroachment.
The effect of the development on the visual amenity of the Green Belt and
character and appearance of the surrounding area
10. The property forms part of a collection of varying designs and types of
dwellings fronting Downsview Close and is sited within a spacious plot. Some
of these dwellings have been altered by side, rear and roof extensions. The
proposed development would not cause any significant harm to the residential
character and appearance of the surrounding area, and the varied streetscene.
The enlarged property would still be sited within a spacious plot which is a
characteristic of other neighbouring dwellings.
11. The Council has not raised any objections to the proposed extensions on the
basis that it would fail to be a subservient addition to the property and would
harm the character of the property. There are no reasons for me to disagree
with the Council’s assessment. For the reasons given, it is concluded that the
proposed development would not cause unacceptable harm to either the visual
amenity of the Green Belt or the character and appearance of the surrounding
area and, as such, it would not conflict with the design requirements of the
Framework.
If the development is inappropriate, whether the harm by reason of
inappropriateness, and any other harm, is clearly outweighed by other
considerations, so as to amount to the very special circumstances necessary to
justify the development
12. The appeal scheme has been judged to not cause harm to the purposes and
visual amenity of the Green Belt. However, these matters merely result in
there being no additional harm to that arising from the inappropriate
development and the weight attached to them needs to be tempered
accordingly. Therefore, moderate weight has been attached to these matters.
For the reasons already given, the absence of unacceptable harm being caused
to the character and appearance of the surrounding area is given significant
weight in the determination of this appeal.
13. The appellants have referred to the fall-back position associated with additions
which might be capable of being erected as permitted development. The
appellants’ claim that the scale of the permitted development would exceed the
footprint of the appeal scheme. Further, there would be an adverse effect on
the streetscene associated with the front porch and side additions which could,
the appellants’ claim, be erected as permitted development.
14. It is accepted that there is a basis for the appellants’ claim concerning what
might be capable of being erected as permitted development. A rear addition
already exists and the minor increase in its extent shown in the appellants’
evidence would not add to the existing footprint in any meaningful way.
However, the evidence does not indicate that prior approval has been given for
an addition projecting up-to 6 metres from the rear elevation of the property.
For this reason, limited weight is given to the possible erection of a 6 metre
deep rear addition.
Appeal Decision APP/K3605/D/17/3176834
4
15. The porch and side addition would approximate to the net increase in the
footprint of the original building and would cause similar limited harm to the
openness of the Green Belt as the appeal scheme. However, I do not share the
appellants’ claim about their significant adverse effect on the appearance of the
streetscene because the alterations undertaken at other dwellings provide a
varied character.
16. By reason of scale and appearance, the potential erection of the porch and side
addition could attract significant weight in the determination of this appeal.
However, this weight is tempered because these additions are not materially
better or worse than the appeal scheme in terms of their impacts on the
openness, purposes and visual amenity of the Green Belt and the lack of
unacceptable harm being caused to the character and appearance of the
surrounding area. Moderate weight is given to these elements of the fall-back
position.
17. The appellants have referred to proposals allowed within the surrounding area
but, other than a reference to a detached dwelling at Middleton Road, no
details of these other schemes have been provided. In the absence of their full
planning circumstances only limited weight can be given to these other
schemes. Where such proposals have already been implemented then they
have been assessed as part of the wider character and appearance of the
surrounding area and the varied streetscene.
18. The appellants’ claim about the effects of the alterations to the roof influencing
the Council’s assessment of the appeal have been noted. Such a consideration
could affect the assessment of the increase in volume of the original property
but the inappropriateness of the proposed extensions has been principally
based upon the increase in footprint. Limited weight is given to this matter.
19. The absence of any objection from the Council on the grounds of harm being
caused to the living conditions of the occupiers of neighbouring properties has
been noted. This matter is given limited weight in the determination of this
appeal because it does not materially alter the assessment about the
implications for development occurring in the Green Belt.
Conclusion
20. These other considerations, even when taken together, do not clearly outweigh
the harm by reason of inappropriateness, the limited harm to the openness of
the Green Belt and the conflict with local and national policy. Accordingly, it is
concluded that the very special circumstances required to justify the
development do not exist and, taking into account all other matters, this appeal
should be dismissed.
D J Barnes
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.