First floor rear extension over existing single storey kitchen and sliding/folding doors in rear boundary wall to south Westby Street to allow vehicular parking access
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 22 August 2017
by Andrew McCormack BSc (Hons) MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 15 September 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/M2325/D/17/3176612
45 Westby Street, Lytham St Annes, Lancashire FY8 5JF
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr Matthew Eaton against the decision of Fylde Borough Council.
The application Ref 16/0894, dated 1 November 2016, was refused by notice dated
24 March 2017.
The development proposed is first floor rear extension over existing single storey
kitchen and sliding/folding doors in rear boundary wall to south Westby Street to allow
vehicular parking access.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matter
2. The Council’s Reasons for Refusal refer to emerging planning policies ENV5 and
GD7 within the Fylde Local Plan to 2032 (Submission Version) (the FLP). The FLP
is currently the subject of an Examination in Public. As such, the policies within it
cannot be afforded full weight in the determination of this appeal. Having had
regard to the FLP policies and the stage which the emerging plan has reached, I
have given moderate weight to those policies as material considerations. However,
as the FLP policies are not adopted, they are not part of the development plan.
Therefore, whilst I have given them due consideration as material considerations, I
have determined the appeal principally against the adopted policies within the
Fylde Borough Local Plan, as altered (October 2005).
Main Issues
3. The main issues are the effect of the proposed development on the:
character and appearance of the surrounding area, including the Lytham Town
Centre Conservation Area; and
living conditions of neighbouring occupiers, with regard to outlook, daylight and
privacy.
Reasons
4. The appeal property is situated within a group of terraced dwellings located
between Westby Street and South Westby Street and a significant number of
nearby properties have single and two storey rear extensions. There are garden
areas to the rear of the properties and beyond these and South Westby Street,
there is a public surface-level car park. The proposal also lies within the Lytham
Town Centre Conservation Area (CA).
Appeal Decision APP/M2325/D/17/3176612
2
Character and appearance
5. The rear elevation of the appeal property is clearly visible from South Westby
Street and the nearby car park. I note that the proposed extension would be of a
similar type, scale and design to some which can be seen at other nearby
properties, including the two storey extension at a neighbouring property, 43
Westby Street (No.43). These extensions form a strong feature in the local area
along the rear elevations of properties on the south side of Westby Street. As a
result, the character and appearance of those properties, particularly when viewed
from South Westby Street, is now mixed and very different to how they would
have appeared originally.
6. Given this change in character and appearance of the properties and the area
overall, I find that the proposed extension would not be out of keeping with its
surrounding context. It would be of a design, scale and appearance which would
be similar to other two storey rear extensions nearby. Furthermore, it would
appear subservient and of an appropriate scale and appearance to its host
property.
7. The Council argues that the upper portion of the appeal property is considered to
be distinctive and would be damaged by the proposed extension. As such, it is
stated that the property should be retained as it is. Notwithstanding this, I find the
upper portion of the property not to be particularly distinctive in its appearance or
character. Therefore, in my view, the proposed extension would have no material
harmful effect on the character and appearance of the property, the wider street
scene or visual amenity within the surrounding area.
8. However, I now turn to the proposed alterations to, and partial removal of, the
rear boundary wall of the property. I note that this part of the proposed
development seeks to provide access for parking within the appeal site.
Nevertheless, given its prominent and highly visible position on South Westby
Street and in the wider street scene, I find that the alteration and removal of this
traditionally built wall would be detrimental to that street scene. As a result, it
would have a significant harmful impact on the character and appearance of the
area, including the CA.
9. I acknowledge the appellant’s comment no objection would be raised to this
element of the proposal being omitted from any planning permission were it
considered to have a harmful impact on the locality. Notwithstanding this, I must
assess the proposed development on the same basis as the Council has determined
the planning application. Therefore, I have considered the proposal in its entirety
and reached my decision accordingly.
10. Having regard to the proposal’s location, I must assess whether it would have a
detrimental effect on the CA or preserve or enhance its character and appearance.
Accordingly, I have carefully considered these matters. As a result, I find it
inevitable that the proposal would alter the appearance of the host property and its
immediate surroundings. Nonetheless, the proposed extension itself would have
only a limited impact on the CA. However, the proposed alteration and removal of
the rear boundary wall would have a significant adverse effect on the character and
appearance of the CA. The harm caused would be less than substantial.
Notwithstanding this, in my view, the proposed development, when considered as
a whole, would not preserve or enhance the character and appearance of the CA.
11. Consequently, I conclude that the proposed development would have a significant
detrimental impact on the surrounding area and would not preserve the character
and appearance of the CA. Therefore, it would be contrary to Policy EP3 of the
Appeal Decision APP/M2325/D/17/3176612
3
Fylde Borough Local Plan as Altered (October 2005) and the relevant sections of
the Framework. Amongst other matters, this policy and guidance seeks to ensure
that development respects and has regard to the character, appearance and
setting of its surroundings, including conservation areas.
Living conditions: outlook, daylight and privacy
12. As a mid-terraced dwelling, the appeal property has neighbours in close proximity
on either side. The neighbouring occupiers of No.43 would be the most affected by
the proposed development with regard to outlook and daylight. I note that there is
a set of glazed doors positioned within the original real wall of No.43. These doors
serve the dining room of the property and are located at ground floor level and are
adjacent to the shared boundary with the appeal property.
13. There is a two storey rear extension at No.43 which is similar to the proposal. The
side elevation of that extension, facing the appeal property and proposed
extension, features a ground floor window for the kitchen and a first floor window
serving a bedroom. From my site visit, I saw that these rooms are both served by
other windows in the south elevation of the property. The first floor bedroom is, in
fact, served by glazed doors and a Juliet balcony. As a result, these rooms have a
dual aspect. Therefore, I find that the impact of the proposed extension on outlook
from these rooms, particularly the bedroom, would be diminished.
14. Furthermore, I note that the glazed doors serving the dining room provide the only
direct source of daylight for the room, as well as the outlook from the room for the
occupiers of the property. The doors are located between the two storey extension
of No.43 and the existing single storey rear extension of the appeal property. As a
result, the dining room currently receives a limited amount of daylight through the
doors and has a limited but open outlook.
15. The proposal would increase the height of the existing rear extension at the appeal
property along the shared boundary with No.43 to two storeys. This would create
a two storey recess between the rear extension of No.43 and the proposed
extension. This recess would have a depth of around 5 metres and would be about
2 metres wide. As a result, I find that the proposal would significantly impact the
amount of daylight reaching the dining room through the glazed doors which is
currently experienced by the occupiers of No.43. Furthermore, the proposed
extension would significantly diminish the outlook of the occupiers of No.43 from
the dining room and create an unacceptable sense of enclosure.
16. In addition, I note the proximity of the proposed extension to the ground floor
doors and windows serving in the dining room and kitchen of No.43. Due to the
position and nature of these openings, I find that the impact of the proposal on
No.43 and its occupiers with regard to daylight and outlook would be significant.
17. I appreciate that the outlook and, to a limited degree, daylight from the first floor
side bedroom window within the rear extension of No.43 would be adversely
impacted by the two storey blank elevation of the proposed extension. However,
from what I saw, I find that its impact would be diminished by the presence of the
glazed doors and Juliet balcony in the south elevation.
18. The Council has indicated that the overlooking of neighbouring properties from the
proposed Juliet balcony would be unrestricted and therefore unacceptable. Whilst I
acknowledge that other properties, including No.43, have been granted permission
for similar proposals, it is noted that approval was granted prior to changes in
national and local planning policy and guidance. Accordingly, I have assessed the
proposed development on its own individual merits and against the most up-to-
date, adopted planning policy and guidance.
Appeal Decision APP/M2325/D/17/3176612
4
19. It is apparent that there would be some overlooking of neighbouring gardens from
the proposed extension. However, I note that this would not be significantly
greater than that which currently exists through the approved and constructed
extensions nearby, include the rear extension at No.43 which overlooks the rear
garden of the appeal property amongst others. Whilst overlooking would occur as
a result of the proposal, in my view, the harm caused would not be significant
given the surrounding context and open aspect of the rear gardens in the
surrounding area. Notwithstanding this, given my findings on the other aspects
relating to outlook and daylight, whilst not significant, I find that combined with
the impact of those other aspects the proposal development would result in some
limited harm regarding overlooking.
20. As a result, I find that the proposal would have an adverse impact on the living
conditions of the occupiers of No.43 and that existing attributes relating to outlook,
daylight and privacy would be materially diminished were the proposed
development allowed. Furthermore, I find that such impacts would not be
appropriately addressed through the imposition of planning conditions.
21. Consequently, I conclude that the proposed development would have a significant
adverse impact on the living conditions of neighbouring occupiers with regard to
outlook, daylight and privacy. Therefore, it would be contrary to Policy HL5 of the
Fylde Borough Local Plan, as altered (October 2005) and the relevant sections of
the Framework. Amongst other matters, this policy and guidance seeks to ensure
that development has no material detrimental effect on the living conditions of
neighbouring occupiers and uses.
Planning Balance
22. The proposed extension would provide additional accommodation to a property in
an established, accessible and sustainable residential area. It would be of a similar
design and scale to other extensions which have been constructed nearby. As a
result, I find that the visual impact of the proposed extension on the host property
and the wider area would not be materially harmful. In addition, in my view, the
proposed extension would not have a significant adverse impact on the character
and appearance of the CA.
23. Notwithstanding this, the alteration and removal of part of the rear boundary wall
would be materially harmful to the local area and the CA. As a result, the proposal
would not have a preserving or enhancing effect on the character or appearance of
the CA. Accordingly, significant weight is given to this matter. Moreover, the
outlook from the glazed doors of the dining room of No.43 and the daylight which
the dining room currently receives through those doors would be significantly
diminished by the proposed development. This would have a significant harmful
effect on the occupiers of No.43. In addition, the proposed extension would have
some limited adverse impact on the privacy of neighbouring occupiers. Therefore,
having had due regard to all of the above, I find that the benefits of the proposal
would not outweigh the significant harm I have identified.
Conclusion
24. For the above reasons, and having had regard to all other matters raised, I
conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
Andrew McCormack
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.