To construct extensions to dwelling (demolish existing garage). Including replacement windows
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Trees & Landscape
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 15 August 2017
by R J Jackson BA MPhil DMS MRTPI MCMI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 25 August 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/G1250/D/17/3176656
19 Chine Crescent Road, Bournemouth BH2 5LG
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr Adrian Eldridge against the decision of Bournemouth Borough
Council.
The application Ref 7-2016-5231-C, dated 22 June 2016, was refused by notice dated
12 April 2017.
The development proposed is to construct extensions to dwelling (demolish existing
garage). Including replacement windows.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
2. The main issue is the effect on the character and appearance of the area.
Reasons
3. The appeal site lies on the southeastern side of Chine Crescent Road. The
majority of the properties on this road are large blocks of flats, but there
appear to be three single family dwellinghouses on this side of the road of
which the appeal property is in the middle. Generally there are significant
spaces between the properties which, with the extensive vegetation in the
vicinity, give the area a spacious feel. The trees are covered by an area Tree
Preservation Order1 (the TPO) protecting the trees in existence when the Order
was made.
4. The proposal is in effect to build a first floor side extension over an existing flat
roofed side element to the house currently providing garaging, as well as a two
storey extension behind this and the enclosure of a small section on the ground
floor to the rear of the living room.
5. The Council has published a document entitled “Residential extensions – A
Design Guide for Householders” (the Design Guide) to seek to improve the
quality of design in its built environment. This is in accordance with
paragraphs 17 and 64 of the National Planning Policy Framework (the
Framework) which indicates that planning should always seek high quality
design and that development should be refused for development of poor design
1 The Borough of Bournemouth (West Cliff Road Area 4) Tree Preservation Order 1982.
Appeal Decision APP/G1250/D/17/3176656
2
that fails to take the opportunities for improving the character and quality of an
area. In light of this, and as this document was adopted following public
consultation, I am able to give it significant weight.
6. At present the property covers the vast majority of the width of the property
with only little space to the boundaries. However, this does not give a
cramped appearance as the garage element is only single storey allowing the
vegetation to the rear to be seen over it. The proposal would result in two
storey building across more or less the whole width of the appeal site and
would significantly and harmfully result in a loss of space around the property
resulting in a cramped appearance. As I have identified above, this sense of
space is one of the defining characteristics of the area and as such the proposal
would be harmful to the character and appearance of the area.
7. There are five significant trees in the area between the appeal property and the
adjoining property to the southwest, No 17. The application was accompanied
by a Tree Report and later supported by a number of additional tree
assessments including an Arboricultural Method Statement pursuant to British
Standard 5837:20122 (the BS). All of these five trees are of some age and are
protected by the TPO.
8. The middle three trees, a Horse Chestnut (T2) and two Limes (T3 and T4) are
of lesser quality than those at either end, the Survey Schedule categorising
them at C1, that being trees of low quality with an estimated remaining life
expectancy of at least 10 years being categorised through their arboricultural
qualities. The two Lime trees were managed in the past by pollarding, but this
has not been undertaken in recent years. All the trees are on a bank, although
tree T5 is close to street level as the level of the appeal property is set down
slightly from the road.
9. As set out above the proposal is “in effect” for a first floor element since there
is some dispute as to the method of construction as to whether the existing
single storey structure would need to be replaced. Whatever the situation, the
branches of T3 would need be significantly pruned to facilitate the development
as these branches currently extend into the area where the proposal would be
located.
10. Tree T3 is within the garden of No 17 and thus any pruning could only be to the
boundary unless the owner of No 17 was to give consent. I have not been
provided with any information that additional works would be permitted by the
owner. In any event, the grant of planning permission only allows for such
work to protected trees as is necessary to implement the planning permission,
not for additional works. The effect of this would be to leave this tree with an
asymmetric crown. While these works would partially replicate previous
pollarding of the tree, this would have been done on a symmetrical basis and
therefore would not be an equivalent. That T3 (and T4) would need to be
pollarded as part of normal management is a different consideration.
11. The new two storey element would extend into the Root Protection Areas
(RPAs) of both trees T1 and T2. The Horse Chestnut T2 bifurcates
approximately 1 m from the ground meaning that there will be inherent
structural concerns. However, tree T1, a Lime, is categorised at B1 using the
BS, meaning that it is of moderate quality with an expected life expectancy of
2 ‘Trees in relation to design, demolition and construction – Recommendations’
Appeal Decision APP/G1250/D/17/3176656
3
at least 20 years being categorised through its arboricultural qualities. The BS
notes that the default position should be that structures are located outside the
RPAs of trees unless there is an overriding justification. No such justification
has been demonstrated to show that this is the only location where the building
could be extended.
12. That being the case the proposal would result in the potential harm to the
health and longevity of protected trees. The loss of these trees would add to
the harm that I have identified above from to the width of the proposal.
13. I therefore conclude that the proposal would be harmful to the character and
appearance of the area. As such the proposal would be contrary to Policy CS41
of the Bournemouth Plan - Core Strategy (October 2012) which requires
development to be designed to respect the site and its surroundings. It would
also be contrary to Policy 4.25 of the Bournemouth District Wide Local Plan
(February 2002) which requires sufficient land for planting and landscaping,
this must include for the retention of existing landscaping. It would also be
contrary to section 3.2 of the Design Guide which indicates that side extensions
should be set at least 1.0 m from the side boundary to make sure the street
does not become cramped. It would also be contrary to paragraphs 17 and 64
of the Framework as set out above.
Conclusion
14. For the reasons given above, and taking into account all other matters raised, I
conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
R J Jackson
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.