Removal of the existing 'butterfly' slate roof; on the rear two thirds of the house the construction of a slate clad dormer roof extension; and on the front third of the house creation of a new private terrace at second floor behind the existing parapet wall
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 18 July 2017
by Oliver Blower MA (T&CP)
a person appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 11 September 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/A5840/D/17/3176329
3 Green Walk, London SE1 4TU
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Ms Rose Campbell against the decision of the Council of the
London Borough of Southwark.
The application Ref 17/AP/0002, dated 30 December 2016, was refused by notice dated
1 March 2017.
The development proposed is described as “removal of the existing 'butterfly' slate roof;
on the rear two thirds of the house the construction of a slate clad dormer roof
extension; and on the front third of the house creation of a new private terrace at
second floor behind the existing parapet wall”.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Application for costs
2. An application for costs was made by Ms Rose Campbell against the London
Borough of Southwark. This application is the subject of a separate Decision.
Preliminary matters
3. The grounds of appeal state that the application was erroneously made in the
name of the agent, Mr Brian Q Love. It is clear from the written evidence that
the appellant is in fact Ms Rose Campbell and I have reflected this in the
header above.
Main Issue
4. The main issue is the effect of the proposed development on the character and
appearance of the terrace and whether it would preserve or enhance the
character or appearance of the Bermondsey Street Conservation Area.
Reasons
5. There is a statutory duty1 to pay special attention to the desirability of
preserving or enhancing the character or appearance of a conservation area
and I must consider the effect of the proposed development from that
perspective.
1 This requirement is set down in section 72(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990
and is always a material consideration when dealing with appeals in conservation areas.
Appeal Decision APP/A5840/D/17/3176329
2
6. Furthermore, the National Planning Policy Framework (‘the Framework’) defines
a conservation area as a ‘heritage asset’, and seeks to ensure that heritage
assets are conserved in a manner appropriate to their significance2. I must
therefore assess the significance of the conservation area in those terms, and
come to a view on whether the development would cause ‘substantial’ or ‘less
than substantial’ harm.
7. The development plan consists of the London Plan 2016 (LP), Southwark
Council Core Strategy 2011 (CS) and the Southwark Plan 2007 (SP).
8. LP polices 7.4, 7.6 and 7.8 seek to ensure, amongst other things, that
development provide high quality design that has regard to the pattern and
grain of the existing spaces and streets; comprise details and materials that
complement the local architectural character; and that development affecting
heritage assets should conserve their significance by being sympathetic to their
form, scale, materials and architectural detail.
9. CS policy 12 seeks to ensure development preserves or enhance Southwark’s
historic environment, including conservation areas.
10. SP saved policies 3.12 and 3.15 seek to ensure that developments achieve a
high quality of both architectural and urban design; and that development
should preserve or enhance the special interest or historic character or
appearance of buildings or areas of historical or architectural significance.
11. Further guidance is given in the Technical Update to the Residential Design
Standards 2015 (RDS) which advises that roof extensions will not be
permitted where there is an unbroken run of butterfly roofs.
12. The Bermondsey Street Conservation Area (CA) has a traditional and historic
character, reinforced by a prevalence of London stock terraced buildings with
parapet roofs. Although there are examples of mansard roofs and other roof
structures in the immediate area, Nos 1 to 5 Green Walk form a distinctive
group of small 19th century two-storey terraced houses with an unbroken run
of butterfly roofs behind a continuous front parapet wall. The pleasing
uniformity of the roofline, when viewed from both the front and rear,
strengthens the cohesive and traditional appearance of this group of houses.
The terrace group in turn makes a positive contribution to the significance of
the heritage asset by contributing to its traditional and historic character and
appearance.
13. The proposal seeks, in part, the removal of the existing butterfly roof and the
construction of a slate clad dormer roof extension. Although it would be set
back from the front parapet wall so that it would not be readily visible from the
street, it would be visible in private views from a number of neighbouring
dwellings and gardens to the rear.
14. The introduction of the dormer extension, due to its height and bulk, would
interrupt the uniform run of butterfly roofs and notably diminish the cohesive
appearance of the terrace. Although a small ‘v’ shaped section of roof would
be kept this would not adequately mitigate the harm caused by the intrusion
2 The Framework makes it clear that decision-makers should identify and assess the significance of any heritage
asset and the impact of a proposal on the significance of the asset. When considering the impact of a development
on significance, great weight should be given to the asset’s conservation.
Appeal Decision APP/A5840/D/17/3176329
3
and bulk of the extension, which would look incongruous in relation to the
largely unaltered butterfly roofs of the remaining terrace.
15. As a result, I find that the development would cause unacceptable harm to the
character and appearance of the terrace group and, thus, would not preserve
or enhance the character or appearance of the CA. This finding of harm must
carry considerable importance and weight. I am satisfied that the harm caused
by the development to the heritage asset is less than substantial, because the
development concerned is small scale, but nevertheless permission should only
be granted if public benefits would outweigh the harm as detailed in the
Framework.
16. The development would benefit the appellant through the provision of
additional space. This, however, cannot amount to a public benefit of the
scheme, or outweigh the harm caused by the development to the character and
appearance of the CA.
17. The appellant argues that the harm to the terrace would not be substantial and
the scheme would not cause harm to the existing townscape or the established
building line or roof line when viewed from the street. Nonetheless the proposal
would cause appreciable harm to the cohesiveness of the terrace group, and it
is still in the public interest to preserve or enhance the character or appearance
of the CA in private views.
18. I note reference has been made to a number of similar proposals which have
been granted planning permission. However in the case of 109a Bellenden
Road and 32 De Laune Street there were pre-existing roof top structures,
either on the host building or within the terrace, thus the sites did not form
part of a distinctive group of unbroken butterfly roofs. I note planning
permission was also granted at 4 Sharsted Street and 8 De Laune Street,
however these sites are not located in a CA. Planning permission was also
granted in 1999 and 2005 for mansard roofs at 4 Hayles Street and 145
Evelina Road respectively; however both these decisions predate the LP
(2016), CS (2011), SP (2007), RDS (2015) and the Framework (2012). These
examples are therefore not directly comparable to the circumstances of this
appeal and, in any event, every case must be determined on its own merits.
19. For the reasons given above and having had regard to all other matters raised,
I conclude that the proposed development would cause unacceptable harm to
the character and appearance of the terrace and thus would not preserve or
enhance the character or appearance of the CA. The proposal is therefore
contrary to LP polices 7.4, 7.6 and 7.8, CS policy 12, SP saved policies 3.12
and 3.15, and advice contained in the RDS. Accordingly the appeal is
dismissed.
O. Blower
Appointed Person
£
Costs decision section
Costs Decision
Site visit made on 18 July 2017
by Oliver Blower MA (T&CP)
a person appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 11 September 2017
Costs application in relation to Appeal Ref: APP/A5840/D/17/3176329
3 Green Walk, London SE1 4TU
The application is made under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, sections 78,
322 and Schedule 6, and the Local Government Act 1972, section 250(5).
The application is made by Ms Rose Campbell for a full award of costs against of the
London Borough of Southwark.
The appeal was against the refusal of the Council to grant planning permission for the
“removal of the existing 'butterfly' slate roof; on the rear two thirds of the house the
construction of a slate clad dormer roof extension; and on the front third of the house
creation of a new private terrace at second floor behind the existing parapet wall”.
Decision
1. The application for an award of costs is refused.
Reasons
2. The Planning Practice Guidance advises that costs may be awarded against a
party who has behaved unreasonably and thereby caused the party applying
for costs to incur unnecessary or wasted expense in the appeal process.
3. It is clear from the Council’s decision letter that it considered the proposal
would harm the architectural integrity of the terrace and would result in less
than substantial harm to a designated heritage asset, with reference to
relevant development plan policies.
4. The officer’s report clarifies that the replacement of a butterfly roof would
cause substantial harm to the integrity of the building and wider terrace; and
that the appearance of the roofline, within the context of adjoining properties,
would not be enhanced. The use of the adjective ‘substantial’ does not
invalidate the Council’s underlying analysis or negate the finding of harm itself.
5. The appellant suggests that the Council’s reasoning is based on an in-principle
objection to alterations to butterfly roofs as the proposal would not be readily
visible from the street. The appellant’s Heritage and Townscape Assessment,
however, recognised that there was a need to assess the impact of the
proposal in private views and that the alterations would be visible from several
domestic properties.
6. It was therefore not unreasonable for the Council to consider the effect of the
proposal on the appearance of the roofline and, on finding harm to the integrity
of the terrace, determining whether this would result in ‘substantial’ or ‘less
than substantial harm’ to the designated heritage asset. On finding ‘less than
Costs Decision APP/A5840/D/17/3176329
2
substantial harm’ to the Conservation Area the Council correctly went on to
weight the harm against the public benefits of additional residential floor space,
as required by the National Planning Policy Framework.
7. The appellant also suggests that the Council has been inconsistent when
determining similar planning applications. This issue has been addressed in my
appeal decision, although I reiterate that the appellant’s examples differ
materially from the circumstances of the appeal proposal.
8. I therefore find that unreasonable behaviour resulting in unnecessary or
wasted expense, as described in the Planning Practice Guidance, has not been
demonstrated.
Oliver Blower
Appointed Person
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.