Retrospective application re details of approved extensions here- to retain the as-built clay-tiled open front canopy over the as-approved entrance doorway; also, to retain the existing as-built white rendered first floor gable frontage here; small roof amendment to yet-to-be-built rear single storey extension, reducing volume and introducing small area of red clay tiled roof to one side elevation, to mirror the as-approved other side elevation here
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Conversion/Use
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 20 June 2017
by R J Jackson BA MPhil DMS MRTPI MCMI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 06 July 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/R5510/D/17/3176314
104 Breakspear Road South, Ickenham UB10 8HF
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr Simon Boxall against the decision of the Council of the
London Borough of Hillingdon.
The application Ref 70259/APP/2016/4197, dated 14 November 2016, was refused by
notice dated 6 March 2017.
The development proposed is described as “retrospective application re details of
approved extensions here- to retain the as-built clay-tiled open front canopy over the
as-approved entrance doorway; also, to retain the existing as-built white rendered first
floor gable frontage here; small roof amendment to yet-to-be-built rear single storey
extension, reducing volume and introducing small area of red clay tiled roof to one side
elevation, to mirror the as-approved other side elevation here.”.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for single storey rear
extension, porch to front, conversion of roof space to habitable use to include,
two side dormers and conversion from hip to gable end at both front and rear,
with four new gable end windows involving demolition of existing porch and
raising of ridge height at 104 Breakspear Road South, Ickenham UB10 8HF in
accordance with the terms of the application, Ref 70259/APP/2016/4197, dated
14 November 2016, subject to the following conditions:
1) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance
with the following approved plans: 3c, 5c, 6a, 40, 41 and 42.
2) The tiles for the roof on the rear extension shall match those used
elsewhere on the existing building.
Background and Procedural matters
2. Planning permission was granted in 20141 for “single storey rear extension,
porch to front, conversion of roof space to habitable use to include, two side
dormers and conversion from hip to gable end at both front and rear, with four
new gable end windows involving demolition of existing porch and raising of
ridge height”. In 2015 a non-material minor amendment to that permission
under Section 62A of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
was approved2 “to allow for amendments to fenestration to rear at first floor
level and changes from tile to render to side/rear at first floor level”.
1 Council Ref: 70259/APP/2014/3055
2 Council Ref: 70259/APP/2015/3821
Appeal Decision APP/R5510/D/17/3176314
2
3. The development was not constructed in accordance with the approved plans,
and the appeal application was made to regularise this as well as proposing
further alterations. In the decision notice refusing planning permission the
Council described the development as “Amendments to fenestration at first
floor level, extension of canopy to front, amendment to roof of single storey
rear element involving alterations to elevations (Part-Retrospective)”.
4. In the Committee report on the application three alterations from the approved
scheme (that is the 2014 permission together with the 2015 non-material
minor amendment) are identified. These are an alteration on the northern side
of the rear single storey extension to provide a lean-to section of roofing to be
clad in tiles, the first floor front elevation rendered and painted white, and the
canopy (a tiled lean-to section on the front elevation above the ground floor
windows and doors) extended across essentially the whole width of the
property.
5. At the site visit it is was clear that the second and third alterations had been
completed but the first had not3. The development as a whole is for “single
storey rear extension, porch to front, conversion of roof space to habitable use
to include, two side dormers and conversion from hip to gable end at both front
and rear, with four new gable end windows involving demolition of existing
porch and raising of ridge height” which is the same description as the 2014
permission, except that the drawings are different. I have therefore used this
description in my formal decision.
6. The reasons for refusal only relate to the alterations to the front elevation and I
can see no objection to the proposed alteration to the rear, being the first
element described above.
Main Issue
7. In light of all of the above the main issue is the effect of the alterations to the
previously permitted development on the front elevation on the character and
appearance of the area.
Reasons
8. The appeal property is set in a row of detached dwellings set on a service road
behind Breakspear Road South with the service road being separated from
Breakspear Road South itself by a vegetated strip of land so that the properties
in this section cannot be readily seen from the main road. Generally the
properties are two-storeys in height although there are some bungalows. On
the front elevations the materials of the buildings follow a similar palette being
red/brown tiles and bricks, with white joinery to the windows.
9. As a bungalow which has been converted into a chalet style dwelling the appeal
property is somewhat different in form to the two storey dwellings which are
more vertical in design approach with their gables and, particularly, bay
windows.
10. The Council has referred to the Hillingdon Design and Accessibility Statement:
Residential Extensions (December 2008) (the HDAS). This was adopted
following public consultation and is written so as to provide clear and
unambiguous guidance on the types of residential extensions and alterations
3 This could be seen over the canopy from the bank on the opposite side of the road.
Appeal Decision APP/R5510/D/17/3176314
3
which are likely to be considered acceptable. As this is in accordance with
paragraph 58 of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework),
which indicates that decisions should aim to ensure that developments respond
to local character, reflecting the identity of local surroundings, I am able to
give this significant weight.
11. The HDAS states that the Council will normally refuse front extensions which
extend across the whole width as they are considered eye catching and change
the face of the building affecting the character of the building and the street
scene.
12. A canopy has been previously permitted across the majority of the width of the
property, with the only section not permitted being that on the right hand side
when facing the property, to create an open porch.
13. Because the property is now a chalet bungalow it has a somewhat different
character to the two–storey properties in the area not having the more vertical
design features described above. The extension of the canopy across the
whole width of the property reflects this different character, so that while is
different it is not discordant in the street scene and harmonises with the street
scene by creating a satisfactory visual relationship; harmony does not require
uniformity. In addition, the canopy pulls together the front elevation as an
architectural piece and is therefore not out of character with either the building
or street scene when considered as a whole.
14. Above is the white painted gable. As noted earlier in this decision the palette
of materials in the immediate area is predominantly red/brown and to that
extent the development as completed does stand out in the street scene.
However, as with the canopy extension, this is not discordant and harmonises
with the street scene. The ground floor, including the canopy, is constructed
from red/brown bricks and tiles which mean that the building fits within the
wider palette of materials, and the white painted render is a relatively small
area located within the triangle created beneath the apex of the gable. It
provides a contrast and creates interest.
15. As such I am satisfied that the alterations to the front elevation are not out of
character with the character and appearance of the area. Consequently it
complies with Policy BE1 of the Hillingdon Local Plan: Part One - Strategic
Policies (November 2012) which requires new development to improve and
maintain the quality of the built environment enhancing local distinctiveness
and a sense of place. It would also comply with Policies BE13, BE15 and BE19
of the Hillingdon Local Plan: Part Two - UDP Saved Policies (November 2012) in
that it would harmonise with the existing street scene, scale, form,
architectural composition and proportions, and would complement the
character of the area. While the proposal would be contrary to the precise
requirements of the HDAS I am satisfied that it complies with its wider aims of
ensuring that changes and extensions to the front of the house do not alter the
overall appearance of the house or dominate the character of the street. It
would also comply with paragraph 58 of the Framework as set out above.
Conditions
16. I have considered the conditions put forward by the Council against the
requirements of the national Planning Practice Guidance and the Framework.
As the development has been commenced there is no need for a condition
Appeal Decision APP/R5510/D/17/3176314
4
specifying by when development must be begun. However, due to the
prospective nature of the rear alteration I have imposed a condition specifying
the relevant drawings as this provides certainty and also imposed a condition
requiring the materials of the proposed alteration of the rear to match the tiles
on the existing building.
Conclusion
17. For the reasons given above I conclude that the appeal should be allowed.
R J Jackson
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.