Alterations to and extension of the existing ancillary building at first floor level with carport underneath, and the construction of a two-storey glazed extension to ‘link’ the host property and ancillary building
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 27 June 2017
by I Jenkins BSc CEng MICE MCIWEM
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 25 July 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/X1355/D/17/3176121
Bracken Cottage, Bank Foot, Shincliffe, DH1 2PD
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs A Whitley against the decision of Durham County
Council.
The application Ref DM/17/00222/FPA, dated 20 January 2017, was refused by notice
dated 21 March 2017.
The development proposed is alterations to and extension of the existing ancillary
building at first floor level with carport underneath, and the construction of a two-storey
glazed extension to ‘link’ the host property and ancillary building.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. I consider that the main issues in this case are: whether the proposal would be
inappropriate development in the Green Belt, having regard to any relevant
Development Plan policies and the National Planning Policy Framework
(the Framework); the effect on the character and appearance of the Shincliffe
Conservation Area; and, whether any harm by reason of inappropriateness,
and any other harm, would be clearly outweighed by other considerations, and
if so, whether this would amount to the very special circumstances required to
justify the proposal.
Reasons
3. The appeal site, which is situated within the Green Belt, is an area of land that
fronts onto the eastern side of the A177 between Shincliffe and High Shincliffe.
The southern section of the site comprises a paddock, while the northern
section contains Bracken Cottage, to the west, and a detached annexe to the
east. Between those 2 two-storey buildings, there are areas of hardstanding
and a planted area. To the north, the appeal site adjoins a former
hotel/restaurant complex, which has been converted to 4 dwellings, Nos. 1-4
Beaumont Court. I understand that, prior to its conversion to a dwelling,
Bracken Cottage was used as a holiday cottage(s) ancillary to the neighbouring
former hotel.
4. The proposal involves the construction of: a first floor offshoot from the
existing ancillary building with a carport beneath; and, a glazed link between
Appeal Decision APP/X1355/D/17/3176121
2
the new offshoot and the dwelling, comprising a conservatory at ground floor
level and a link corridor at first floor level.
5. Policy E1 of the City of Durham Local Plan, 2004 (LP), indicates that within the
Green Belt the construction of new building is inappropriate and will not be
permitted unless it is for one of a number of identified purposes. They include
limited extensions or alterations to existing dwellings where this is consistent
with LP Policy Q9. The meaning of ‘limited’ in this context is not defined by the
Policy.
6. In keeping with the view expressed by my colleague who determined appeal
Ref. APP/X1355/D/16/3157689, I consider that due to its proximity and
ancillary function, the detached annexe can be regarded as part of the existing
dwelling. Furthermore, in comparison with that existing dwelling, the footprint
and volume of the proposed extension would be significantly smaller. In that
particular context the proposal would constitute a limited extension of an
existing dwelling.
7. As regards compliance with LP Policy Q9, with reference to my findings below
regarding the likely impact on the character and appearance of the Shincliffe
Conservation Area, I consider that, in terms of its design, scale and materials,
the proposal would be sympathetic to the main dwellings as well as the
character and appearance of the area. The proposed development would
include 2 first floor windows facing the rear elevations and gardens of 3 of the
Beaumont Court dwellings. However, it appears to me that the garden areas
can already be overlooked by neighbouring windows and the intervening
distance between facing elevations would be sufficient to ensure that the
scheme would not materially harm the privacy of the residents of those
neighbouring dwellings. There is no evidence before me to show that the
proposal would be likely to lead to problems associated with multiple
occupation. I consider that the scheme would not conflict with LP Policy Q9.
8. Having regard to the matters set out above, in my judgement, the proposal
would not amount to inappropriate development under the terms of LP Policy
E1. However, that is not the end of the matter. The LP is now dated and in
such circumstances the Framework indicates that due weight should be given
to relevant policies in existing plans according to their degree of consistency
with the Framework. Whilst the approach set out in LP Policy E1 is consistent
in some respects with the Framework, I consider that it differs significantly in
others. In particular, the Framework identifies that the extension or alteration
of a building is regarded as inappropriate development in the Green Belt if it
results in ‘disproportionate additions over and above the size of the original
building’. As such, in my judgement, LP Policy E1 can be regarded as being out
of date.
9. The Framework indicates that where relevant policies of the Development Plan
are out-of-date, planning permission should be granted unless: any adverse
impacts of doing so would significantly and demonstrably outweigh the
benefits, when assessed against the policies of the Framework taken as a
whole; or, specific policies in the Framework, such as those relating to the
Green Belt, indicate that development should be restricted. I consider that the
second of these tests is of particular relevance in the Green Belt case before
me.
Appeal Decision APP/X1355/D/17/3176121
3
10. I turn then to the question of whether the proposal would result in
disproportionate additions over and above the size of the original building.
The Council has confirmed that the building now known as Bracken Cottage,
which was originally a stable block, was converted to 2 self-contained holiday
units prior to 2003. In 2003 planning permission was granted for a further
change of use to a dwelling. Since that time a number of extensions have been
added to the cottage, including a two-storey side extension and a front
entrance lobby, and a garage has been replaced by a double garage;
the structure now referred to as the detached annexe. I consider when taken
together with previous extensions, the proposal would be likely to result in a
substantial increase in the footprint and volume of the original building,
which would amount to disproportionate additions over and above the size of
the original building.
11. The appellants seek to rely on a section of the Framework which indicates that
construction of new buildings is not inappropriate in the Green Belt if it
constitutes ‘limited infilling or partial or complete redevelopment of previously
developed sites (brownfield land), whether redundant or in continuing use
(excluding temporary buildings), which would not have a greater impact on the
openness of the Green Belt and the purpose of including land within it than the
existing development’.
12. The proposal, which would link the existing detached annexe and the main
dwelling, would not extend beyond the southern building line on the previously
developed portion of the site. However, the proposed two-storey development
would infill the gap between the two at first floor level and partially infill it at
ground floor level. Notwithstanding that the visibility of the proposed
extension from public vantage points would be limited to glimpses from the
footpath that passes through woodland to the east of the site and parts of the
A177 to the west and southwest, I consider that the infill development would
consolidate built development hereabouts and diminish the openness of the
Green Belt, albeit to a limited degree.
13. In my judgement therefore, the proposal, which would result in
disproportionate additions over and above the size of the original building and
would harm the openness of the Green Belt, would constitute inappropriate
development under the terms of the Framework.
14. I conclude that whilst the proposal would not conflict with LP Policy E1, that
matter should be afforded little weight, as the Policy is inconsistent with the
terms of the more recent Framework and as such I consider that it can be
regarded as being out of date. I conclude overall, with reference to the terms
of the Framework, that the proposal would amount to inappropriate
development in the Green Belt.
The Conservation Area
15. Development within the Shincliffe Conservation Area is concentrated for the
most part in the built-up area of the village, which is situated some distance to
the northwest of the appeal site. Bracken Cottage and Nos. 1-4 Beaumont
Court comprise a relatively isolated cluster of development, the surroundings of
which, with the exception of the adjacent A177, are characterised by
countryside. Nos. 1-4 consist of 4 adjoining dwellings of different sizes, which
form an irregular shaped block of development up to 2 storeys high.
Appeal Decision APP/X1355/D/17/3176121
4
16. It would be possible to ensure, through the imposition of a suitable condition,
that the materials used in the external surfaces of the proposal would match
those of the existing dwelling. Whilst the proposal, linking the cottage and
annexe, would result in a more complex, L-shaped form, it would be in keeping
with the irregular form of the adjacent Beaumont Court development and
would remain smaller than that neighbouring block in terms of scale and mass.
Furthermore, as I have already indicated, the public vantage points from which
the proposal would be visible would be limited.
17. I conclude that the proposed development would satisfactorily preserve the
character and appearance of the Shincliffe Conservation Area and in this
respect it would accord with the aims of LP Policy E22 and the Framework, as
regards safeguarding the significance of designated heritage assets.
The neutral impact of the proposed development in this regard does not weigh
for or against the scheme.
Other considerations
18. Other than the matters addressed above, the appellants have not drawn any
other considerations to my attention.
Conclusions
19. I conclude that whilst the proposal would not conflict with LP Policy E1,
that matter should be afforded little weight, as the Policy is inconsistent with
the terms of the more recent Framework and as such I consider that it can be
regarded as being out of date. I conclude on balance that the proposal would
amount to inappropriate development which the Framework confirms is, by
definition, harmful to the Green Belt and should not be approved except in very
special circumstances.
20. The Framework also indicates that local planning authorities should ensure that
substantial weight is given to any harm to the Green Belt. Furthermore, ‘very
special circumstances’ will not exist unless the potential harm to the Green Belt
by reason of inappropriateness, and any other harm, is clearly outweighed by
other considerations. I attribute substantial weight to the harm associated with
the inappropriate development in the Green Belt and have found that the
impact of the scheme on the character and appearance of the Conservation
Area does not weigh for or against it. I conclude on balance that the harm to
the Green Belt by reason of inappropriateness is not clearly outweighed by
other considerations. Therefore, the very special circumstances necessary to
justify inappropriate development in the Green Belt do not exist and the
scheme does not amount to sustainable development under the terms of the
Framework. Whilst the proposal would not conflict with the Development Plan,
there are other material considerations which indicate that planning permission
should not be granted in this case.
21. For the reasons given above, I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
I Jenkins
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.