Raising height of dormer bungalow to create full storey height first floor level with new roof over
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 17 July 2017
by Caroline Jones BA (Hons) DipTP MTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 1 August 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/E2734/D/17/3174636
Rose Cottage, Tofts Lane, Follifoot HG3 1DY
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs Steve & Elspeth Smith against the decision of
Harrogate Borough Council.
The application Ref 17/00954/FUL, dated 1 March 2017, was refused by notice dated
27 April 2017.
The development proposed is raising height of dormer bungalow to create full storey
height first floor level with new roof over.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues are:
(i) Whether the proposed development would be inappropriate
development in the Green Belt having regard to the National Planning
Policy Framework and any relevant development plan policies.
(ii) The effect on the openness of the Green Belt and the purposes of
including land within it.
(iii) Would the harm by reason of inappropriateness, and any other harm
be clearly outweighed by other considerations. If so, would this
amount to the very special circumstances required to justify the
proposal.
Reasons
Whether or not the proposal would amount to inappropriate development
3. The appeal site lies within the village of Follifoot which is “washed over” by the
Green Belt. The proposal comprises raising the roof of the detached dormer
bungalow by approximately 2 metres to create a full two storey dwelling with
gable roof.
4. Section 9 of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) attaches
great importance to the Green Belt, the essential characteristics of which are
its openness and permanence. Paragraph 89 of the Framework establishes
that new buildings within the Green Belt are inappropriate, unless, amongst
Appeal Decision APP/E2734/D/17/3174636
2
other things, it involves the extension of a building. This is provided that it
does not result in disproportionate additions over and above the size of the
original building. The Framework defines the original building as the building
as it was on 1 July 1948.
5. The relevant development plans in this case includes the saved policies of the
Harrogate District Local Plan (2001) (LP) and the Harrogate District Core
Strategy DPD (2009) (CS). Policy SG4 of the CS relates to settlement growth
and aims to protect the countryside and Green Belt from inappropriate
development. Whilst Policy EQ2 of the CS relates to Green Belt, it provides no
detailed guidance to extensions to houses in the Green Belt. Policy H15 of the
LP concerns extensions to dwellings. The supporting text advises that in the
countryside an extension of the ground floor area by more than 50% will not
normally be permitted unless there is clear evidence of need for household
occupation. However the text is not policy. Given the absence of local policy in
relation to extensions within the Green Belt, for the purpose of this appeal, I
have attached greater weight to the Framework, as it is current national policy.
6. The property has previously been extended by way of a single storey rear
extension, the alteration from a hipped roof to a gabled, and the insertion of
two dormer windows which were granted permission in 19901. According to
the Council the previous extensions resulted in an increase in the ground floor
area of the original property by just over 50%. Whilst the proposal would not
result in any further additions to the ground floor, the Council state that
together with the previous extensions, the proposal would equate to more than
a 100% increase in volume. Whilst the appellants do not dispute this figure,
they assert that the proposals would only increase the floor area of the original
bungalow by approximately 48% and therefore Green Belt policy would not be
contravened.
7. The Framework does not define ‘disproportionate’ in terms of a specific
numerical threshold. However, assessing proportionality is primarily an
objective test based on size. The proposed increase in volume, taken together
with the previous extensions would increase the overall height, mass and bulk
of the dwelling. From the evidence before me, comparing the original dwelling
to the one that would result if the proposal were to go ahead would in my view
result in disproportionate additions over and above the size of the original
building.
8. The proposal would therefore be inappropriate development which is by
definition harmful to the Green Belt, contrary to the third bullet point of
paragraph 89 of the Framework. I attach substantial weight to this harm.
The effect of the development on the openness of the Green Belt and the purposes
of including land within it
9. The fundamental aim of Green Belt policy, as set out in paragraph 79 of the
Framework, is to prevent urban sprawl by keeping land permanently open. In
that the general bulk and volume would be increased by additional built
development the appeal scheme would have a greater effect on the openness
of the Green Belt which would conflict with the Framework. Having regard to
the scale of the proposals and its location surrounded by residential
development, I conclude that the loss of openness would be limited.
1 Planning application ref: 90/03229/FUL
Appeal Decision APP/E2734/D/17/3174636
3
10. The appeal scheme would be contained within the existing residential plot and
would not lead to any substantial encroachment on the countryside.
Accordingly, it is concluded that the proposed development would not conflict
with this purpose of the Green Belt as identified in the Framework. However,
this does not override the limited harm that it would cause to openness.
Other Considerations
11. I note that the Council has not raised any concerns in relation to the impact on
character and appearance of the area. The proposed extension would relate
well to the existing property both in design and materials. I agree that ample
space would be retained around the property and that it would not appear
overbearing or out of keeping in the street scene. In this regard, despite the
concerns raised above in relation to whether the extensions would be
disproportionate, which is a specific Green Belt test, I find that the proposal
would not have a harmful effect on the character and appearance of the host
property or the surrounding area.
12. Whilst I have not identified harm in respect of character and appearance, nor
do I find that the proposals would lead to a particular enhancement. I do not
agree that existing pitched roofs on the rear of the property are incongruous
and the dwelling as existing does not detract from the street scene. I therefore
regard the lack of harm in this respect as a neutral factor which doesn’t weigh
significantly for or against the appeal.
13. The appellants have drawn my attention to a number of similar extensions
which have been allowed by the Council in the immediate vicinity of the appeal
site. The permissions granted at Overdale and Summerfield, were determined
prior to the adoption of the CS and the publication of the Framework and I
therefore give them little weight in this regard.
14. I note that the application at Meadowsweet was determined in 2013, that the
proposals were very similar to those before me and that the Council took a
different approach in its consideration because the site was within the village.
However, I am of the opinion that the Council took the correct approach in the
current application rather than that at Meadowsweet. The village is washed
over by the Green Belt and it follows that any application should be assessed
against Green Belt policies. Whether or not a site is within a village does not
form part of the test as to whether an extension results in disproportionate
additions constituting inappropriate development. In light of this, I do not
consider that the permission at Meadowsweet should justify the harm to the
Green Belt by reason of inappropriateness or the limited loss of openness that
would arise from this proposal and I attach limited weight to this matter as a
result.
15. The appellants state that the modification of the roof over the rear extension
would address a long standing maintenance problem as a result of damp. Even
if this were the case, I am not persuaded that the proposed extension would be
the only option available to address such problems and I give this matter little
weight.
16. The letters of support received carry limited weight in favour of the proposal.
The lack of harm in relation to highway safety is a neutral factor neither
weighing for nor against the proposal.
Appeal Decision APP/E2734/D/17/3174636
4
Conclusion
17. The Framework indicates that inappropriate development is, by definition
harmful to the Green Belt and should not be approved except in very special
circumstances. In addition, any harm to the Green Belt carries considerable
weight and very special circumstances will not exist unless the potential harm
to the Green Belt by reason of inappropriateness, and any other harm, is
clearly outweighed by other considerations. In this case, I have found harm
from inappropriateness as well as a limited loss of openness to the Green Belt.
18. I have given only limited weight to the other considerations above. However,
the substantial weight to be given to Green Belt harm is not clearly outweighed
either individually or cumulatively by other considerations sufficient to
demonstrate the very special circumstances that are necessary to justify
inappropriate development in the Green Belt.
19. For the above reasons and taking all other matters into consideration, I
conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
Caroline Jones
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.