Removal of soil filled area of front garden and construction of a retaining wall to allow parking space to be moved from driveway to flat based parking space
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Flood Risk
Character & Appearance
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 27 June 2017
by Graham M Garnham BA BPhil MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 06 July 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/Q5300/D/17/3174659
112 Clay Hill, Enfield, London, EN2 9AE
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Dr Rachel Ryan against the decision of London Borough of
Enfield Council.
The application Ref 16/05288/HOU, dated 16 November 2016, was refused by notice
dated 13 February 2017.
The development proposed is removal of soil filled area of front garden and construction
of a retaining wall to allow parking space to be moved from driveway to flat based
parking space.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matters
2. The works for which planning permission is sought had been started at the
time the planning application was submitted, and apparently finished by the
time of my site visit. The retrospective nature of the proposal does not affect
my consideration of its planning merits.
3. I appreciate that, having first consulted the Planning Portal, the appellant was
not sure why planning permission was needed for her proposal. Nonetheless,
an application was submitted and an appeal subsequently lodged, which it is
my duty to decide.
Main Issues
4. I consider that these are the effects of the proposal on firstly, the character
and appearance of the site and the local street scene; and secondly, the
sustainable handling of surface water drainage and possible consequences for
the risk of flooding elsewhere.
Reasons
5. The appeal property is a semi-detached house on elevated ground above the
public highway. From photographic evidence, it seems that there used to be
an inclined driveway leading up to a narrow attached garage. There is now no
Appeal Decision APP/Q5300/D/17/3174659
2
garage and steps replace the drive. Instead a retaining wall has created a
single parking space on the property, adjoining and parallel to the footway,
accessed from a pre-existing crossover.
First main issue – effect on character and appearance
6. The wall and parking space (and associated steps) present a “hard” surfaced
frontage filling most of the width of the appeal site. This is in contrast the
prevailing frontages along Clay Hill, which mainly comprise well-weathered
low brick walls and attractive front garden planting. These give a pleasant
and mature suburban character to this section of the road. The contrast is
made more stark by the light colour of the paving on the parking space and in
particular of the retaining wall brickwork, which is of considerable height (1.6
metres). Some planting has been installed in a narrow bed at the top of the
retaining wall, which may hang down in due course, and at the top of the
former drive (now outside what appears to be living accommodation). No
details have been provided of this planting. Thus I am unable to gauge how
successful it might be in mellowing and softening the appearance of the site.
7. The proposed hardstanding would not be the only one along this stretch of
Clay Hill. I do not know if the others required or obtained planning
permission. Moreover, such features occur only on quite a small minority of
properties. By and large, these other existing features have succeeded in
retaining more noticeable amounts of planting than on the appeal site, and
thus have a less obtrusive appearance in the local street scene.
8. The works appear to have been carried out to a satisfactory standard of
construction. However, there is no scaled plan to show clearly what has taken
place. Consequently, even if I had been minded to grant planning permission,
there is no drawing to be referenced to show exactly what would be approved,
in the interests of certainty.
9. I conclude that the proposal detracts significantly from the character and
appearance of the site and the pleasant well-planted ambience of the local
street scene. This brings it into conflict with Policies DMD 8 & 37 in the
Enfield Development Management Document (2014); Core Policy 30 in The
Enfield Plan Core Strategy (2010); and Policy 7.4 in the London Plan (2015).
Among other things, these policies seek to ensure that hardstandings do not
dominate a residential frontage; and that proposals demonstrate good design
and respect the local context and quality of the built environment. The
propsoal would also fall short with regard to the high quality of design that
the National Planning Policy Framework recognises to be a core planning
principle of sustainable development.
Second main issue – effect on surface water drainage and flood risk
10. Adopted Policy DMD 59 (and associated policies) concern avoiding and
reducing flood risk. They require surface water to be managed as part of all
development to reduce run-off. One way of doing this is to prevent the loss of
permeable surfaces/areas of soft landscaping.
11. The proposal is small in scale and has a drainage channel along the boundary
with the footway. However, some soft landscaping has been lost, and I have
no information as to where the site drains. The appellant has not
Appeal Decision APP/Q5300/D/17/3174659
3
demonstrated that there would be no contribution to the risk of flooding
elsewhere arising from additional surface water run-off leaving the site. The
impact would no doubt be small, but the local development plan takes a firm
stance on this matter, reasoning that the cumulative effect of minor
development can contribute significantly to run-off and consequent flood risk
elsewhere. A lack of information means that compliance with this policy
cannot be properly assessed.
12. I conclude that the proposal lacks evidence of the sustainable handling of
surface water drainage and is therefore unable to show that it would not
contribute to the risk of flooding elsewhere. This is contrary to local
development plan Policies DMD 59, 60 & 61 and Core Policy 28, and to
general provisions on sustainable drainage in Policy 5.13 of the London Plan.
Overall conclusion
13. I have found against the proposal with respect to both main issues. To some
extent, this may be due to a paucity of supporting information. However, in
its absence, I have to decide the appeal on what is before me, and in the light
of a range development plan policies that weigh significantly against the
proposal.
14. Thus planning permission should be withheld and I dismiss the appeal.
G Garnham
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.