Dormer roof addition on rear for a loft conversion, to be created within a one and a half storey high section of the property. Alter rear pitched roof to suit

📊

See the success rate & inspector analytics

Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.

Sign Up Free

Technical Issues Heatmap

Heritage & Conservation
Extensions
Residential Amenity

Inspector’s Reasoning

Appeal Decisions Site visit made on 18 September 2017 by Jonathan Hockley BA(Hons) DipTP MRTPI an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government Decision date: 25 September 2017 Appeal A: APP/Y2620/D/17/3174231 2 White Lion Coach House, White Lion Street, Holt, Norfolk NR25 6BA  The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against a refusal to grant planning permission.  The appeal is made by Mrs C Bradbury against the decision of North Norfolk District Council.  The application Ref PF/16/1654, dated 6 December 2016, was refused by notice dated 1 February 2017.  The development proposed is a dormer roof addition on rear for a loft conversion, to be created within a one and a half storey high section of the property. Alter rear pitched roof to suit. Appeal B: APP/Y2620/Y/17/3172643 2 White Lion Coach House, White Lion Street, Holt, Norfolk NR25 6BA  The appeal is made under section 20 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 against a refusal to grant listed building consent.  The appeal is made by Mrs C Bradbury against the decision of North Norfolk District Council.  The application Ref LA/16/1675, dated 6 December 2016, was refused by notice dated 1 February 2017.  The works proposed are a dormer roof addition on rear for a loft conversion, to be created within a one and a half storey high section of the property. Alter rear pitched roof to suit. Decision 1. The appeals are dismissed. Main Issue 2. A main issue in both cases is whether the proposal would preserve the special architectural and historical interest of the Grade II listed building. An additional main issue for Appeal A is whether the proposal would have an adverse effect on the living conditions of the residents of Hornbeam Cottage, with regards to privacy. Reasons 3. The Grade II listed White Lion Public House occupies a prominent position close to the centre of Holt, opposite the junction of White Lion Street and Bull Street, and is located within the Holt Conservation Area (HCA). The building, which is no longer a public house but retains the hanging sign on its corner, is primarily cream rendered with a pantiled roof, with a distinctive plastered and moulded brick course between the ground and first floors on the west facing façade. Appeal Decisions APP/Y2620/D/17/3174231, APP/Y2620/Y/17/3172643 2 The northern side gable is located very close to the highway edge, and has a noticeable catslide roof flowing from the original pitch. 4. To the rear a 2 storey wing to the east has a flint dressed gable end with red brick quoins. This faces a yard and car parking area, which also features a former stable block. This block, mentioned in the listing and converted to residential use has a 2 storey central section with pantiled roof, flint upper floor, and primarily black painted wooden boarded ground floor. Distinctive semi-circular windows are located in the upper floor, with brick surrounds. To either side are single storey elements, with the right side rendered. The special interest of the buildings is largely defined by their siting in the heart of town, their designs and materials redolent of the local vernacular tradition, and their various distinctive architectural features. 5. Policies EN4 and EN8 of the Core Strategy1, together state that all development will be designed to a high quality which reinforces local distinctiveness, and preserves or enhances the character and appearance of designated assets. The Planning (Listed Building and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 requires special interest to be given to the desirability of preserving a listed building and any features or architectural interest it possesses. Section 72(1) of the same Act states that special attention must be paid to the desirability of preserving or enhancing the character or appearance of a conservation area. 6. The proposal seeks to convert the loft of the right hand side single storey element of the former stable block. The plans indicate that this would entail creating an opening in the end of the two storey section of the property into an existing loft room. A dormer window with a very slight pitch would be inserted into the rear elevation of the property, to provide 3 opaque glazed windows, with 2 rooflights inserted in the front roof plane. 7. The rear elevation is significantly less prominent in the street scene than the façade of the former stables, but can still be clearly seen from a car parking area to the south. From such views the proposed dormer window would appear ungainly and obtrusive, and would adversely affect the existing simple roofscape of the rear of the property. While the materials of the proposed dormer would be appropriate in isolation, the design and proposed length of the dormer would dominate the rear roof of the listed building. To the front, the introduction of 2 roof lights would also appear incongruous when there are no similar features on the forward facing planes of the stable block roof. 8. My attention is drawn to existing dormer windows on 2 other adjacent properties in the town. I noted these on my site visit. However, those above the building occupied by the Hospice shop are individual and smaller than those proposed in this case. Furthermore, in their siting they follow the window hierarchy in the building below. The individual dormers in the adjacent property to this are of an unfortunate appearance and as such are not necessarily a good example to follow. 9. The National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) makes it clear that when considering the impact of a proposed development on the significance of a listed building, great weight should be given to its conservation. Significance can be harmed or lost through alteration of the heritage asset, and as they are irreplaceable, any harm should require clear and convincing justification. For 1 North Norfolk Local Development Framework Core Strategy, 2008 Appeal Decisions APP/Y2620/D/17/3174231, APP/Y2620/Y/17/3172643 3 the reasons given above, I consider the proposal would result in harm being caused to the significance of this listed building and that in so doing it would fail also to preserve the historic character and appearance of the HCA, to which the property makes an important contribution. However, given the scale of the proposals, I am satisfied in this case that the degree of harm caused to the identified heritage assets would be less than substantial. 10. In such situations this harm should be weighed against the public benefits of a proposal, including securing the asset’s optimum use. The appellant notes that the proposal would constitute a proportionate extension, to the benefit and security of the listed building as a whole. However, the property appears to function as a dwelling already, and is superficially well maintained and seemingly in good repair. It has also not been shown that its continued occupation is in anyway dependent on the proposed development. As a consequence, what public benefits there might be are insufficient to outweigh the harm caused. 11. I therefore conclude that the proposal would cause less than substantial harm to the significance of this Grade II listed building, and would not preserve its special architectural or historic interest. The proposal would also neither preserve nor enhance the character or appearance of the HCA. It has not been shown that public benefits would outweigh this harm, and the proposal would conflict with the Framework and the Core Strategy policies EN4 and EN8. 12. The Council raise concerns over the proposed internal opening required to access the loft room. At the time of my visit the property was in use as a holiday cottage and it was not reasonable to gain direct internal access. However, given my conclusions above concerning the proposed external alterations it is not necessary for me to consider this matter further. Appeal A – Living Conditions 13. The rear of the property is sited very close to the rear garden of Hornbeam Cottage. This property is attached to the Grade II listed Wansbeck House. Its walled garden is of a fairly small size, but despite being surrounded by buildings on most sides does not appear to be significantly overlooked, with an existing roof light in the loft room of the appeal property angled away from the garden. 14. The proposal would introduce three new windows in the proposed dormer adjacent to the garden of Hornbeam Cottage. I note that all of the windows would be opaque glazed, with only one of them able to be opened for emergency purposes. Nevertheless, at such proximity to the garden of Hornbeam Cottage, the number and size of the proposed windows would give rise to a significant feeling of being overlooked when in the garden. This would be contrary to Core Strategy policy EN4, which states that proposals should not have a significantly detrimental effect on the residential amenity of nearby occupiers. 15. I therefore conclude that for Appeal A the proposal would have an adverse effect on the living conditions of the residents of Hornbeam Cottage, with regards to privacy. Appeal Decisions APP/Y2620/D/17/3174231, APP/Y2620/Y/17/3172643 4 Conclusion – Appeals A and B 16. I have concluded that the proposal would not preserve the special architectural or historic interest of the Grade II listed property, and nor would the character or appearance of the HCA be preserved or enhanced. Furthermore, I have concluded that for Appeal A the proposal would harm the living conditions of adjacent residents. Therefore, for the reasons given above, and having regard to all other matters raised, I conclude that the appeals should fail. Jon Hockley INSPECTOR
Expert Representation

Don't leave your appeal to chance.

Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.

Get Free Review How it works →