Extensions to rear/side to enlarge cottage along with the demolition of existing outbuildings and erection of a new one
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Ecology & Biodiversity
Rural Impact
Heritage & Conservation
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 3 July 2017
by John D Allan BA(Hons) BTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 18th July 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/H1705/D/17/3174159
The White Cottage, Popham Lane, North Waltham, RG25 2BD
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against
a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr Ellangovan against the decision of Basingstoke and Deane
Borough Council.
The application Ref 16/04383/HSE, dated 24 November 2016, was refused by notice
dated 27 January 2017.
The development proposed is extensions to rear/side to enlarge cottage along with the
demolition of existing outbuildings and erection of a new one.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matter
2. There is a slight discrepancy between the spelling of the appellant’s name on
the original application form and the appeal form. I have taken the name from
the application form and am satisfied that this is merely a typographical error
and that the applicant and the appellant are one and the same person.
Main Issues
3. The main issues are the effect of the proposal on: - (i) the character and
appearance of White Cottage and the wider area; (ii) highway safety; and (iii)
protected species.
Reasons
Character and Appearance
4. The existing property is a modest cottage that has been modified and extended
in a number of ways over time. Despite this, and its position close to the back
edge of the highway along Popham Lane, it has a fairly inconspicuous presence
within its countryside setting due to its low profile and articulated form.
5. The works proposed are considerably more involved than implied by the
original description of the development. Included amongst them are
substantial extensions to the existing dwelling. According to the Council’s
figures, which have not been disputed, the existing ground floor footprint
Appeal Decision APP/H1705/D/17/3174159
2
would be almost doubled by extending the building in the direction away from
Popham Lane, with the amount of accommodation at first floor level increased
from a modest and token 37sqm to an extensive living space totalling 208sqm.
The remodelled building would be covered with a new and wholly integrated
roof with a ridge-line around 3m higher than the tallest part of the existing,
which significantly spans only just a small part of the existing property at this
height.
6. The Council’s Design and Sustainability Supplementary Planning Document:
Extending Your Home and Replacement Dwellings (SPD), adopted February
2012, advises that the design and style of a proposed extension should
replicate the design and style of the original house and that the basic shape of
the extension should be subservient, and in proportion to the original building.
Whilst it goes on to recognise that in some circumstances it may not be
appropriate to design an extension which is truly subservient to the original
building in every respect, it states that the size and scale (width, depth and
height) of an extension remains critical in determining whether a development
will remain in proportion to the building. It further states that extensions
which are overly large in size and scale and are disproportionate in relation to
the original house will not be favoured.
7. In this instance the resulting building will show no semblance of the original
dwelling either in terms of its size, scale or appearance. It would replace a
modest cottage with a fairly substantial two-storey contemporary looking
home. Despite retaining elements of the existing building’s fabric, for all
intents and purposes the proposal would be akin to a replacement dwelling. In
countryside locations such as this, the SPD advises that proposals for new
dwellings that are significantly larger than the dwellings that they are replacing
will only be permitted in exceptional circumstances where the development can
be appropriately justified. It further advises that where an enlargement of
around 50% in size is proposed, such proposals should be accompanied by a
Landscape Impact Assessment, carried out in accordance with appropriately
published guidelines.
8. Whilst in this instance it may not be the case that a replacement dwelling is
proposed, the principles of the SPD insofar as they relate to the impact of new
residential development in the Countryside are relevant, particularly as I note
that part d to Policy S S6 – New Housing in the Countryside of the Basingstoke
and Deane Local Plan (LP) (2011 to 2029), adopted in 2016, deals with
replacement dwellings, and the extension to an existing dwelling, as one and
the same. This allows for such development provided the size of the proposal
would be appropriate to the plot and it would not be significantly visually
intrusive in the landscape.
9. In this instance, despite the proposed additional landscaping to the site’s
frontage that may restrict views deeper into the appeal site from Popham Lane,
the substantially enlarged scale of the dwelling would be clearly evident from
the adjoining highway. The position of the current dwelling immediately
adjacent to the roadside is typically reflective of its age and modest scale. The
contemporary form and size of the altered building would be unsympathetic to
this position and in this regard its siting would be inappropriate for the plot. In
addition, I have been provided with no information with regard to longer
distance views towards the property from the north where I cannot be certain
Appeal Decision APP/H1705/D/17/3174159
3
that the scale and form of the building would not be seen to impact upon the
wider character of the open countryside which extends in this direction.
10. In a similar vein, I saw that the three outbuildings, which sit next to each other
and deep into the plot, appear reasonably comfortable in their fairly open
surroundings. Whilst they are of no particular aesthetic merit, their traditional
pitched roofs and low rise scale is reflective of many such buildings within the
countryside. In contrast their replacement with an apparently brick built, two-
storey, box-like structure with an array of large windows at first floor level
would appear wholly out of context and alien within its fairly isolated and open
position. This too would have the potential to be seen from further afield
where it would be damaging to the rural character of the area.
11. Although there are a number of trees on the site, I am not persuaded that any
would be immediately affected or that, in themselves, they directly contribute
to the wider character of the countryside, which comprises typically large open
spaces beyond the roadside enclosures, a character feature that is true also for
the vast majority area of the appeal site. Nevertheless, for the reasons given,
I find that due to their size, scale and appearance, the proposed works to the
dwelling would be intrusive and harmful to the character and appearance of the
area, as would the erection of the proposed outbuilding in its own right. In this
regard the works to the house would be in clear conflict with LP Policy S S6,
and the development overall at odds with the aims and objectives of LP Policies
EM1- Landscape and EM10 - Delivering High Quality Development insofar as
they require all development proposals to be sympathetic to the character and
visual quality of the area and to respect the local environment. For these
reasons, the proposal would also fail to achieve the quality of design that is
required by the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework).
Highway Safety
12. There are currently two access points to the site from Popham Lane. The first
leads to an open area of parking directly adjacent to the road and immediately
to the north-west side of the dwelling. The second is a gated access to a track
that runs from the south-east corner of the plot to the three outbuildings. It is
proposed to remove the parking area to the side of the dwelling and to plant
additional landscaping along the roadside at this point. The second point of
access would become the main access to the site, leading to a new parking
area to the south-east side of the dwelling and onwards to the new outbuilding,
which would have three garage spaces at ground floor level and office space
above.
13. The appellant has argued that there would be an overall improvement to
highway safety by removing the existing parking area to the side of the
dwelling and creating a sole access where vehicles could enter and leave the
site in forward gear. However, I saw during my visit that, whilst there were a
few scattered vehicles along the track leading up to the outbuildings, the
access at this point did not appear to be in frequent use as both the surface
and junction with Popham Lane were overgrown, and the gate was padlocked.
14. I have been presented with no information relating to the current use of the
outbuildings or any recorded vehicle movements associated with them. In
addition, whilst it may be the case that cars may need to reverse into or out of
Appeal Decision APP/H1705/D/17/3174159
4
the existing parking area adjacent to the house, I have no evidence to suggest
that this has resulted in any recorded accidents along the highway.
15. The proposed arrangement would consolidate all traffic movements to the
house and detached outbuilding into one point of access, from where I saw
that visibility onto Popham Lane was restricted in both directions. To the
south-east views towards oncoming traffic is blocked by the corner of the
adjoining building which is part of the Wheatsheaf Hotel. To the north-west
visibility is restricted by vegetation to the front of the appeal site but which is
shown to be retained as part of the proposal.
16. From the limited information I have available to me, I find that there would be
an intensification of use to a poor and substandard access. Whilst the proposal
may remove one possibly sub-standard access, I find no justification to accept
the intensified use of another. I conclude therefore that the proposal would fail
to provide safe, suitable and convenient access for all potential users of the
site and that it would potentially compromise highway safety. In this regard it
would directly conflict with LP Policy CN9-Transport
Protected Species
17. The appellant has not disputed the Council’s view that the existing buildings
have the potential to provide roosting habitats for bats. I have no reason to
disagree that there is a reasonable likelihood of protected species being
present on or near to the site. Given also that the development would involve
work to the existing roof structure of the dwelling and demolition of the
outbuildings there is a risk that protected species may be adversely affected by
the proposal.
18. LP Policy EM4 – Biodiversity, Geodiversity and Nature Conservation states that
development proposals will only be permitted if significant harm to biodiversity
and/or geodiversity resulting from a development can be avoided. If that is
not possible the impact should be adequately mitigated and it be clearly
demonstrated that there will be no adverse impact on the conservation status
of key species, and no loss or deterioration of a key habitat type.
19. No ecological information has been provided. I have carefully considered the
appellant’s suggestion that this matter could be controlled by condition but I
am mindful that Circular 6/2005: Biodiversity and Geological Conservation -
Statutory Obligations and Their Impact Within The Planning System indicates
that where there is a reasonable likelihood of a protected species being present
and affected, a survey should be carried out before planning permission is
granted. It goes on to advise that surveys should only be required by
condition in exceptional circumstances. I have been presented with no
evidence to suggest that there are exceptional circumstances in this case. I
cannot be certain that a bat population would not be adversely affected by the
works and therefore the proposal would be contrary to Policy EM4.
Other Matters
20. I have considered the impact of the proposal upon the nearby Grade II Listed
Wheatsheaf Hotel but share the Council’s view that, due to the location of the
appeal site in relation to the primary location of the listed building, and the
separation distances involved, there would be no impact upon the setting of
Appeal Decision APP/H1705/D/17/3174159
5
the listed building, the significance of which as a heritage asset would be
unaffected.
21. The appellant has drawn comparison between the siting of parts of the
Wheatsheaf Hotel immediately to the back edge of the highway along Popham
Lane and the appeal proposal. However, despite the scale of the neighbouring
building in this position, its prominent corner setting at the entrance from a
main highway into Popham Lane, combined with its architectural and historic
significance, sets it notably apart from the appeal proposal, which is to replace
a modest cottage along the road’s frontage with a large and contemporary
extended dwelling.
22. I have noted the scale and appearance of other nearby buildings, including the
fairly large and apparently recently constructed property opposite, and the
vehicle repair garage slightly further along Popham Lane. However, both are
set back from the highway’s frontage such that each is viewed in its own
setting in relation to the road. Although the property opposite is large, I have
no details of the planning history to this site. The repair garage appears long
established and although not an attractive range of buildings they are
reasonably low rise and unobtrusive. Neither these, nor any other buildings
nearby compare with the circumstances at the appeal property.
23. The appellant has drawn my attention to an appeal decision in April 2016 for a
property known as Woodside within the administrative area of East Hampshire
District Council (Ref: APP/M1710/D/15/3138737). Whilst this related to
extensions and new roofs to an existing detached dwelling, I know nothing
more about the details of that case. Regardless, I note that the Inspector
concluded in that instance that the proposal would be appropriate in relation to
the character and appearance of its local area. That is not my conclusion in
this case, which in any event I have considered on its own merits.
24. The Council’s reference to the possible enlargement of the dwelling’s residential
curtilage is noted but this was not reflected by anything that I saw during my
visit and there is no evidence before me to suggest that this is the case.
Conclusions
25. For the reasons given, I find that the proposal would be harmful to the
character and appearance of the area. I have also found that there would be
potential for harm to highway safety and protected species. There would be
clear conflict with the development plan and the Framework. As such, and
having regard to all other matters raised, including the absence of any
objections from any interested third parties, the appeal is dismissed.
John D Allan
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.