Front open porch, ground and first floor extension with alterations
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 29 June 2017
by Lynne Evans BA MA MRTPI MRICS
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 10 July 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/R3650/D/17/3173996
Oakland View, 3 Courts Mount Road, Haslemere GU27 2PR
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against
a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by S Hitchcock against the decision of Waverley Borough Council.
The application Ref: WA/2016/2416 dated 5 December 2016, was refused by notice
dated 2 March 2017.
The development proposed is front open porch, ground and first floor extension with
alterations.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues in this appeal are:
a) the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of the
Haslemere Conservation Area, and
b) the effect of the proposal on the living conditions of the adjoining
neighbours at No 1 Courts Mount Road, with particular regard to over
shadowing and effect on outlook.
Reasons
Issue a) Conservation Area
3. The appeal property is a modest detached bungalow set back from the road
frontage on the south side of Courts Mount Road. The land slopes up steeply
both from east towards west and north towards south so that the existing
property is set at a higher level than the road.
4. The appeal property and surrounding area lie within the designated heritage
asset of the Haslemere Conservation Area. Section 72 (1) of The Planning
(Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 requires me to pay special
attention to the desirability of preserving or enhancing the character or
appearance of such areas. The Conservation Area is focussed on the town
centre and historic core, extending out to include the verdant surrounding
areas, encompassing the historic development of the settlement.
Appeal Decision APP/R3650/D/17/3173996
2
5. Sandrock and Courts Mount Road are narrow and very verdant roads with a mix
of properties styles, but predominantly with a cluster of tight knit properties on
the corner of the two roads with larger properties on more generous plots
moving further west along Courts Mount Road. Whilst it is seen in some street
scene views, and although of a more modern, suburban style than the adjoining
more historic buildings, its modest scale and set back from the road results in
the existing building being of limited impact in these views. Approaching from
the east up Courts Mount Road the elevated side elevation of No 5 Courts Mount
Road, with its distinctive arts and craft inspired design, is prominent in the
street scene.
6. The proposed extension, introducing a first floor with raised roof, and dormers
to the front and the rear would result in significantly greater bulk and massing
to the appeal building. It would be more visually intrusive in the street scene
and would uncomfortably compete in views with the side elevation of No 5
Courts Mount Road, when approaching from the east.
7. Contrary to the contentions of the Appellant, I did not find from my site visit
and the information before me that the proposed design would reflect the local
vernacular. It would, in my view, both in terms of its increased bulk and
massing as well as its detailed design, and particularly the proposed front
dormers including a full length door with Juliet balcony, appear as a visually
discordant element in the street scene. The proposal would relate neither to the
cluster of properties to the east nor to the larger and spaciously sited properties
to the west. As a result, it would, in my view, detract from the character and
appearance of the designated heritage asset of the Conservation Area.
8. I therefore conclude that the proposed development would not preserve the
character and appearance of the Haslemere Conservation Area. It would
therefore conflict with Policies D1, D4 and HE8 of the adopted Waverley
Borough Local Plan 2002 (Local Plan), the Haslemere Design Statement 2012
and the National Planning Policy Framework (Framework) and in particular
section 12, all of which seek a high quality of design which conserves the
historic environment and heritage assets. The Council has also referred to
Policies TD1 and HA1 of the draft Local Plan Part 1 (draft LP Part 1) which I
have also taken into account, although as the Plan is not yet adopted, this limits
the weight I can give to these policies.
9. Paragraph 134 of the Framework sets out that where a development proposal
will lead to less than substantial harm to the significance of the designated
heritage asset, this harm should be weighed against the public benefits of the
proposal. No public benefits have been advanced although work on the proposal
could lead to some small benefits to the local economy and would add to the
provision of residential accommodation. Whilst the harm to the designated
heritage asset of the Conservation Area would, in my view, be less than
substantial, the public benefits would not be sufficient to outweigh that harm.
10.The Appellant has drawn my attention to a number of other extensions which
have been permitted above the size of the original dwelling. Each proposal must
be considered on its individual merits. Furthermore, the principle of extending
the property is not, in itself, the issue but the particular proposal before me,
where I have found harm to the designated heritage asset.
Appeal Decision APP/R3650/D/17/3173996
3
Issue b) Living Conditions
11.The adjoining property to the east of the appeal property, at No 1 Courts Mount
Road, is a modest single storey cottage. Given the steep slope of the road,
climbing from east to west, No 1 is set at a much lower level than the appeal
property, but it is also set forward towards the road frontage. It has a sitting
room with windows facing west towards the appeal site and glazed opening to
the south into a covered area. There is a small garden area to the west of the
property. The neighbours would be aware of the extended property, particularly
from within their garden area, but given the siting of the proposal in relation to
the adjoining property, the principal outlook for the neighbours would remain
over the front garden of the appeal property. As a result I do not consider that
the proposal would materially harm the outlook for the neighbours at No 1.
12.Although a number of references have been made, there is no technical
information before me from either the Appellant or the Council in respect of the
Council’s objection in relation to overshadowing of No.1. However, given the
relationship and distance between the properties, even taking into account the
significant change in levels and orientation of the two properties, I do not
consider that the proposed development would result in material harm to the
neighbours’ living conditions, through overshadowing.
13.I therefore conclude that the proposal would not materially harm the living
conditions of the neighbours at No 1 Courts Mount Road, with particular regard
to loss of outlook and over shadowing. There would therefore be no conflict in
this regard with Policies D1 and D4 of the Local Plan, the Waverley Borough
Residential Extensions SPD (2010) and one of the Core Principles of the
Framework as set out at Paragraph 17, all of which seek to ensure a good
standard of amenity for all existing and future occupants of land and buildings.
The Council has also referred to Policy TD1 of the draft LP Part 1, which I have
also taken into account, although as the Plan is not yet adopted, this limits the
weight I can give to this policy.
14.I agree with the Council’s assessment that given the relationship between the
appeal property and No 5 to the west, and in particular the difference in levels
and the distance between properties, as well as the design of the proposal,
there would be no material harm to the living conditions at No 5, with particular
regard to loss of outlook and light. There is also sufficient distance between
properties that, in my view, the proposed increase in height and massing would
not harm the living conditions of the neighbours in Sandrock, through loss of
outlook and light. Were there no other matters of concern and planning
permission were to be granted, appropriate conditions could be imposed, to
ensure that proposed side windows and rooflights were sited and glazed to
ensure that privacy between neighbours would be respected.
Conclusion
15. I have concluded, under my first main issue, that the proposal would not
preserve the character and appearance of the Haslemere Conservation Area and
that the public benefits would not be sufficient to outweigh that harm. I have
taken into account the family related reasons for seeking the increased and
improved accommodation and whilst, under my second main issue I am
satisfied that there would be no harm to the living conditions of the neighbours
Appeal Decision APP/R3650/D/17/3173996
4
and particularly to the neighbours at No 1, these findings do not outweigh the
harm I have concluded under my first main issue.
16.The Appellant has drawn my attention to the manner in which the application
was determined by the Council but my assessment has focussed on the
planning merits of the proposal.
17.For the reasons given above and having regard to all other matters raised,
including in representations from surrounding neighbours as well as other
consultees, I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
L J Evans
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.