New pitched roof extension to existing flat roof with room in roof & dormers
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 14th June 2017
by Alison Roland BSc DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date:
Appeal Ref: APP/C2741/D/17/3173686
Glen Cottage, Stripe Lane, Skelton, York, YO30 1YJ.
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs Dunn against the decision of City of York Council.
The application Ref: 17/00262/FUL, dated 7 February 2017, was refused by notice
dated 5 April 2017.
The development proposed is new pitched roof extension to existing flat roof with room
in roof & dormers.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
2. The main issue in this appeal is whether the proposal amounts to inappropriate
development in the Green Belt (GB) and if so, whether the harm by reason of
inappropriateness and any other harm, (including harm to the
character and appearance of the area), is clearly outweighed by other
considerations, so as to amount to the very special circumstances necessary to
justify the development.
Reasons
3. The National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) states that extensions
to buildings in the GB are not inappropriate development provided that they do
not result in disproportionate additions over and above the size of the original
building. Policy GB4 of the City of York Draft Local Plan Incorporating the 4th Set
of Changes (2005) (LP) is concerned with alterations and extensions to
dwellings in the countryside and GB. Criterion c) requires them to be small in
scale compared to the original dwelling. The explanatory text states that in
general terms a planning application to extend a dwelling by more than 25% of
the original footprint will be considered to be a large scale addition and resisted
accordingly. Policy GB1 allows for the limited extension of existing dwellings
provided they would not detract from the open character of the GB. As this plan
was not adopted, it limits the weight I can attach to these policies. Nonetheless,
the objective of GB4 to restrict the scale of residential extensions in the GB is
broadly consistent with the advice in the Framework and it therefore carries
Appeal Decision APP/C2741/D/17/3173686
2
some weight. Policy GB1 is inconsistent with the Framework in that it refers to
the existing and not original dwelling, and I therefore consider it carries limited
weight.
4. In its own right, the proposed first floor addition would represent a modest
addition to the property above an existing flat roofed element at ground floor.
However, to view it in isolation without reference to the previously approved
and built extensions (application Ref: 16/00116/FU) would not be correct (nor
Framework compliant), since such an approach could potentially allow a number
of incremental additions to a property which cumulatively could amount to a
disproportionate addition. The reference to original building the Framework and
linked definition of that term in Annex 2 lends credence to this view.
5. I have been supplied with the previously approved drawings for application Ref:
16/00116/FU and was able to view the extensions as built at my visit. There is
disagreement between the parties as to what constituted the original building.
The Council take the view (with reference to drawing No 15/27/01 dated
December 2015), that it comprised the lounge and kitchen to the ground floor
with bedroom 2 and bedroom 3 above. The appellant believes it included the
single storey wing (bathroom and store) to the East elevation. It is difficult to
reconcile these differing accounts on the information available, but I do not
consider the difference has any bearing on the outcome of the appeal.
6. The extensions as built have imparted a significantly greater bulk to the
appeal property (particularly in the case of the rearwards extension) and the
appellant concedes that they exceeded the 25% allowance in Policy GB4. The
appeal proposal would add still further to the bulk of the property, most
markedly at first floor level and whilst its frontage width would not increase at
ground floor level, the addition of the first floor above would make the
property appear appreciably wider. Even adopting the appellant’s
interpretation of what constituted the original building, it is clear to me that
the appeal proposals, taken together with the previous additions to the
property, would amount to a disproportionate addition. Added to this harm
would be a loss of openness arising from the substantial increase in size of the
resultant property. Even taken in isolation, the proposal would lead to some
loss of openness. This would be localized, but would add to the harm by
reason of inappropriateness.
7. The proposal would thus amount to inappropriate development in the GB and
would conflict with the advice in the Framework, Policies GB1 and GB4 of the
LP and Design Guideline 4 of the Skelton Village Design Statement (VDS)
which relate to development in the GB. The appellant questions whether the
latter document is relevant, but the introduction on page 3 clearly states that
“It concerns anyone considering development–large or small–in, or in the
surroundings of, Skelton village” and the Parish map on page 2 includes the
appeal site. I appreciate its status as an Interim Planning Statement to the
unadopted Local Plan limits the weight I can attach to it, but it is nonetheless
relevant as a material consideration.
8. Paragraph 87 of the Framework states that inappropriate development is by
definition, harmful to the GB and should not be approved except in very
special circumstances. Paragraph 88 states that the decision maker should
ensure that substantial weight is given to any harm thereto.
Appeal Decision APP/C2741/D/17/3173686
3
9. In addition, I consider that the extension in combination with the previously
built extensions would be excessive in scale and would visually overwhelm the
appeal property, to the detriment of its character and appearance. In this
respect, it would conflict with the advice in the House Extensions and
Alterations Draft Supplementary Planning Document (2012) (SPD). This
advises amongst other things, that side extensions should be subservient to
the original dwelling, with the ridge height being lower than the original and
the front elevation should be set behind the building line. It would also conflict
with criterion a) of Policy GP1 of the LP which requires proposals to respect or
enhance the local environment and criterion b) of Policy H7 which requires the
design and scale of residential extensions to be appropriate in relation to the
main dwelling.
10.Whilst the previous side extension incorporated a small step down in the
ridge, as would the appeal proposal, the effect would be insufficient to render
them (in combination) appearing subservient to the original property. I
appreciate the appellant’s point that the SPD is a draft document, but it was
subject to public consultation prior to adoption by the Council’s Cabinet and
carries some weight as a material consideration.
11.The appellant advances other considerations in favour of the appeal. The
garden of the appeal property is largely surrounded by trees and hedgerows
and an outbuilding dominates the site frontage. Whilst I do not disagree with
that assessment, the frontage of the dwelling is nonetheless visible from
Stripe Lane and the change from the original scale of the dwelling to its
resultant appearance were the appeal to proceed, would be readily
discernible, particularly following leaf fall in winter. I therefore give this factor
limited weight.
12.My attention has been drawn to a consent granted for a replacement dwelling
nearby which the appellant says is around 50% larger than the dwelling it
replaced. However, in the absence of any detailed information about that
application, it is difficult to make a meaningful comparison with the appeal
proposal which I must in any event, consider on its merits. I therefore attach
very limited weight to that particular point.
13.It is also contended that the proposal would not conflict with any of the
purposes of including land in the GB and I agree. However, that is not the
correct parameter in the consideration of extensions to buildings, which is the
case here. I also do not accept that the correct test is to assess the proposal
against the existing appearance of the building, for the reasons outlined
earlier in my decision.
14.It is contended that the provision of a pitched roof over the existing flat
roofed part of the building would effect a visual improvement. However, the
latter being single storey, is visually discrete and not visible above the
frontage hedgerow, whereas the proposal would be. I therefore attach limited
weight to this issue.
15.I have found on the main issue that the proposal would amount to inappropriate
development in the GB and that it would also give rise to some loss of openness
thereto. I attach substantial weight to these findings. There would be added
harm caused to the character and appearance of the original cottage by virtue
of it appearing overwhelmed with extensions. For the appeal to succeed, the
Appeal Decision APP/C2741/D/17/3173686
4
combined weight of the other considerations raised by the appellant must be
sufficient to clearly outweigh the totality of harm identified. Overall, I conclude
that the other considerations raised by the appellant, even taken together,
would not clearly outweigh the harm identified. It follows that the very special
circumstances necessary to justify the development do not exist. The appeal
therefore fails.
ALISON ROLAND
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.