Double carport for Chestnut Cottage
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Rural Impact
Ecology & Biodiversity
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decisions
Site visit made on 26 July 2017
by Grahame Gould BA MPhil MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 15th August 2017
Appeal A Ref: APP/Z3825/D/17/3169769
Chestnut Cottage, Water Lane, Storrington RH20 3LY
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs Julian Aviss against the decision of Horsham District
Council.
The application Ref DC/16/1905, dated 18 August 2016, was refused by notice
dated 30 November 2016.
The development proposed is described as ‘double carport for Chestnut Cottage’.
Appeal B Ref: APP/Z3825/W/17/3171901
Chestnut Cottage, Water Lane, Storrington RH20 3LY
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mrs Jaye Ford against the decision of Horsham District Council.
The application Ref DC/16/1904, dated 18 August 2016, was refused by notice
dated 21 December 2016.
The development proposed is described as ‘replacement dwelling, improved access and
with one new dwelling on site adjacent to Chestnut Cottage’.
Decision
1. Appeals A and B are dismissed.
Procedural Matter
2. Appeal A would involve the siting of a double carport to the rear of Chestnut
Cottage (the cottage) and would also include the use of a new engineered
drive that would provide access to the carport. Appeal B would involve the
demolition of the dwelling contained in the converted garage (the lodge),
sited to the side of the cottage, and its replacement with two detached
houses. The new houses would also use the new drive.
3. While the appeals involve different developments, they concern the same host
property and are clearly related to one another. I have therefore considered
the appeals concurrently.
Main Issues
4. The main issues are:
the effect of the development on the character and appearance of the
area and the setting of the cottage as a grade II listed building
– appeals A and B;
Appeal Decisions APP/Z3825/D/17/3169769 and APP/Z3825/W/17/3171901
2
whether the site would be a suitable location for an additional dwelling –
appeal B;
the effect of the carport and drive on the living conditions of the
occupiers of School Cottage, with particular regard to noise – appeal A;
and
the effect of the new houses on the habitat for protected species –
appeal B.
Reasons
Character and Appearance and listed building setting – appeals A and B
5. The cottage is one half of a pair of semi-detached houses, the other half being
School Cottage. The cottages date from the eighteenth century and were
originally built as the village school. The cottage is set in a wide plot and the
lodge, which is a building dating from the 1970s, occupies part of that plot.
The cottage and the lodge share a drive and parking area, served by a single
vehicular access point.
6. While there is some residential ribbon development along Water Lane at this
point and an active quarry directly opposite, the lane has a verdant
appearance, with it being lined by hedges and trees. While the infill
development at 1 to 4 Angell Sands (Nos 1 to 4) has a more urban
appearance, I found it to relate more closely with the continuous ribbon of
dwellings fronting Washington Road on its approach to the centre of
Storrington. As Angell Sands have replaced ‘several light industrial units’ that
development is not directly comparable with the proposals subject to appeals
A and B. The residential development on Water Lane, beyond Nos 1 to 4, is of
a less intense and looser form than that on Washington Road and is consistent
with its rural location.
7. The house that would replace the lodge and the extra house would both be
significantly larger than the lodge and their provision would involve the
cottage’s grounds being formally sub-divided into three plots. The lodge is
modestly scaled and I found there to be nothing particularly objectionable
about its appearance, such as to warrant it being replaced by two much larger
houses. I consider that the development would result in the cottage’s
grounds having a much harder and more urban and regimented appearance,
which would be incompatible with the low density, rural character of Water
Lane. The trees and evergreen hedge along the site’s frontage would provide
some screening for the house replacing the lodge. However, the extra house,
because of the sloping nature of Water Lane and its proximity to the vehicular
access would not benefit to the same degree from the presence of the
roadside trees and hedging.
8. The formation of the new drive would contribute to the hardening in the area’s
appearance, with it being beyond the cottage’s garden in an area that has not
been fully restored following the closure of a former quarry. Although the
drive would occupy an area of scrub I nevertheless consider it would be at
odds with the area’s rural character. I also consider that the formation of the
drive would not be directly comparable with the existing drive and parking
area, which I found to have an appearance that is compatible with the scale of
the cottage and the lodge.
Appeal Decisions APP/Z3825/D/17/3169769 and APP/Z3825/W/17/3171901
3
9. I am therefore of the opinion that the developments in their totality would be
harmful to the rural character and appearance of the area, harm that could
not be overcome by the imposition of reasonable planning conditions.
Although the site constitutes previously developed land, I consider that the
benefit arising from the reuse of such land is outweighed by the harm that I
have identified.
10. The setting of the cottage, as a listed building, is characterised by the
openness of its garden grounds. The extent of those essentially open grounds
is to be expected of a house in a rural location such as this and it is the
openness of the cottage’s grounds that is of significance to this listed
building’s setting. While the lodge is an independent dwelling, given its siting,
modest scale and design, it has the appearance of being clearly subservient to
the cottage. The replacement house would be much larger than the lodge and
it, together with the extra house and the new drive, would collectively
significantly reduce the openness of the cottage’s grounds. The developments
would change the character of this cottage’s grounds from garden land to a
much more intense residential development. I consider that the scale of the
developments would dominate the cottage rather than being subservient to it.
11. I therefore find that there would be significant harm to the listed building’s
setting and that the listed building’s setting would not be preserved.
12. For the reasons given above I conclude that the development subject to
appeals A and B would be harmful to the character and appearance of the
area and would fail to preserve the setting of a listed building. The
developments would therefore be in conflict with Policies 2, 25, 26, 32 and 33
of the Horsham District Planning Framework (excluding South Downs National
Park) of 2015 (the HDPF). That is because the developments would: not
conserve or enhance the rural character of the area; fail to complement the
heritage value of the site and the sense of space around it; and be
unsympathetic of its surroundings. There would also be conflict with Policy 34
of the HDPF because the developments would fail to retain or improve the
setting of a heritage asset.
13. With regard to the provisions of paragraphs 132 to 134 of the National
Planning Policy Framework (the Framework), I consider that while there would
be significant harm to the setting of the cottage, the overall harm to the listed
building would be less that substantial, given that neither development would
alter the listed building’s physical fabric. That being said I consider that there
would be no public benefits, including the improvement to the visibility for
drivers emerging onto Water Lane, weighing significantly in favour of the
developments. The absence of substantial harm to the listed building, in the
Framework’s terms, however, does not usurp the statutory duty to pay special
regard to the desirability of preserving its setting.
Suitability of the location for an additional house – Appeal B
14. As the development subject to appeal B would involve a net increase of one
dwelling, I consider it is the extra dwelling, as opposed to the replacement
house, which falls to be considered under this issue.
15. The extra house would be located a little beyond Storrington’s built-up area
boundary (BUAB). Storrington is a small town/larger village for the purposes
of the HDPF’s settlement strategy. The extra house would therefore be in a
Appeal Decisions APP/Z3825/D/17/3169769 and APP/Z3825/W/17/3171901
4
location where new development is discouraged by Policies 2, 3, 4 and 26 of
the HDPF, with the growth strategy across the Council’s area seeking to focus
new development in the main settlements rather than the countryside.
Policy 26 indicates that the rural character and undeveloped nature of the
countryside will be protected against inappropriate development. Policy 26
goes onto state that any development must be essential to its countryside
location and should: support the needs for agriculture and forestry; enable
the extraction of minerals or the disposal of waste; provide for quiet informal
recreational use; and enable the sustainable development of rural areas.
16. The extra house would not meet the first three of the above mentioned
exceptions referred to in Policy 26 of the HDPF and, as I have concluded
above, this development would also cause unacceptable harm to the character
and appearance of the area. There would therefore be conflict with Policy 26
of the HDPF. I am mindful of the fact that there has been a recent substantial
development at Millford Grange1 to the east of Water Lane and that
Nos 1 to 4 are of fairly recent construction. However, both of those
developments were granted planning permission prior to the HDPF’s adoption
and it is necessary to determine appeal B having regard to the extant
development plan policies. While the extra house would be closer to the
centre of Storrington than the houses at Millford Grange, I consider that factor
to be of little consequence. That is because not only is there no rural needs
justification for the extra house, but its construction would also be harmful to
the appearance of the area, as well as the setting of a listed building.
17. I therefore conclude that this would be an unsuitable location for an extra
house, with there being conflict with Policies 2, 3, 4, and 26 of the HDPF.
Living conditions for the occupiers of School Cottage – Appeal A
18. When regard is paid to the likely frequency of the drive’s use and the degree
of physical separation there would be between it and School Cottage and its
garden, I consider that the use of the drive would not give rise to levels of
noise that would be disturbing for the occupiers of School Cottage.
19. On this issue I conclude that the development subject to appeal A would not
be harmful to the living conditions of the occupiers of School Cottage. There
would therefore be no conflict with Policy 33 of the HDPF because the noise
associated with the use of the carport and the new drive would not cause
harm to the living conditions (amenity) of the occupiers of School Cottage.
Protected species – appeal B
20. The ecological evidence submitted by the appellant with appeal B includes
species specific reports for bats, dormice and reptiles. The bat report
identifies the lodge as having high bat roosting potential, on an occasional
basis, by a small bat population. Some mitigation for bats would therefore be
required. Details of a bat mitigation strategy are contained in the fifth
appendix to the bat report and there is no suggestion from the appellant’s
ecologist that it would not be possible to provide an appropriate level of
mitigation for roosting bats. During the course of the dormice survey no
dormice were found to be present, although further surveying has been
recommended by the appellant’s ecologist.
1 Subject to planning application DC/11/1457 and allowed on appeal (APP/Z3825/A/12/2176793)
Appeal Decisions APP/Z3825/D/17/3169769 and APP/Z3825/W/17/3171901
5
21. The survey for reptiles identified the presence of slow-worms, grass snakes
and common lizards, respectively at medium, low and medium populations.
Details of the outline of a reptile mitigation strategy are included in the reptile
report and there is nothing within this report that suggests that appropriate
mitigation could not be provided.
22. The Council has submitted no evidence of its own demonstrating that
appropriate mitigation could not be provided commensurate with the
populations of bats, dormice and reptiles frequenting the site. On the
available evidence I therefore conclude that the development subject to
appeal B would not cause unacceptable harm to the habitat for protected
species. I therefore find that the development subject to appeal B would not
conflict with Policies 2 and 31 of the HDPF because there would be no
unacceptable harm to the area’s biodiversity.
Other Matters
23. I recognise that the development subject to appeal B would not be harmful to
the living conditions of the occupiers of any neighbouring dwellings and that
there would be no adverse effect on highway safety. Those are matters
weighing in favour of the development, however, I find them to be
outweighed by the harm that I have identified.
Conclusions
24. I have found that there would be no unacceptable harm to the habitat for
protected species (appeal B) and that the noise associated with the use of the
new drive, as an access to the carport, would not harm the living conditions of
the occupiers of School Cottage (appeal A). However, I have found that both
developments would cause unacceptable harm to the character and
appearance of the area and would fail to preserve the setting of the cottage
as a listed building. I have also found that this would be an unsuitable
location for an extra house. I therefore consider that the developments would
be unsustainable, when the HDPF is read in the round.
25. I therefore conclude that appeals A and B should both be dismissed.
Grahame Gould
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.