Described on the application as ‘Erection of stable & ancillary facilities on the same footprint as the (recently) previously demolished stable with ancillary kennel facilities which was an element in the previous stable
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Character & Appearance
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 2 May 2017
by J C Clarke BSc(Hons) BTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 30 May 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/R1010/D/17/3168460
The Laurels, Ruthyn Avenue, Barlborough, Chesterfield, Derbyshire
S43 4EX
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mrs Julia Manfredi against the decision of Bolsover District
Council.
The application Ref 16/00468/FUL, dated 24 October 2016, was refused by notice dated
6 December 2016.
The development proposed is described on the application as ‘Erection of stable &
ancillary facilities on the same footprint as the (recently) previously demolished stable
with ancillary kennel facilities which was an element in the previous stable’.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural matters
2. The description of development given on the Council decision notice differs
from that on the application. As it is unclear that the appellant agreed to this
change I have used the description given on the original application in my
decision.
3. I understand that the new building subject to appeal had already been erected
when the application was submitted. This has not affected my consideration of
the appeal, which I have determined on its planning merits. At the time of my
site visit, the building had yet to be brought into use and proposed changes to
its elevations, shown on drawing number JBA.3531.103, had to be
implemented. As these proposed revisions are of a minor nature I have
referred to the new building in the present tense in my decision.
4. The Council has expressed concerns that the building subject to appeal could
be used in the future as a dwelling. However, the submitted details show that
it would be used to provide stables and kennels connected with the use of the
adjacent dwelling. I have determined the appeal on this basis.
Main Issue
5. The main issues are:
(a) Whether or not the building subject to appeal constitutes inappropriate
development in the Green Belt;
Appeal Decision APP/R1010/D/17/3168460
2
(b) The effect of the building on the character and appearance of the
countryside; and
(c) If the building constitutes inappropriate development in the Green Belt,
whether the resultant harm by reason of inappropriateness, and any
other harm, are clearly outweighed by other considerations so as to
amount to the very special circumstances necessary to justify its
approval.
Reasons
Policy Context
6. The adopted development plan, with which my decision must accord unless
material considerations indicate otherwise, comprises the saved policies of the
Bolsover District Local Plan (BDLP) 2000. The National Planning Policy
Framework (the ‘Framework’) forms an important material consideration.
7. The Council’s reason for refusal claims that the development conflicts with
saved policy HOU9 of the BDLP. However, as the appellant does not propose to
use the building as a dwelling this policy is not applicable. I address the other
policies referred to in the Council’s decision later.
Inappropriate development
8. Paragraph 89 of the Framework establishes that the erection of new buildings
in the Green Belt is, subject to exceptions set out in its 6 bullet points,
inappropriate.
9. Under bullet point 4 of paragraph 89, the ‘…replacement of a building…’ is not
inappropriate provided ‘…the new building is in the same use and not materially
larger than the one it replaces’.
10. The building subject to appeal occupies land that previously accommodated an
earlier building which has been demolished. The appellant’s photographs
confirm that the earlier structure was built in brick and block and had a partly
tiled roof. I have no reason to doubt that the new building is intended to be
used for similar purposes to that earlier structure and forms a replacement for
it.
11. However, bullet point 4 does not expressly cover the replacement of a building
which, as in this case, no longer exists. The submitted details also indicate
that a substantial length of the roof at the western end of the earlier building
was notably lower than the equivalent area within the new building. Whilst the
appellant has described the new building as being on the same footprint as the
earlier one he has also stated that it is 0.45 metre wider1. These points
collectively indicate that the new building is materially larger than the previous
building. For these reasons, the new building does not fall within the scope of
bullet point 4 of paragraph 89.
12. Under bullet point 6 of paragraph 89, the redevelopment of previously
developed sites is not inappropriate provided it would not have a ‘… greater
impact on the openness of the Green Belt and the purpose of including land
within it than the existing development’. Having regard to the use of the site
and the previous existence of a building on it, it is likely to be a previously
1 letter to the Council dated 5 August 2016
Appeal Decision APP/R1010/D/17/3168460
3
developed site. However, as the previous building has been demolished it does
not comprise part of the ‘existing development’ in the context of bullet point 6.
The development has also created a new structure which has impacted upon
the openness of the Green Belt. Given these circumstances, the development
falls outside the exception set by bullet point 6.
13. Under bullet point 2 of paragraph 89, provision of a building to support an
outdoor recreational use is not inappropriate in the Green Belt in certain
circumstances. Saved policy GEN9(2) of the BDLP identifies small stables as
being acceptable in principle in such areas. In this context I note that the new
building would provide 2 to 3 stables connected with the appellant’s
landholding of 2.54 hectares. However, as much of the new building would be
used as domestic kennels connected with the adjacent dwelling, its use as a
whole would not fall within the range of purposes supported by bullet point 2 or
saved policy GEN9(2).
14. The building also does not fall within the scope of any of bullet points 1, 3 or 5
of paragraph 89.
15. Having regard to all these points, I conclude that the building subject to appeal
constitutes inappropriate development in the Green Belt as defined in the
Framework and policy GEN9 of the BDLP.
Character and appearance
16. The building subject to appeal is located within the countryside, at the rear of a
small group of buildings. Whilst it is close to the M1 motorway, it is not
prominently visible from this or other public viewpoints.
17. The Council has raised concerns that the building is not of a suitable design or
mode of construction for a rural setting. However, rural buildings can suitably
take many forms. Whilst the building has a substantial footprint, and
notwithstanding my earlier comment regarding openness, it has a relatively low
lying form compared to the nearby large dwelling. Its rendered elevations and
pitched roof do not look out of place alongside this or the other existing
buildings at the site.
18. I conclude that the building has a neutral effect on the character and
appearance of the area. Its approval would not materially conflict with relevant
provisions of policy GEN2 or ENV3 of the BDLP relating to this matter.
Other considerations
19. I have noted the points raised by the appellant related to the history of the site
and her correspondence with the Council. However, these do not include any
substantive planning considerations to add to those which I have considered
earlier.
Planning balance and conclusion
20. I have found that the building subject to appeal constitutes inappropriate
development in the Green Belt. Paragraph 87 of the Framework establishes
that inappropriate development is by definition harmful to the Green Belt and
should not be approved except in very special circumstances. Paragraph 88
requires that substantial weight be given to such harm.
Appeal Decision APP/R1010/D/17/3168460
4
21. I have also found that the building has a neutral effect on the character and
appearance of the area. However, no other substantive considerations have
been identified. Consequently, I find that other considerations in this case
would not clearly outweigh the harm that I have identified. Therefore, the very
special circumstances needed to justify the development do not exist. The
development does not accord with the development plan or amount to
sustainable development in the terms of the Framework.
22. For the reasons given above I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
Jonathan Clarke
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.