Raising of roof level to existing garage to create additional accommodation
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Policy Weight
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
www.planningportal.gov.uk/planninginspectorate
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 1 March 2017
by Keith Manning BSc (Hons) BTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 8 March 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/R4408/D/16/3167701
118 Smithies Lane, Barnsley S71 1NL
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr Chris Denton against the decision of Barnsley Metropolitan
Borough Council.
The application Ref 2016/1234, dated 23 September 2016, was refused by notice dated
3 November 2016.
The development proposed is raising of roof level to existing garage to create additional
accommodation.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
2. The main issue is the effect of the proposed development on the character and
appearance of the property and of the area with particular reference to the
street scene.
Reasons
3. The appeal site is adjacent to an access off Smithies Lane serving a Council
depot. It is one of a row of similar houses, all semi-detached apart from No
102, which lines the west side of Smithies Lane at this point. The east side is
characterised by properties of a different type, 153 and 155, which are less
formally laid out. Beyond the junction adjacent to 102 there is a large fishing
pond with an informal car park. Despite the presence of a waste processing
facility adjacent to the depot, the overall character and appearance of the area
is not unpleasant and the row of houses including the appeal site is relatively
neat, simple and compact in appearance.
4. The planning officer’s report articulates a number of principles that the Council
aims to adhere to in considering both house extensions and detached garages,
In particular it aims to keep extensions subservient in massing and proportions
to the host dwelling and detached garages generally at single storey scale and
without dormer windows, even though ancillary accommodation, albeit
specifically not residential annexes, may be contemplated in the roof space.
5. These principles are detailed in the Council’s Supplementary Planning
Document (SPD) House Extensions which has been adopted following
consultation under the auspices of policy CSP29 of the Council’s Core Strategy,
adopted in 2011. Insofar as this seeks to achieve good design in context it is
Appeal Decision APP/R4408/D/16/3167701
www.planningportal.gov.uk/planninginspectorate 2
consistent with the principles in that regard set out in the subsequent national
Planning Policy Framework (‘the Framework’) and may therefore be accorded
the full weight due to a formally adopted development plan policy. I accord
significant weight also to the SPG, albeit this cannot equal the weight carried
by the development plan itself. That said, the purpose of the SPD is to
interpret the intentions of the development plan in more detail in a manner
which is consistent with its overarching policy intentions.
6. In this case the proposed development fails to observe a number of the
published guidelines serving the policy intention of harmonious design in
context effectively embodied in CSP29. The net result would be a building that
would appear as a form of detached dwelling squeezed in beside one half of a
semi-detached pair. Moreover, the appearance would be ungainly as a
consequence of mixing the large garage door at ground floor level with
conventional house windows1 at first floor level under a half-hipped or ‘clipped
eaves’ roof, as the appellant describes it, that would neither accord with the
style of the host dwelling nor effectively soften its relationship to it by reducing
the apparent comparative height and bulk of the proposed development.
7. These considerations lead me to the conclusion that the proposal would harm
the character and appearance of the property and consequently the street
scene and the area more generally. That would plainly not be in accordance
with the intentions of the development plan.
8. The rather unusual nature of the residential environment here, with a markedly
industrial backdrop, is potentially material. However, the introduction of a
jarringly incongruous element, such as that proposed, into the street scene
would not be justified by that. The Framework is clear that design is always
important and that proposals of poor design which fail take the opportunities
available to improve the character and quality of an area should be refused.
9. Personal circumstances can also be material but I have no evidence to suggest
that a less intrusive means of accommodating one of the appellant’s children as
a consequence of caring for his mother in the main house cannot be found.
10. The example of the property in Monk Bretton does suggest that proposals of
this nature do not automatically court refusal of planning permission. However,
it is evident from the photograph that circumstances are different, in that the
host dwelling is a detached bungalow, and in any event I am not aware of all
the circumstances of this development and each case must be considered on its
specific merits.
11. Notwithstanding the partially industrial surroundings, I consider, for the
reasons I have given, that the proposed development does represent poor
design in context, contrary to the intentions of the development plan as
supplemented by guidance, as well as the intentions of the Framework in that
respect. I have taken all other matters raised into account but no material
considerations sufficient to outweigh that harmful conflict with policy have been
identified. I therefore conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
Keith Manning
Inspector
1 The submitted drawing signifies that the proposed approach to these is not definitive pending resolution of the
floor layout internally.
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.