Loft conversion to provide additional bedrooms, extensions and alterations to existing roof, alterations to existing rear extension and side extension at first floor level
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Heritage & Conservation
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 14 February 2017
by Richard Aston BSc (Hons) DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 3rd March 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/Z5630/D/17/3167695
56 Park Road, Kingston-upon-Thames, Surrey KT2 6AU
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs S Burley against the decision of the Council of the
Royal Borough of Kingston-upon-Thames.
The application Ref 16/12816/HOU, dated 27 June 2016, was refused by notice dated
28 October 2016.
The development proposed is loft conversion to provide additional bedrooms, extensions
and alterations to existing roof, alterations to existing rear extension and side extension
at first floor level.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matter
2. The Location and Block Plans submitted with the original application clearly
show the host property and its curtilage outlined in red1. However, I also have
been appointed to determine an appeal following the refusal of planning
permission for a similar proposal at No. 58 and I carried out a joint site visit.
Although this appeal relates to No. 56 only and I am required to determine the
appeal on this basis, I have also had regard to the current appeal proposal at
No. 582.
Main Issues
3. The main issue is the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of
the host property and the Liverpool Road Conservation Area (‘LRCA’).
Reasons
4. The appeal site lies within a predominantly residential area although there are
commercial and retail uses along Park Road. It is located on the periphery of
the LRCA. Further along Park Road and outside the LRCA, there are a variety of
detached and semi-detached properties that have been subject to a number of
alterations in the form of extensions, roof alterations and box projecting roof
dormer windows. Nevertheless, these do not form part of the LRCA, the
significance of which derives mainly from its residential streets of substantial 2
to 2 ½ storey detached and semi-detached villas and houses set in mature
1 The land to which the planning application relates to.
2 APP/Z5630/D/17/3167492.
Appeal Decision APP/Z5630/D/17/3167695
2
planting and street trees that emphasise the pleasant leafy and suburban
character of the area on the edge of Richmond Park.
5. Despite the use of sympathetic materials and appropriate detailing the
additional increase in height of both the roof and the first floor side extension
would detract from the integrity and uniformity of the design of the pair. The
large expanse of flat crown roof extending to the rear and side, at a greater
height than the immediate roofscape would exacerbate the scale of the
building, resulting in it being overly prominent and unduly dominant. Although
views are not widespread it would be publically visible and the size and
projection of the rear element and overall increase in scale and bulk at roof
level would appear at odds with the immediate roofscape, diminishing views of
its chimney which is an attractive existing feature of the pair.
6. Rather than reflecting the existing rhythm of the LRCA, the proposal would
unbalance the appearance of Nos. 56 and 58 as a freestanding pair of semi-
detached dwellings and would cause harm to the character and appearance of
the host property. The additional increase in height of both the roof and side
extension and change to the roof form would look incongruous and out of
keeping with the character and appearance of the host property and the LRCA.
In its context it would not therefore constitute good design.
7. The appellant contends that the proposals at Nos. 56 and 58 ‘can’t go ahead
without the alterations must maintain a parallel roof enhancements. Both
developments are inextricably linked’. However, although the appellant refers
to a legal agreement, no such agreement is before me that would secure joint
construction. I have considered whether the use of a Grampian style planning
condition could be attached to the planning permission which prohibited the
proposal being constructed at No. 58 until the proposal at No. 56 was
constructed.
8. However, on the evidence before me there is little for me to be certain of any
prospect whatsoever of the development at No. 58 being constructed within a 3
year time period (which would be the time limit in which a potential planning
permission would have to be begun for works at No. 56). In this particular case
a Grampian style condition would not therefore be appropriate and would fail
the tests set out in paragraph 206 of the National Planning Policy Framework
(‘Framework’) as it would not be enforceable or reasonable.
9. Moreover, even if a Grampian condition was appropriate the proposal would
still result in an unbalancing effect to the building that would be harmful, given
the contrasting height, form and design of the first floor side extensions one
each property and the overall mass, scale and design of the roof alterations
and extensions. This would still cause harm to the character and appearance of
the pair and would fail to preserve or enhance the character and appearance of
the LRCA.
10. For these reasons, the proposal would not preserve or enhance the character
and appearance of the LRCA and would harm the character and appearance of
the host property. It would conflict with Policies CS8, DM10 and DM12 of the
Royal Borough of Kingston-upon-Thames Core Strategy 2012. When taken as a
whole, these require good design, seek to maintain and improve the local built
and historic environment and require that new developments conserve and
enhance the character and appearance of the Borough’s heritage assets.
Appeal Decision APP/Z5630/D/17/3167695
3
11. In the context of the Framework, the proposal would cause less than
substantial harm to significance of the LRCA. On the evidence before me, any
public benefits in terms of economic activity during construction and improved
family accommodation would not outweigh the considerable weight and
importance I give to the desirability of preserving or enhancing the historic
asset and the harm that I have identified to the character and appearance of
the host property.
12. The Council raise no objections to the first floor window and other alterations
on the rear elevation and having visited the site I have no reason to disagree
with such an assessment. Whilst the Council objects to the dormer windows, I
found that other dormer windows existed within the LRCA. Moreover, they
would be subservient additions within the roof and of a suitable and
sympathetic design. Whilst I have found the necessary roof alterations to be
unacceptable, the dormer windows per se would not be an alien feature and
would preserve the character and appearance of the LRCA.
Other Matters
13. I acknowledge the appellant’s desire to improve the living accommodation of
the property and contention that the roof needs replacing as it is
‘environmentally inefficient’. However, these do not outweigh the harm that I
have identified in relation to the first main issue, mindful that there is also no
substantive evidence before me to suggest that such improvements could only
be realised by the appeal scheme.
Conclusion
14. For the reasons set out above the proposal would conflict with the development
plan, when read as a whole and the Framework. Material considerations do
indicate that a decision should be made other than in accordance with the
development plan and having considered all other matters raised, I therefore
conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
Richard Aston
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.