Two storey side and rear extension, single storey rear extension and new detached garage/store
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 21 February 2017
by Amanda Blicq BSc (Hons) MA CMLI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 24th February 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/Y2810/D/17/3167416
Christmas Cottage, Hothorpe, Marston Trussell LE17 6QX
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs Rogers against the decision of Daventry District
Council.
The application Ref DA/2016/0759, dated 3 August 2016, was refused by notice dated
9 November 2016.
The development proposed is two storey side and rear extension, single storey rear
extension and new detached garage/store.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for two storey side
and rear extension, single storey rear extension and new detached
garage/store at Christmas Cottage, Hothorpe, Marston Trussell LE17 6QX in
accordance with the terms of the application, Ref DA/2016/0759, dated
3 August 2016, subject to the following conditions:
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than 3 years from
the date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with
the following approved plans: 3497 – 01; 3497 – 02; 3497 – 03; 3497 –
04; 3497 – 05a; 3497 – 06a; 3497 – 07a; 3497 – 08a.
3) The external surfaces of the development hereby permitted shall match
those used in the existing building.
Procedural Matters
2. During the appeal I confirmed that the drawings upon which the appeal is to be
determined are those that formed part of the original application, namely those
listed in condition 2. Although amended plans have been submitted which
present an alternative scheme, the evidence before me indicates that the
appeal is to be determined on the original scheme. As such I have not
considered the alternative scheme in my reasoning.
3. The evidence before me indicates that there is an extant permission for a two
storey rear extension. However, limited details have been supplied and having
reviewed the cases from both main parties I have concluded that this is not
determinative to this appeal and I have not considered it further.
Appeal Decision APP/Y2810/D/17/3167416
2
Main Issue
4. The main issue is the effect of the development on the character and
appearance of the area.
Reasons
5. Christmas Cottage is one of a pair of modest period chalet-style detached
cottages situated in a predominantly rural landscape to the south of
Theddingworth. They appear to have been built in a simple Arts and Crafts
style. There is another pair of period detached cottages, built in a contrasting
style, nearby.
6. Both Christmas Cottage (the cottage) and its neighbour, Sunnie Brae, have
retained much of their original character through the retention of their original
front elevations with gable ends above sections of bellcast roof, that also run
along both flank elevations. There are also narrow flared buttresses on the
corners of their front elevations. The cottage has existing extensions in the
form of a rear conservatory, as well as a single storey projection that wraps
around the rear elevation and extends partway along its northern flank wall.
Sunnie Brae has also been extended, with a two storey extension that
continues the gable roof form to the rear but which also has large gable style
dormers.
7. The development would comprise two storey rear and side extensions, both of
which would provide their second storey accommodation within roof space.
The single storey projection which appears as a rather untidy and incongruous
addition to the cottage would be removed, and the conservatory’s footprint
would be subsumed into the overall development. The Council argues that
although the rear extension would be acceptable on its own, the side extension
would have a significant visual impact that would detract from the symmetry,
form and character of the cottages. Given that the Council has not objected to
the rearward extension as such, I have confined my reasoning to the side
extension although I have been mindful that the quantum of development
proposed would include the rearward extension.
8. The side extension would be set back from the cottage’s front elevation by
some 4 -5 metres. This would enable the retention of the cottage’s front
elevation as well as a reasonable section of the flank walls on either side. The
side extension would have a ridgeline slightly lower than that of the host
dwelling, and would retain the simplicity of the double pitched roof that
currently characterises the cottage. The extension would also have flared
buttresses on the corners of the gable end.
9. There would be a degree of visual separation between the original features of
the cottage’s distinctive front elevation and the proposed side extension. This
would safeguard the visual impact and the setting of the front elevation’s
character and detailing. The symmetry of detail and form between the front
elevations of the cottage and Sunnie Brae, which are the most visible from the
road, would be retained.
10. As such, although I appreciate that the side extension would be of significant
size, I disagree with the Council that it would detract either from the cottage or
such symmetry as there is with Sunnie Brae.
Appeal Decision APP/Y2810/D/17/3167416
3
11. The Council also argues that the design and materials of the proposed garage
would detract from the setting of the cottages. The garage would be partially
screened from the road by the frontage hedge and by rising ground. Although
I appreciate that a half hipped roof would not be entirely sympathetic to the
local vernacular I am not satisfied that it would be sufficient to warrant
dismissal of the appeal in the absence of other concerns.
12. It is proposed to use oak cladding to face the garage’s walls which the Council
considers inappropriate. However, the Council has not suggested an
appropriate alternative, were the appeal to be allowed. As such, given the
rural setting, and on the basis of the evidence before me, I am not persuaded
that oak cladding would be inappropriate.
13. In the light of the above, I find no conflict with Policy HS24 of the Local Plan1
(LP) which states in its supporting text, (rather than the policy itself), that
extensions to existing dwellings in the countryside should respect the character
and scale of the original dwelling and should still be a recognised part of the
extended building. Nor do I find conflict with the design aims of LP Policy EN24
which seek to ensure development blends in within the site and its
surroundings.
Conditions
14. I have considered the conditions put forward by the Council against the
requirements of the national Planning Practice Guidance and the Framework.
In respect of the plans, I have imposed a condition specifying the drawings
upon which I have based this appeal, as this provides certainty.
15. I have also imposed a condition ensuring that the materials used match those
of the host building to safeguard the appearance of the area. Where necessary
and in the interests of clarity and precision I have altered the conditions to
better reflect the relevant guidance.
Conclusion
16. For the reasons given above and taking all matters into account, I conclude
that the development would not be contrary to the relevant policies of the
Council’s Local Plan and that therefore the appeal should be allowed.
Amanda Blicq
INSPECTOR
1 Daventry
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.