Single and double storey rear extension incorporating a roof conversion
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 7 March 2017
by Graham M Garnham BA BPhil MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 14th March 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/J1915/D/16/3166118
147 Bengeo Street, Bengeo, Hertford, SG14 3EY
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr P McKay against the decision of East Hertfordshire District
Council.
The application Ref 3/16/2356/HH, dated 19 October 2016, was refused by notice dated
8 December 2016.
The development proposed is single and double storey rear extension incorporating a
roof conversion.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matter
2. I have based my decision on the plans as listed on the Council’s decision
notice.
Main Issue
3. I consider that this is the effect of the proposal on the character and
appearance of the building and the locality.
Reasons
4. The appeal property is a modest, 2 storey semi-detached house with a single
storey outrigger to the rear that accommodates the kitchen and bathroom. It
is proposed to widen the outrigger at ground floor level to the full width of the
house; erect 2 floors of rear extension above part of it adjoining the host
house; carry out a roof conversion, and other external works at the front.
5. The Council does not object to the single storey rear extension; installing new
side windows and a small front velux; and creating a parking space with
landscaping works in the front garden. I consider that all these works would
be compatible with the character and appearance of the building and the
locality, and have no reason to take a different view. Moreover, I see no
objection to the principle of converting the roof space to living space. I shall
focus the rest of my attention on the area of dispute, which is the double
storey rear extension above the outrigger and the main roof slope.
Appeal Decision APP/J1915/D/16/3166118
2
6. The proposed first floor plan shows the rear extension going out about 3.5
metres from the existing main rear wall of the house. The first floor would
accommodate a bedroom (the existing rear bedroom making way for a
bathroom and staircase). An extension of this height would be clearly
subordinate in height and scale to the main house, and similar to existing rear
extensions on either side. However, it is proposed to add another floor above,
which, together with the roof conversion, would create an en suite third
bedroom at 2nd floor level. The resultant full-width extension of 3 storey
height would have an eaves line significantly higher than that of the main
roof. The ridge height of the extension would match that of the main roof,
but it would be considerably longer. The extension would thus fail to appear
subordinate in height and scale to the host house.
7. The extension would have a gable end to match that of the host house. The
eaves line on the boundary would meet the roof slope of the attached house
about half way up towards the ridge, and protrude outwards from it for a
significant distance. I consider that this would add to the “top-heavy”
appearance of the back of the house, and be at odds with the prevailing two-
storey heights of existing rear extensions locally. These incongruities would
be seen in oblique views from side roads to the north and south of the site.
However, I consider that, because of proximity to the neighbouring house to
the north, the enlarged side wall would not be generally visible or harm the
character and appearance of the dwelling.
8. The appeal site is in the Hertford Conservation Area, a very large area which
covers much of the older part of Hertford, including the town centre. The
Council has provided no character appraisal or account of the heritage
significance of the conservation area, against which I can consider the
proposal. I have to rely on the conservation area boundary plan and my
observations during the site visit. The site is near the northern extremity of
the conservation area. Along the appeal side of Bengeo Street, only frontage
buildings are included, suggesting that it is the street scene that is of
importance. This is very mixed, and includes recent as well as earlier 20th
century buildings such as the appeal property. Little of the extension could be
seen from the road. Its relationship to the host house and nearby properties
at the rear could be seen clearly only from public viewpoints outside the
conservation area.
9. The appellant has referred to a house on Bengeo Street just south of the
appeal site. This appears to have a pitched roof rear extension that has an
eaves line higher than that of the main roof at the front of the house, and a
ridge line above that of the main roof. There is some similarity of form
between this development and the appeal proposal. However I have no details
about this dwelling, which from external appearances looks like a more recent
building. Hence I find it gives little support to the appellant’s case. It serves
as an example of the diversity of age, styles and qualities of the built
development in this part of the conservation area.
10. The National Planning Policy Framework says that great weight should be
given to the conservation of a heritage asset such as a conservation area.
Where harm is “less than substantial”, it should be weighed against the public
benefits of the proposal. In this case, I consider that the harm I have
identified in terms of the top of the rear extension is tangible, albeit small, in
Appeal Decision APP/J1915/D/16/3166118
3
the context of the wider conservation area. Nonetheless I consider this harm
to be significant in so far as the unsatisfactory design and appearance of an
addition to an older building would be expected to detract from the heritage
quality of the area to some degree. Against this are the benefits to the
appellant’s family and to established social networks of being able to remain
embedded in the local community. I regard this as a small but nonetheless
material contribution to the social role of sustainable development, supporting
the health of the local community. There is thus an identifiable public benefit.
However, I consider this would not outweigh the evident harm to the heritage
quality of the conservation area that I have identified above. Therefore I find
that the balancing judgement set out in paragraph 134 of the Framework
does not support the proposal.
11. I conclude on balance that the proposal would detract materially from the
character and appearance of the building and the locality, to a small but
significant extent. It would be contrary to Policies ENV1, ENV5, ENV6 & BH5
in the East Herts Local Plan Second Review (2007). Among other things,
these require new development to be of a high design quality that reflects
local distinctiveness, relates well to the surrounding townscape, and is
sympathetic to the general character and appearance of the conservation
area; and that extensions should complement the existing dwelling. The
propsoal would also fall short in respect of the statutory duty to have special
regard to the desirability of preserving or enhancing the character or
appearance of the conservation area.
12. Thus planning permission should be withheld and I dismiss the appeal.
G Garnham
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.