Erection of a first floor side and 2-storey rear extension, internal alterations and loft conversion including side and rear dormers
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Residential Amenity
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 3 February 2017
by Gary Deane BSc (Hons) DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 14 February 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/R5510/D/16/3164511
47 Lime Grove, Ruislip HA4 8RL
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 again st
a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mrs Tanya Huehns against the decision of the Council of the
London Borough of Hillingdon.
The application Ref 36542/APP/2016/2319, dated 15 June 2016, was refused by notice
dated 15 September 2016.
The development proposed is the erection of a first floor side and 2-storey rear
extension, internal alterations and loft conversion including side and rear dormers.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main issue
2. The main issue is the effect of the proposed development on the character and
appearance of the host building and the local area.
Reasons
3. The appeal property is a mainly 2-storey detached house in a predominantly
residential area wherein dwellings vary in scale, design and appearance. The
roof of No 47 is tiled with hipped ends. At the side of the main house is an
attached single storey garage. The site does not fall within a Conservation
Area or an Area of Special Local Character. The appeal building is not listed.
4. The proposal is to enlarge the existing dwelling with a full width single storey
rear extension and a first floor side and rear addition. Extra living space would
also be provided by converting the garage and within the roof space, which
would be served by 3 new dormers and roof lights.
5. From what I saw, the existing garage of No 47 establishes a substantial built
form at ground floor level up to the shared side boundary with the adjacent
property, which is 49 Lime Grove. The new side and rear extension would
reduce the gap at first floor level between Nos 47 and 49 by introducing
additional built form. Given the position of the existing garage, the finished
building would not achieve the minimum 1 metre separation to the site’s side
boundary for the full height of the building as required by Policy BE22 of the
Hillingdon Local Plan: Part Two - Saved UDP Policies (LP Part 2).
Appeal Decision APP/R5510/D/16/3164511
2
6. Nevertheless, at first floor level a gap of about 1.3 metres would separate the
new upper sidewall and the side boundary. The new side addition would also
be set back from the front wall of the main house. As a result, sufficient space
would be retained around the completed dwelling to preserve a clear visual
break with No 49. This arrangement would ensure that the finished building
would not appear cramped in terms of layout nor would it close a visually
important gap between adjacent houses nor lead to a ‘terracing effect’ in the
street scene. For these reasons, a conflict with LP Part 2 Policy BE22 would be
insufficient in itself to withhold planning permission in this case.
7. However, the combination of proposed additions and alterations at roof level
would radically change the appearance of No 47 and significantly impact on the
local street scene to which it belongs. Specifically, the 3 new dormers and
alterations to the roof form of the appeal dwelling would significantly increase
the scale and bulk at a high level that would give the completed building an
awkward top-heavy appearance. That would be most evident from the
highway in front of the site. From this vantage point, each of the new side
dormers would be a new and prominent feature given their elevated position.
The new central ridgeline broadly parallel to the road would also visually
accentuate the size and mass of the new roof when seen from Lime Grove.
When taken together, the proposal would be on a scale where the simple form
of the original building with its pyramidal shaped roof would be unduly
compromised. Consequently, I am unable to share the appellant’s opinion that
the extension and dormers would not fundamentally alter the character and
appearance of the host property.
8. The considerable scale and varied shape of the new roof would also markedly
contrast with the clean lines, modest proportions and traditional shape of the
roofs of properties along the same side of Lime Grove, close to the site.
Consequently, the completed building would stand uncomfortably in its
immediate context and be obtrusive in the street scene. The outcome would
be material harm to the area’s character and appearance. Although I saw an
eclectic mix of houses and bungalows in the local area, it is with the properties
in the immediate vicinity of the site that No 47, as proposed to be enlarged,
would be visually ‘read’.
9. In reaching this conclusion, I have taken into account the use of external
materials to match the host building. I also note that the eaves level of the
proposal would match that of the existing building. I have also had regard to
the properties to which the appellant has referred as ‘precedents’ that include,
amongst other things, side extensions and dormers. None of these examples
directly compare to the proposal before me in terms of scale or in their
relationship to the host building and those nearby. Consequently, there are
few direct parallels to be drawn between these cases and the appeal scheme
that support the appellant’s case. Therefore I attach limited weight to them.
10. The appellant is critical of the Council’s refusal because she considers that it is
based on subjective judgement. Matters of character and appearance
inevitably are. Nor do I accept that the Council has been overly prescriptive in
the light of the policies and principles of the National Planning Policy
Framework (the Framework). The Framework clearly states that planning
decisions should not attempt to impose architectural styles or particular tastes
and they should not stifle innovation, originality or initiative through
Appeal Decision APP/R5510/D/16/3164511
3
unsubstantiated requirements to conform to certain development forms or
styles. It is, however, proper to seek to secure high quality design, to which
the government attaches great importance. The Framework also makes clear
that new development should respond to local character and add to the overall
quality of the area. For the reasons given, the proposal would not adhere to
these important principles.
11. On the main issue, I therefore conclude that the proposed development would
materially harm the character and appearance of the host building and the local
area. As such, it is contrary to Policy BE1 of the Hillingdon Local Plan: Part One
- Strategic Policies and LP Part 2 Policies BE13, BE15 and BE19. These policies
aim to ensure that development harmonises with the original building and the
existing street scene, and complements or improves the character of the area.
These policies underpin the guidance within the Hillingdon Design and
Accessibility Statement (HDAS) Supplementary Planning Document, with which
the proposal would also conflict.
12. The proposal would make efficient use of the property in an accessible location
and the additional accommodation would improve the living conditions of the
appellant and enable them to stay and work in the local area. However, these
matters do not outweigh the significant harm that I have identified.
Conclusion
13. For the reasons set out above, I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
Gary Deane
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.