Single-storey rear extension and single-storey porch to entrance
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 4 January 2017
by I Jenkins BSc CEng MICE MCIWEM
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 27th January 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/X4725/D/16/3163618
The Smithy, South Lane, Netherton, Wakefield, WF4 4LN
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr Cook against the decision of City of Wakefield Metropolitan
District Council.
The application Ref 16/01920/FUL, dated 4 August 2016, was refused by notice dated
25 October 2016.
The development proposed is a single-storey rear extension and single-storey porch to
entrance.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for a single-storey
rear extension and single-storey porch to entrance at The Smithy, South Lane,
Netherton, Wakefield, WF4 4LN in accordance with the terms of the application,
Ref 16/01920/FUL, dated 4 August 2016, subject to the following conditions:
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than 3 years
from the date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance
with the following approved plans: 1618/100; 1618/101; 1618/102;
1618/110 D; 1618/111 D.
3) The materials to be used in the construction of the external surfaces of
the front and rear extensions hereby permitted shall match those used in
the existing building.
4) The rear extension hereby permitted shall not be occupied until the
window contained within its southern elevation has been fitted with
obscured glazing, and no part of that window that is less than 1.7 metres
above the floor of the room in which it is installed shall be capable of
being opened. Details of the type of obscured glazing shall be submitted
to and approved in writing by the local planning authority before the
window is installed and once installed the obscured glazing shall be
retained thereafter.
Main Issues
2. I consider that the main issues in this case are the effect of the proposal on the
living conditions of residents of The Smithy, with particular reference to
amenity space, and the character and appearance of the appeal property and
the group of buildings of which it forms part.
Appeal Decision APP/X4725/D/16/3163618
2
Reasons
3. The appeal property is a dwelling situated in an area designated as Green Belt.
The proposal involves extensions to the property, which would comprise a
single-storey rear extension and a front porch. The Council accepts that the
proposed development would be sufficiently limited so as not to result in
disproportionate additions over and above the size of the original building.
I agree. In this respect it would accord with Policy D23 of the Wakefield Local
Development Framework Development Policies (DP). It also follows that it
would not amount to inappropriate development in the Green Belt under the
terms of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework).
Living conditions
4. The Council’s Residential Design Guide, November 1996 (RDG) indicates that it
will normally seek a minimum private garden area of not less than 75 m²,
with an area at least 3 metres in depth from the rear of the dwelling which is
not overlooked by adjacent sitting out areas or living and dining room windows.
Whilst the rear garden area remaining after the proposed development would
fall short of 75 m², as the same can be said of the existing rear garden area,
in my judgement, this conflict with the guidance contained within the RDG
would not be sufficient to justify withholding planning permission in this case.
5. The combined area of the front and rear gardens belonging to The Smithy
greatly exceeds 75 m² and this would remain the case if the proposed
extensions were built. In keeping with the requirements of the Council’s RDG,
the proposed rear extension would take up less than half of the area of the rear
garden. In my view, the remaining areas to the north, south and rear of the
proposed extension would not be so limited as to prevent them from continuing
to function as amenity space. They would include areas adjacent to the back of
the main building which would be unlikely to be overlooked from the adjacent
dwellings. Furthermore, the appellant has indicated that amenity space
provided by the front garden is of a superior quality to that of the existing rear
garden, not least as it is larger, it benefits from sunlighting later in the day and
the area closest to the front of the house is reasonably private. I agree.
6. I conclude that the effect of the proposal on the living conditions of residents of
The Smithy, with particular reference to amenity space, would be acceptable
and in this respect it would accord with the aims of DP Policies D9 and D10,
which seek to protect the amenity of existing and future occupants, in keeping
with the aims of the Framework. I consider, for the reasons set out above,
that the technical conflict with the 75 m² RDG guideline would not be sufficient
in this particular case to justify withholding planning permission.
Character and appearance
7. The Smithy is a two-storey mid-terrace house, within an L-shaped row of
dwellings, which were formerly farm buildings. The front elevations of other
properties in the row have a number of features that might reasonably be
regarded as typical characteristics of former agricultural buildings, such as a
large arched opening in the frontages of 2 of the dwellings, and the relatively
plain front elevation of a third, which is punctuated by a number of doorway
sized openings at ground floor level and unusually small window openings
above. By comparison, The Smithy, with reference to its centrally positioned
doorway and domestically proportioned windows, has more the appearance of
Appeal Decision APP/X4725/D/16/3163618
3
a traditional cottage. Against this background, the proposed small front porch,
constructed in materials to match the existing building, would complement and
reinforce the character of the dwelling.
8. The rear elevation of the row of which The Smithy forms part is irregular in
character, including: single-storey and two-storey elements; a step in the
two-storey rear building line between the Smithy and the adjoining property to
the south; and, significant variations in the pattern of fenestration. In this
context, the relatively small scale of the proposed rear extension as well as the
use of matching materials and a pitched roof design in keeping with that of the
main dwelling would be sufficient to ensure that it would not look out of place.
9. As I have indicated, in keeping with the requirements of the Council’s RDG,
the proposed rear extension would take up less than half of the area of the rear
garden. Together, the proposed extensions would result in only a small
increase in the footprint of the building, which would continue to be much
smaller than the combined area of the front and rear gardens of The Smithy.
The scheme would not result in a major increase in the developed proportion of
the site.
10. I conclude that the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of
the Smithy and the group of buildings of which it forms part would be
acceptable and in this respect it would accord with the aims of DP Policies D9,
D10 and D23 as well as the aims of the Framework, such as securing good
design, reinforcing local distinctiveness and integrating new development into
the built environment.
Other matters
11. The ground floor level of The Coach House, which adjoins the Smithy on its
northern side, is higher than that of the appeal property. I consider that, due
to the difference in ground levels, the single-storey nature of the proposed rear
extension as well as the separation distance between it and the nearest back
window of The Coach House, the proposal would be unlikely to noticeably
reduce the daylight received by that neighbouring window. For the same
reasons, it would not appear unduly dominant when seen from there.
Furthermore, as that east facing neighbouring window is narrow, the room it
serves is unlikely to benefit to any significant extent from sunlight from a
southeasterly direction. Under these circumstances, I consider that the
proposed rear extension, which would be situated to the southeast of the
nearest back window of The Coach House would be unlikely to materially
reduce the sunlighting received by the room the window serves. I conclude
that the effect of the proposal on the living conditions of residents of The Coach
House would be acceptable and it would accord with the aims of DP Policies D9
and D10 as regards safeguarding the amenity of neighbouring residents.
12. The side boundaries of the front garden of the appeal property are enclosed by
walls and the potential for overlooking of the patio area adjacent to the front of
the house from windows of the nearest neighbouring properties is limited.
That potential would be further reduced by the erection of the proposed porch.
I am not convinced that the proposal would be likely to result in a requirement
to also increase the height of the front garden boundary enclosures to enhance
the privacy of the area. Such works do not form part of the proposal before
me.
Appeal Decision APP/X4725/D/16/3163618
4
13. In my judgement, the proposed rear extension would be unlikely to result in a
significant reduction in the levels of natural light received by the kitchen of
The Smithy. Loss of light resulting from the proposed removal of the rear
kitchen window and any overshadowing of the patio doorway adjacent to the
proposed rear extension would be offset by light received by the kitchen from
the adjoining extension, which would be served by windows and rooflights.
The effect of the proposal on the living conditions of residents of The Smithy
with respect to light would be acceptable and it would not conflict with DP
Policies D9 and D10.
14. I give little weight to the Council’s concern that the proposed development
would set an undesirable precedent. Each case must be considered primarily
on its own merits and I have found that the appeal scheme would not harm
interests of acknowledged importance. Furthermore, as I have indicated,
The Smithy differs from other properties in the row in a number of respects.
In any future case it would remain open to the Council to show in the particular
circumstances that harm would be caused. Neither this, nor any other matters
raised are sufficient to outweigh the considerations which have led to my
conclusions on the main issues.
Conditions
15. The Council has suggested 4 conditions which it considers should be imposed in
the event that the appeal is allowed and planning permission granted.
In addition to the normal commencement condition, a condition would be
necessary in the interests of clarity and proper planning, to ensure that the
permitted development would be carried out in accordance with the approved
plans. In the interests of visual amenity, a condition would be necessary to
ensure that the materials used in the external surfaces of the proposed
extensions match those used in the existing building. In the interests of
safeguarding the privacy of neighbouring residents, it would be necessary to
ensure, through the imposition of a condition, that the window contained within
the southern elevation of the proposed rear extension would be glazed with
obscured glass.
Conclusions
16. I conclude on balance, that the proposal would amount to sustainable
development under the terms of the Framework. It would accord with the
Development Plan taken as a whole and there are no other material
considerations sufficient to indicate that planning permission should
nevertheless be withheld. For the reasons given above, I conclude that the
appeal should be allowed.
I Jenkins
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.