Construction of a loft conversion using a front and rear mansard roof extension, to provide additional residential accommodation
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 17 January 2017
by H Lock BA (Hons) DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 1 February 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/C5690/D/16/3162236
13 Bolden Street, LEWISHAM, LONDON, SE8 4JF
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against
a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mrs Mary-Clare Alford against the decision of the Council of the
London Borough of Lewisham.
The application Ref. DC/16/097644 was refused by notice dated 16 September 2016.
The development proposed is the construction of a loft conversion using a front and rear
mansard roof extension, to provide additional residential accommodation.
Application for Costs
1. An application for costs was made by the appellant against the Council. This
application is the subject of a separate decision.
Decision
2. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
3. The main issue is the effect of the proposal on the character and a ppearance of
the appeal property and the Brookmill Road Conservation Area.
Reasons
4. The appeal property is located at the end of a short terrace of nineteenth
century houses in Bolden Street, a residential cul-de-sac which is notable for
the cohesive design and detailing of its dwellings. The surrounding streets
comprise similarly designed dwellings, and in particular, the original roof form is
that of a corniced parapet that creates the perception of flat-roofed dwellings
when viewed from the street, and hides the distinctive ‘butterfly’ roof at the
rear. The appeal site and the surrounding streets are located within the
Brookmill Road Conservation Area.
5. Within the conservation area there are a number of examples of terraced
houses of similar design to the appeal property which have been extended with
mansard roofs. Some are seen within the same immediate context of Bolden
Street, with examples in Albyn Road and Lind Street, to the rear of the appeal
site. Although the appellant refers to an unimplemented permission at 6 Bolden
Street, the dwellings in this road retain the original and distinctive roofscape
that is a feature throughout the conservation area. In its largely unaltered form,
the housing in Bolden Street makes a positive contribution to the character and
appearance of the area.
Appeal Decision APP/C5690/D/16/3162236
2
6. The local topography is such that the roof level of the appeal property stands
above the neighbouring terrace to the northwest. Although the front of the
proposed mansard roof would be recessed behind the parapet, I do not share
the appellant’s view that it would have no tangible impact on the street scene.
It would create a further storey that would appear bulky relative to the original
house, and disruptive to the cohesion of the terrace and wider streetscene. This
increased mass would be perceived due to the stepped roofline, and the visual
intrusion in the street scene would be compounded by the prominence of the
extended side parapet wall and the height of the chimneys. This impact would
conflict with DM Policy 31 of the Council’s Development Management Local Plan
2014 (DM), which seeks to resist roof extensions on the street frontage of a
building, and extensions which would adversely affect the architectural integrity
of a group of buildings as a whole, as in this case.
7. The appellant has drawn attention to a number of mansard roof extensions in
the vicinity of the site, and I am mindful that there are examples in Albyn Road
and Lind Street within the same vista as the appeal property. To an extent, they
are a feature of the conservation area, but the original roofline and form
prevails. Indeed, in some cases these roof extensions have undermined the
character and appearance of the original roofscape, and serve to demonstrate
the harm which would result from the appeal proposal. In this case, the set-
back, traditional design and matching materials of the extension would not
mitigate the adverse visual impact on the dwelling, the street scene and the
wider conservation area.
8. In countering the appellant’s costs application, the Council advises that
permission was granted for a mansard roof at 142 Albyn Road in 2007, and for
this reason, further permissions for this form of development in that particular
street have been granted. Although the appellant lists other examples in
surrounding streets (including extensions at 10 and 157 Albyn Road “built last
year”), limited detail has been supplied of their various planning permissions,
the rationale for their approval, and their construction dates. On the basis of
the information supplied, it is unclear whether or not the examples were
assessed against the current national and local policies, and I cannot gauge a
direct comparison with the appeal proposal. Whilst it is evident that local
examples exist, the current proposal is clearly in conflict with a number of
requirements of the policies currently in force.
9. There is a requirement to pay special attention to the desirability of preserving
or enhancing the character or appearance of a conservation area in exercising
planning functions, and this is reflected in DM Policy 36, which amongst other
criteria, also opposes extensions which are incompatible with the special
characteristics of the area, its buildings, scale, form and materials. For the
reasons outlined above, the proposal would be incompatible in this manner.
10.The proposal would conflict with a number of the guidelines set out at
paragraph 6.7 of the ‘Residential Standards’ Supplementary Planning Document
2012, in that it would fail to preserve the architectural character of the building,
would be built above the height of the ridge of the main roof, and the rear of
the mansard would be formed by building up the existing external wall. This
would destroy the historic ‘butterfly’ roof which is a notable feature of the
original buildings in the conservation area. I accept that this has occurred on
other properties with mansard roofs, but is a result which I do not regard as
Appeal Decision APP/C5690/D/16/3162236
3
either preserving or enhancing the character or appearance of the buildings
within the conservation area.
11.Paragraph 134 of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework)
states that where a development proposal would lead to less than substantial
harm to the significance of a designated heritage asset, this harm should be
weighed against the public benefits of the proposal. The appellant’s need for the
additional accommodation is understood, and the proposal would optimise the
potential for the site, but it is not evident that any public benefits would result.
Having established that harm to the heritage asset (the conservation area)
would result from the proposal, I am obliged to give that harm considerable
importance and weight. Whilst I accept that in a number of ways the proposal
would accord with the thrust of national policy, it would nevertheless conflict in
terms of its heritage impact, and I do not find other factors would outweigh this
harm.
12.I can appreciate the appellant’s frustration given the number of mansard roofs
in the conservation area, including examples seen from the appeal site itself.
However, I am persuaded by the Council’s view that the appropriateness of this
form of development in the Conservation Area will need to be assessed on a
case by case basis. Whilst I note the appellant’s view that there is no policy
basis to ‘single out’ Bolden Street as a sub-area of the conservation area, its
largely unaltered roofscape is nevertheless an important example of the
appearance, character and continuity of the historic street.
13.I therefore conclude that the proposal would be detrimental to the character
and appearance of the appeal property, and would fail to preserve or enhance
the character and appearance of the Brookmill Road Conservation Area. It
would conflict with the strategic design and conservation aims of Policies 15 and
16 of the Lewisham Core Strategy 2011, and DM Policy 30, and with the more
detailed design criteria set out in DM Policies 36 and 31, and the SPD. For the
same reasons, it would not accord with the strategic and specific aims of
Policies 7.4, 7.6 and 7.8 of The London Plan 2016. Having regard to Section 12
of the Framework, I find that this proposal would harm the significance of the
designated heritage asset, and this harm would not be outweighed by public
benefits.
Conclusion
14.In conclusion, the Framework establishes a presumption in favour of sustainable
development, and part of its environmental strand is to contribute to protecting
and enhancing the built and historic environment. Core planning principles of
the Framework include always seeking to secure high quality design and to
conserve heritage assets in a manner appropriate to their significance. For the
reasons given above the proposal would not comply with these principles and
would not constitute sustainable development supported through the
Framework. As a consequence, I conclude that this appeal should be dismissed.
H Lock
INSPECTOR
£
Costs decision section
Costs Decision
Site visit made on 17 January 2017
by H Lock BA(Hons) DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 1 February 2017
Costs application in relation to Appeal Ref: APP/ C5690/D/16/3162236
13 Bolden Street, LEWISHAM, LONDON, SE8 4JF
The application is made under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, sections 78,
322 and Schedule 6, and the Local Government Act 1972, section 250(5).
The application is made by Mrs Mary-Clare Alford for a full award of costs against the
Council of the London Borough of Lewisham.
The appeal was against the refusal of planning permission for the construction of a loft
conversion using a front and rear mansard roof extension, to provide additional
residential accommodation
Decision
1. The application for an award of costs is refused.
Reasons
2. The Planning Practice Guidance advises that costs may be awarded against a
party who has behaved unreasonably and thereby caused the party applying
for costs to incur unnecessary or wasted expense in the appeal process.
3. The assessment of the proposal related to matters of judgement, and the
Council’s decision was supported by a sufficiently reasoned analysis having
regard to current national and local planning policies. There is limited
information in the appeal submissions regarding the permissions which
resulted in other mansard roofs in the vicinity being built. However, the
Council’s evidence suggests that it has not granted such developments
throughout the conservation area, and determines proposals on a site-
specific basis. In this context, it was not unreasonable or inconsistent for the
Council to have reached its decision given the lack of comparable examples
in Bolden Street itself.
4. An appeal statement was not submitted by the Council in accordance with
the Householder Appeal Service procedure, but the Council clearly conveyed
its objections to the appeal development through its officer report.
5. I therefore find that unreasonable behaviour resulting in unnecessary or
wasted expense, as described in the Planning Practice Guidance, has not
been demonstrated.
H Lock
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.