Proposal is described as “the demolition of existing garage and the erection of a two-storey extension (revised submission with a lower visual profile and a 23% reduced floor area)
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Policy Weight
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 15 November 2016
by William Fieldhouse BA (Hons) MA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 6th December 2016
Appeal Ref: APP/E2001/D/16/3161806
4 Eastfield Close, Beverley HU17 9PW
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against
a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr Keith Dales against the decision of East Riding of Yorkshire
Council.
The application ref DC/16/02187/PLF/EASTSE, dated 28 June 2016, was refused by
notice dated 6 September 2016.
The proposal is described as “the demolition of existing garage and the erection of a
two-storey extension (revised submission with a lower visual profile and a 23% reduced
floor area)”.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matter
2. As is reflected in the description of development, this is a revised proposal
following the withdrawal of an earlier planning application for a similar scheme.
Main Issue
3. The main issue is the effect that the proposal would have on the living
conditions in 3 Eastfield Close.
Reasons
The Site, its Surroundings, and the Proposal
4. The appeal relates to a two-storey, semi-detached house with a single garage
to the side which is attached to a similar garage at no. 3. The garages are 2.8
metres high at the front with mono-pitched roofs that slope down to a height of
2 metres at the rear. The other properties in the cul de sac are of similar
layout and design. Whilst there are houses in the wider surrounding area that
have two-storey side additions, none of the properties on Eastfield Close have
been extended in such a way.
5. The proposal would entail the demolition of the garage on the appeal site and
the erection of a two-storey side extension that would adjoin the front corner of
the house and project back at a slight angle. It would be 3.9 metres in width,
standing 0.7 metres from the side boundary with no. 3; 5.2 metres in depth,
slightly less than the adjoining garage; and 4.7 metres in height to the eaves,
compared to 5.5m on the main dwelling. The roof would be hipped, sloping
Appeal Decision APP/E2001/D/16/3161806
2
away from no. 3 up to a ridge height of 6.65 metres, compared to 8.15m on
the main dwelling.
Living Conditions
6. The proposal would not project beyond the rear of the existing garage at no.3
which would to some degree screen the new structure when seen from the
adjoining property. However, a two-storey wall some 5.2 metres in length and
4.7 metres in height would be erected only 0.7 metres from the shared side
boundary and less than 5 metres from the side elevation of no. 3. Whilst the
appeal site is at a slightly lower level and the proposed roof would slope away,
the side wall would be considerably higher than the garage and the ridge would
be closer to the adjoining property than the existing dwelling. The proposal
would, therefore, be clearly visible from no. 3 above the garage and existing
screen fence.
7. The main kitchen window in no. 3 is in the side elevation to the rear of the
garage. The new two-storey pitched-roof structure would be set forward of
this, but it would be clearly seen from that window albeit at an angle.
Similarly, it would also be visible from the main sitting out area at no. 3 which
is a short distance behind the garage beyond a small bin storage area and
trellis fence. From these perspectives, the proposal would appear as a
somewhat overbearing structure due to its height and proximity.
8. Furthermore, the two-storey extension would be to the south east of the
kitchen window and sitting out area at no. 3. Thus, whilst the amount of
sunlight to this window and patio will already be restricted by existing buildings
and structures, the erection of a building of the height proposed in such close
proximity would inevitably lead to a loss of direct sunlight to the window and
back garden of no. 3 at certain times.
9. The proposal includes a first floor bedroom window in the side elevation that
would potentially overlook the kitchen window and back garden of no. 3.
However, as this would be a secondary window which is intended to provide
natural daylight rather than outlook, a planning condition could be imposed if
the appeal were to be allowed to require the opening to be fitted with obscure
glass and fixed closed.
10. I conclude on the main issue that the proposal, due to its effect on outlook
from and light to the main kitchen window and back garden, would materially
harm the living conditions at no. 3 Eastfield Close contrary to national policy1
and policy ENV1 of the East Riding Local Plan Strategy Document (2016) which
collectively seek to achieve high quality design and ensure a good standard of
amenity for the occupants of buildings.
Other Matters
11. The appellant has clearly made a considerable effort to design and assess a
scheme, including through the preparation of three-dimensional models and
photographic analysis of the proposal and surrounding area, with the intention
of minimising the impact on the adjoining property. However, the particular
design and layout of the houses on this cul de sac means that a two-storey side
1 National Planning Policy Framework paragraph 17, 4th bullet point.
Appeal Decision APP/E2001/D/16/3161806
3
extension of the type proposed, which could potentially be comfortably
accommodated in other residential areas, would cause material harm for the
reasons that I have set out above.
Conclusion
12. By virtue of the conflict with local plan policy ENV1, the proposal would not be
in accordance with the development plan and material considerations do not
indicate that planning permission should be granted. I therefore conclude that
the appeal should be dismissed.
William Fieldhouse
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.