Erection of a front and rear roof extension; erection of a rear extension at second floor level over part of the existing back addition; erection of a rear extension at first floor level over part of the existing back addition
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 20 February 2017
by G J Fort BA PGDip LLM MCD MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 24 February 2017
Appeal Ref: APP/H5390/D/16/3161590
2 Rosaline Road, London SW6 7QT
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr Narendra Patel against the decision of the Council of the
London Borough of Hammersmith & Fulham.
The application Ref 2016/02688/FUL, dated 13 June 2016, was refused by notice dated
10 August 2016.
The development proposed is erection of a front and rear roof extension; erection of a
rear extension at second floor level over part of the existing back addition; erection of a
rear extension at first floor level over part of the existing back addition.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matter
2. I have used the description of development given on the appeal form in the
banner heading above, which more accurately captures the scope of the appeal
scheme than the description given in the planning application form. Moreover,
I note that the appellant and Council agreed to the change during the course of
the application’s determination.
Main Issues
3. I consider the main issues in this appeal to be firstly, the effects of the
proposed development on the character and appearance of its host building
and surroundings; and secondly, its effects on the living conditions of the
occupants of 246, 248 and 250 Munster Road in terms of the outlook available
from those dwellings.
Reasons
Character and appearance
4. Situated at the end of a long terrace of two-storey residential properties, the
appeal building, like its neighbours, and those across the road, is of two
storeys, brick-faced, bay-fronted, and set back from the highway behind
modest front gardens bounded by short brick walls. The terrace has a strong
sense of rhythm and consistency of detailing, imparted by the regularity of its
bay windows, structural openings, party wall upstands and chimney stacks.
Appeal Decision APP/H5390/D/16/3161590
2
5. The proposed development seeks comprehensive alterations to the appeal
building’s roof replacing it with a mansard style roof to the front with two
dormer windows. The appeal building’s flank wall and party wall upstand would
be built up to either side to a higher level than, and proud of, the mansard
roof. At the rear, a flat roof structure with a Juliet balcony on its rear elevation
would replace the appeal building’s existing roof slope. The existing rear
outrigger would be extended at first floor to the same depth as that of the
existing extension at ground floor level. A dormer would be inserted in the new
rear roof element above the extended rear wing.
6. The appeal building’s host terrace is a long one, and whilst I noted two other
mansard roof alterations along it, the front roof slopes of its constituent
dwellings were otherwise intact, except for rooflights inserted here and there.
I also note the Council’s comment that no planning history exists in relation to
the two mansard alterations within the block. As a result, the existing
mansards do not establish a predominant pattern for the appeal scheme to
replicate; and conversely, serve to demonstrate how such extensive alterations
could be discordant and incongruous in the context of the consistent
proportions and detailing and the wider rhythm of the terrace.
7. Moreover, the appeal building’s position at the end of the terrace would render
the proposed alterations starkly visible. As a result, the proposed height and
depth of the flank wall and party wall upstand, combined with the scale and
massing of the front mansard would create a dominant impression insensitive
to the proportions and detailing of its host building, and discordant in terms of
the rhythm of the wider terrace. As a consequence, the proposed development
would cause considerable harm to the character and appearance of its host
building and its surroundings in this regard.
8. The rears of the appeal building and its neighbouring properties directly
address Aintree Street and are thus widely visible in public views. I saw that
alteration to the rear of the Rosaline Road properties is by no means unusual
including at roof level. However, the depths of the first floor outriggers are
generally consistent. In this context, the proposed first floor rear extension
would read as excessive and discordant, and would disrupt the balance of the
attached outriggers of the appeal building and 4 Rosaline Road to an extent
that would cause harm to the character and appearance of the streetscene.
9. Whilst I note comments that the appeal building is not in a conservation area
and is not listed, these matters do not alter my findings of the harm caused to
the character and appearance of the host building and its surroundings as a
result of the proposed development. The use of matching materials would not
soften these harmful effects to any material degree.
10. Thus for the reasons given above, the proposed development would cause
considerable harm to the character and appearance of the host building and its
surroundings. As a result the proposed development would conflict with Policy
BE1 of the Hammersmith and Fulham Core Strategy (adopted October 2011)
(the Core Strategy) and DMG3 the Hammersmith and Fulham Development
Management Local Plan (adopted July 2013) (the DM Plan). Amongst other
things, and taken together, these policies seek to ensure that all development
within the borough creates a high quality urban environment which respects
and enhances its townscape context; and that alterations and extensions are of
Appeal Decision APP/H5390/D/16/3161590
3
a high standard of design compatible with the scale and character of existing
development.
Living Conditions
11. I saw that the rear aspects of 246 to 250 Munster Road face the side of the
appeal building. The proposed development would introduce a considerable
amount of additional flank walling to the front and rear of the appeal building.
12. I saw that a first floor outrigger window in No 250 would face directly onto the
flank wall of the proposed first floor rear extension. Due to the depth and scale
of the rear extension’s blank flank wall, and its proximity to No 250’s outrigger
window, it would constitute an enclosing structure that would impair the
outlook available from this window to a material degree. This would, as a
consequence, be of harm to the living conditions of No 250’s occupants in this
regard.
13. No 248 has an outrigger window at first floor that looks directly onto the flank
wall of the appeal building. This is a small window, the outlook of which is
dominated to a considerable degree by the existing form and scale of the
appeal building. Consequently, I consider that the proposed development
would not impair outlook from this window to a degree that would be material.
Whilst the increased scale of the flank walling would be visible from other rear
windows in No 248, due to the distance of those windows from the appeal
building the proposed development would not be a dominant presence in views
from them, and would thus not materially reduce the quality of outlook
available. As a result, I consider that no material harm would be caused to the
living conditions of the occupants of No 248 as a result of the proposed
development.
14. In terms of No 246, I noted that the rear wall of its outrigger has no windows
that look out onto the appeal building. The windows on the return wall of its
outrigger would only afford oblique views of the proposed development; and
whilst the windows of its main rear elevation and dormer would face the
enlarged front part of the flank wall they are at a sufficient distance from it so
that the outlook available from them would not be impaired to any material
degree as a consequence of the proposal. Consequently, I find that the
proposed development would cause no significant harm to the living conditions
of the occupants of No 246 in this regard.
15. Whilst I have found no harm to the living conditions of the occupants of Nos
246 and 248 would occur as a result of the development, I have found that the
proposed development would cause harm to the living conditions of the
occupants of No 250 as a result of its effects on the outlook available from the
rear outrigger first floor window. As a consequence, the proposed development
would conflict with Policies DMA9 and DMG3 of the DM Plan, and SPD Housing
Policy 8 of the Planning Guidance Supplementary Planning Document (adopted
July 2013). Taken together, and amongst other matters, the policies and
guidance seek to ensure that extensions protect the amenity of neighbouring
occupiers, and avoid detrimental impacts to the outlook available from the
windows of neighbouring properties.
Appeal Decision APP/H5390/D/16/3161590
4
Other Matter
16. I note that there were no objections to the proposed development at
application stage. However, this matter does not alter my conclusions in
regard to the harm that the development would cause to the character and
appearance of the area or the living conditions of the occupiers of 250 Munster
Road.
Conclusion
17. The proposed development would avoid causing material harm to the living
conditions of the occupants of 246 and 248 Munster Road. However, this is
merely indicative of a lack of harm in these respects as opposed to a positive
benefit of the scheme, and in the overall planning balance is demonstrably
outweighed by the considerable harm caused to the character and appearance
of the host building and surroundings, and to the harm caused to the living
conditions of the occupants of No 250.
18. The proposed development would thus conflict with the development plan
insofar as the policies that have been drawn to my attention are concerned. As
no material considerations have been advanced sufficient to outweigh this
conflict I conclude, for the reasons given above, and having regard to all other
matters raised, that the appeal should be dismissed.
G J Fort
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.