Extensions and alterations
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 6 December 2016
by A Napier BA(Hons) MRTPI MIEMA CEnv
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 20 December 2016
Appeal Ref: APP/J1915/D/16/3160819
3 Hollydell, Hertford SG13 8BE
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr L Merhemitch against the decision of East Hertfordshire
District Council.
The application Ref 3/16/1635/HH, dated 19 July 2016, was refused by notice dated
27 September 2016.
The development proposed is extensions and alterations.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The appeal site is located within Hertford Conservation Area, which is a
designated heritage asset and I am mindful of my statutory duties in this
regard. The main issues in this appeal are:
Whether or not the proposal would preserve or enhance the character or
appearance of the Conservation Area; and
The effect of the proposal on the living conditions of neighbouring
occupiers, with particular regard to privacy and outlook.
Reasons
Character and appearance
3. The appeal site is located towards the edge of the Conservation Area, which is
extensive in size and covers much of the historic core of the settlement. From
the evidence available to me, I consider that its importance is largely derived
from the range and type of properties within it and the pattern of built
development, including the spaces between and around buildings, as well as
several important areas of open space. Whilst a school exists nearby, the
established development in the immediate vicinity of the appeal site is
predominantly residential in character and largely comprised of older, fairly
substantial houses, set within generous gardens, interspersed with more recent
development of varying sizes and styles, generally on smaller plots.
4. The appeal dwelling forms one of a small number of similar single-storey
dwellings that, from the submitted details, were constructed relatively recently
on sites that previously formed part of the larger garden areas of neighbouring
older dwellings. Whilst there is some variety in design details, in terms of their
Appeal Decision APP/J1915/D/16/3160819
2
overall scale, form, appearance, density and the pattern of built form, the
single-storey dwellings form a cohesive group of properties that relate
positively to each other and can be clearly read as later development to the
larger dwellings nearby.
5. Whilst I have not been provided with a copy of the document, I understand
that no specific reference is made to Hollydell within the Council’s draft
Conservation Area Appraisal. Furthermore, I recognise that greater variety is
provided further along the road by more recent additions to the streetscene.
Nonetheless, I consider that this does not diminish the contribution made by
the appeal group of dwellings identified above and, overall, I find that they
make a modest but positive contribution to the quality and character of the
area.
6. The proposed additions and extensions to the appeal dwelling would
significantly alter its appearance. The proposal would notably change the form
and considerably increase the scale and mass of the appeal dwelling. The
introduction of a first floor would materially increase the height of the dwelling
and the design approach proposed would not reflect the details of the existing
dwelling, such as the distinctive roof, simple fenestration and use of brick
external walling materials. As a result, overall, I consider that the proposed
alterations would not be sympathetic or complementary additions to the
dwelling and would markedly change the character of the property.
7. The proposal would significantly increase the amount of development on the
site. Given the size of the garden areas remaining to either side, I consider
that the resulting dwelling would not appear unacceptably cramped.
Nonetheless, notwithstanding the variety in design that exists elsewhere in the
locality, the resulting material change to the form, design and appearance of
the dwelling and the significant increase in its relatively modest existing scale
and mass would materially alter the visual relationship of the appeal dwelling
to its immediate neighbours.
8. As a result, I consider that it would appear as an unacceptably dominant
element within this small group of properties, which would significantly disrupt
their existing cohesive design and intrusively detract from the qualities of the
streetscene. Therefore, notwithstanding the limited long-distance views of the
site, but given the positive contribution currently made by this group to the
street as a whole, I also consider that the wider impact of the proposal in this
respect would be materially detrimental.
9. Consequently, for these reasons, I conclude that the proposal would not
preserve the character and appearance of the Conservation Area. It would
conflict with the East Herts Local Plan Second Review April 2007 (LP) Policies
ENV1, ENV5, ENV6 and BH5, which collectively seek to protect local character
and appearance, including in relation to the historic environment. Policies from
the pre-submission consultation draft of the Council’s District Plan have also
been drawn to my attention. However, as this is an emerging policy document,
its policies may be subject to change and this considerably limits the weight
that I give to them. Nonetheless, they do not lead me to an alternative
conclusion in these regards.
10. For the reasons given, the proposed development would be harmful to the
significance of the heritage asset. However, it would affect one site within a
much larger Conservation Area. As such, I consider that the harm, whilst
Appeal Decision APP/J1915/D/16/3160819
3
material, would be less than substantial. Paragraph 134 of the National
Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) requires that, in the case of
designated heritage assets, the harm should be weighed against the public
benefits of the proposal, including securing its optimum viable use.
11. The main public benefits resulting from the scheme would be the provision of
additional living accommodation for the dwelling. However, although this
would increase flexibility in the use of the property and, as such, make some
contribution to sustaining its residential use in the long-term, there is nothing
before me to suggest that the use of the dwelling would be at risk in the
absence of the scheme. Furthermore, whilst the construction of the proposal
would also be likely to have some local economic benefits, given the scale of
the development proposed, I consider that these would be likely to be
relatively modest. As a result, I give these benefits limited weight.
12. Paragraph 132 of the Framework advises that great weight should be given to
the conservation of a heritage asset in considering the impact of a proposal on
its significance. Significance can be harmed or lost through alteration or
destruction of the heritage asset and, as heritage assets are irreplaceable, any
harm or loss should require clear and convincing justification. In addition,
paragraph 131 of the Framework refers to the desirability of new development
making a positive contribution to local character and distinctiveness. For the
above reasons, I consider that the development would not make such a
contribution and, as such, whilst the use of the site as proposed may be viable,
it would not represent its optimum use.
13. For these reasons, I conclude that the benefits of the proposal would not be
sufficient to outweigh the harm identified to the significance of the heritage
asset and the proposal would not meet the aims of paragraph 17 of the
Framework, to achieve high quality design, take account of the different roles
and character of different areas and conserve heritage assets in a manner
appropriate to their significance.
Living conditions
14. The appeal site is broadly rectangular in shape and has a relatively limited
depth. The dwelling is sited roughly centrally within it, close to the rear
boundary. As a result of this siting, it is in reasonable proximity to the
neighbouring property to the rear, No 16 Morgan’s Road, which is a substantial
house, with windows to its side and rear elevations. Although the re-siting of
the garage element and addition of a first floor as proposed would increase the
amount of built development immediately adjacent to this boundary, the
appeal scheme proposes no new windows to the first floor on the rear
elevation.
15. Furthermore, although the rooflights and glazed window and doors to the
master bedroom would be in close proximity to this boundary, due to the
position of these openings and respective siting of the dwellings, the potential
for overlooking would largely be limited to oblique views of the neighbouring
property. Given the proposed use of this room, I am satisfied that the impact
of the proposal in this regard would not cause an unacceptable loss of privacy
for these neighbouring occupiers.
16. Whilst the first floor side window would result in some overlooking between the
appeal dwelling and the neighbouring single-storey dwelling at No 2 Hollydell,
Appeal Decision APP/J1915/D/16/3160819
4
taking into account the separation distances involved, the albeit relatively
limited screening provided by the two garden areas and the urban location of
the site, I consider that the impact of the proposal would not be materially
harmful in this regard. In addition, for similar reasons, notwithstanding the
proposed first floor bedroom windows to the other side elevation, I consider
that the proposal would not have an unacceptable impact on the privacy of the
neighbouring occupiers at No 12.
17. From the details provided, the garden of No 16 is generous and,
notwithstanding the siting of that dwelling close to the common boundary, I
consider that the extent of development proposed, including the resulting
increase in height of the appeal dwelling, would not be unacceptably
overbearing to these neighbouring occupiers, or result in a significant loss of
outlook for them.
18. Accordingly, overall, I conclude that the proposal would not have an
unacceptable effect on neighbouring living conditions. It would not conflict
with LP Policies ENV1, ENV5 and ENV6, where they collectively seek to protect
residential living conditions. It would also meet the aims of paragraph 17 of
the Framework, to achieve a good standard of amenity for all existing and
future occupants of land and buildings.
Other matters
19. The three roles of sustainable development are mutually dependent.
Paragraphs 6-9 of the Framework indicate that ‘sustainability’ should not be
interpreted narrowly. Elements of sustainable development cannot be
undertaken in isolation but should be sought jointly and simultaneously.
Sustainable development also includes ‘seeking positive improvements in the
quality of the built, natural and historic environment as well as in people’s
quality of life’.
20. I have found above that the effect of the proposal on neighbouring living
conditions would be acceptable and it would have a number of public benefits.
In addition, I recognise that the provision of additional living accommodation is
very likely to be of personal benefit to the appellant. However, for the reasons
given, I conclude that none of these matters, either collectively or individually,
would be sufficient to address or outweigh the harm identified above, to the
character and appearance of the area and the significance of the heritage
asset. As such, I find that the proposal would not represent sustainable
development.
Conclusion
21. For the above reasons and having regard to all other matters raised, I conclude
that the appeal should be dismissed.
A Napier
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.