Demolition of an existing garage and the construction of front, rear & side extensions, re-forming of roof with dormer windows to provide second floor accommodation and fenestration changes
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 7 December 2016
by D J Barnes MBA BSc(Hons) DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 15 December 2016
Appeal Ref: APP/G5180/D/16/3160874
60 Manor Way, Beckenham BR3 3LJ
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs O’Brien against the decision of the Council of the
London Borough of Bromley.
The application Ref DC/16/02382/FULL6, dated 17 May 2016, was refused by notice
dated 21 July 2016.
The development proposed is the demolition of an existing garage and the construction
of front, rear & side extensions, re-forming of roof with dormer windows to provide
second floor accommodation and fenestration changes.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
2. It is considered that the main issue whether the proposed development would
preserve or enhance the character or appearance of the Manor Way,
Beckenham Conservation Area.
Reasons
3. The appeal property is a large 2-storey detached dwelling with a detached
single storey garage and is situated on a large plot within the Manor Way,
Beckenham Conservation Area. There is a statutory duty to pay special
attention to the desirability of preserving or enhancing the character or
appearance of the Conservation Area and this duty is echoed in Policy BE11 of
the London Borough of Bromley Unitary Development Plan (UDP) and Policy 7.8
of The London Plan (LP).
4. The Supplementary Planning Guidance for the Manor Way, Beckenham
Conservation Area (SPG) refers to the character and appearance of the area
being comprised of individual detached houses with common references to neo
vernacular design and materials. The dwellings are generally 2-storey and set
back from the edge of the footways to the rear of front gardens which are
landscaped and used for parking. Some of the dwellings have been extended
but the streetscene maintains a spacious and verdant character and
appearance.
Appeal Decision APP/G5180/D/16/3160874
2
5. The Arts and Crafts style of the property, including its front gable, fenestration
and proportions, makes a positive contribution to the streetscene and the
Conservation Area as a whole. I also share the Council’s assessment that the
pair of projecting gables to the rear of the property are features associated
with the style of property and are similar to other gables observed during the
site visit.
6. Planning permission was previously granted for alterations to the appeal
property which included a single storey rear addition and the replacement of
the detached garage by a single storey extension with an integral garage (Ref
13/03673/FULL6). From the street, the existing 2-storey element of the
property would have been unaltered and remained the dominant feature and
the property’s appearance from the street would not have materially changed.
At the rear there would have been a change to the property’s character at
ground floor level because of the box like design of the single storey extension.
This planning permission remains extant and is a potential fall-back position to
which I have had regard in assessing the appeal scheme.
7. By comparison to what was approved, the proposed development includes a
larger single storey box like rear extension; the loss of one of the 2-storey
gables to the rear of the property; a new central rear gable feature; a 2-storey
side extension; an increase in the height and form of the property’s main roof;
the erection of dormer windows within the roof slopes and an enlarged central
gable within the front elevation. The scale and design of the proposal would
materially alter the proportions, form, character and appearance of the
property’s rear and front elevations.
8. When viewed from Manor Road and assessed individually, the proposed 2-
storey side extension would be neither an unsympathetically designed or
disproportionate extension to the property. Its size and appearance would be
similar to the addition observed during the site visit at No. 27. There would
remain adequate and appropriate visual and physical separation from No. 58 to
maintain the spacious and verdant appearance of the streetscene. The
proposed fenestration, including the bay window, would be sympathetic to the
host property. A condition could be imposed to require matching external
materials.
9. However, in combination the alterations to the roof, the dormers and the
central gable, the proposed 2-storey side extension would significantly alter the
bulk, form, proportions and character of the property in a manner that would
detrimentally affect its appearance and positive contribution to the streetscene
of the Conservation Area. Although there are examples of crown roofs within
the Conservation Area, the proposed alterations to the property’s roof would
also contribute towards giving the resulting dwelling a bulky form and
appearance.
10. Although some elements may be individually acceptable, the cumulative impact
of the loss of a gable, the size of the box like single storey extension and the
various alterations to the roof would be significantly detrimental to the Arts and
Crafts style of the host property’s rear elevation. This significant harm would
be accentuated by the poor quality design of the fenestration, particularly the
replacement opening for the lost gable and the window at second floor level
within the proposed central gable.
Appeal Decision APP/G5180/D/16/3160874
3
11. Overall, the appeal scheme would not be of a high quality of design because it
would fail to adequately complement the scale and form of the host property’s
Arts and Crafts style and, as such, it would conflict with UDP Policies BE1 and
H8 and LP Policy 7.4. These policies are consistent with the National Planning
Policy Framework's (the Framework) core principle of securing high quality
design.
12. I agree with the appellant that the resulting property would be capable of being
accommodated within the curtilage and it would not alter the overall verdant
and spacious character and appearance of the Conservation Area. However, it
is the cumulative effect of the scale and design of the proposed alterations that
would cause significant harm to the form, proportions, character and
appearance of the property. The resulting dwelling would materially detract
from the property’s current positive contribution to the Conservation Area.
13. Although less than substantial harm would be caused to the Conservation Area
this matter is not outweighed by the public benefits of the proposed
development. Accordingly, it is concluded that the proposed development
would fail to preserve the character and appearance of the Manor Way,
Beckenham Conservation Area and, as such, it would conflict with UDP Policies
BE1, BE11 and H8, LP Policies 7.4 and 7.8 and the Framework.
Other Matters
14. The proposed development would not adversely affect the living conditions of
the occupiers of the neighbouring properties but this matter is significantly and
demonstrably outweighed by the harm which has been identified. Accordingly,
and taking into account all other matters, it is concluded that this appeal
should fail.
D J Barnes
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.