Single storey side and rear extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Fallback Position
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 28 November 2016
by C Jack BSc(Hons) MA MA(TP) MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 28th December 2016
Appeal Ref: APP/A2280/D/16/3159647
1 Embassy Close, Gillingham, Kent ME7 3EN
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs P and K Dudley against the decision of The Medway
Council.
The undated application Ref MC/16/2725 was refused by notice dated 16 August 2016.
The development proposed is a single storey side and rear extension.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for a single storey
side and rear extension at 1 Embassy Close, Gillingham, Kent ME7 3EN in
accordance with the terms of the undated application, Ref MC/16/2725, subject
to the following conditions:
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than three years
from the date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance
with the following approved plan: drawing 16.06.03.
3) The materials to be used in the construction of the external surfaces of
the development hereby permitted shall match those of the existing
building.
Application for costs
2. An application for costs was made by Mr and Mrs P Dudley against The Medway
Council. This application is the subject of a separate Decision.
Main Issue
3. The main issue is the effect of the proposed development on the living
conditions of neighbouring occupiers, with particular regard to daylight.
Reasons
4. 1 Embassy Close is a modest end of terrace house, typical in the local
streetscene. The close is part of a predominantly residential area where there
is a mix of generally close-knit housing. A variety of extensions and alterations
can be seen in the vicinity. At No 1, there is currently a canopy across the full
width of the rear elevation, which is constructed from lightweight timber with a
clear plastic roof covering.
Appeal Decision APP/A2280/D/16/3159647
2
5. The proposed development is a single-storey, wrap around extension to the
side and rear of the house. It would have a sloping, tiled roof with four
rooflights in the side roofslope. The existing canopy would be removed.
6. No significant concerns have been raised in relation to the side element of the
proposed extension and I see no reason to disagree. The Council’s principle
concern relates to the relationship between the rear part of the extension and
the glazed patio doors that are centrally positioned in the rear elevation of the
attached mid-terrace property, 2 Embassy Close, serving the living room.
There are no other windows or external doors to that room.
7. The Council’s report indicates that it found the 45 degree test to show a
detrimental loss of daylight in plan and elevation. However, the Council has
subsequently advised that it carried out the test in elevation incorrectly. It has
submitted a revised test with its response in relation to the appellants’
application for costs, taking the 45 degree line from half way down the roof
slope of the proposed extension. The revised position of the 45 degree line
indicates the test to be passed, however the Council states that its decision
was also based on the information submitted with the application and the case
officer’s site visit. The Council further submits that the appellants also used
the methodology incorrectly for the test in elevation.
8. The appellants have undertaken the 45 degree test in plan and elevation,
shown on the submitted Diagram 1. They accept that the proposed rear
extension fails the test in plan form, because the centre point of the patio
doors lies within the 45 degree line from the outermost adjacent point of the
extension. However, in elevation form, they consider that because the test
refers to patio doors, rather than a conventional window, it should relate to a
point 2 metres above ground level on the centre line of the doors. The 2m
point lies outside the 45 degree line, taken from half way along the sloping roof
of the extension.
9. The appellants’ grounds of appeal indicate that Diagram 1 refers to the 45
degree ‘rule of thumb’ test set out in the Building Research Establishment’s
‘Site Layout Planning for Daylight and Sunlight: A guide to good practice’, 2011
second edition (BRE). The 45 degree test is not enshrined within saved Policy
BNE2 of the Medway Local Plan 2003 (MLP) itself but the supporting text to the
policy advises that the Council will have regard to the advice in the ‘Kent
Design’ 2000, with specific reference to the BRE as containing tests to check
the level of daylight and sunlight. I have also not been provided with that Kent
Design document, however, as it was dated 2000 it would anyway refer to the
earlier edition of the BRE, which has been effectively superseded by the 2011
edition.
10. Section 2.2 of the BRE sets out guidelines for extensions to existing buildings in
order to safeguard the daylight to nearby buildings, including the 45 degree
test in plan and elevation. It advises that if both elements of the test are failed
then a significant reduction of light is likely. Furthermore it advises at
paragraph 2.2.15 that in the case of a floor-to-ceiling window such as a patio
door, a point 1.6m above the ground on the centre line of the window may be
used, rather than the centre of the window. The 1.6m point is not marked on
Diagram 1 but by taking an approximate extrapolation from the marked 2m
point I consider that it would lie marginally outside the 45 degree line, thus
narrowly meeting the test in elevation.
Appeal Decision APP/A2280/D/16/3159647
3
11. However, the patio doors in this case are not fully glazed, having a uPVC panel
section at the bottom. Nonetheless, even if the glazed section alone is
considered to be the ‘window’, and an estimated centre point of that ‘window’
area is extrapolated from Diagram 1, instead of a point at 1.6m, that centre
point would also lie just outside the 45 degree line, again indicating the test
would be met in elevation.
12. Notwithstanding, it must be acknowledged that the test is only a rule of thumb
and needs to be interpreted flexibly in relation to the circumstances of the
case. Here, there would be no two-storey element to the proposed
development, and no other larger structure beyond the proposed extension
that would also block daylight from that direction. There is also no extension
to the rear of 3 Embassy Close on the other side of the patio doors so no
significant ‘tunnel effect’ would result from the proposed extension, albeit the
rear elevation of No 3 is staggered a little behind that of No 2.
13. I note that the proposed extension would have a greater effect on daylight than
the existing canopy, which due to its smaller scale, and relatively lightweight
construction and materials would currently have little impact on the level of
daylight experienced at No 2. Notwithstanding, for the reasons given above, I
consider that while the extension would cause some perceptible reduction in
the level of daylight received at the patio doors, this would not be significant
and accordingly would not constitute harm to the living conditions experienced
there.
14. I therefore conclude that the proposed development would not harm the living
conditions of neighbouring occupiers, with particular regard to daylight.
Accordingly, I find no conflict with saved Policy BNE2 of the MLP, which among
other things seeks to ensure that development would protect the amenities
enjoyed by nearby and adjacent properties, including with regard to daylight.
Other Matters
15. I have considered the various other matters raised by an interested party
including that the proposed extension would block light from the rear garden of
No 2. I have found that the extension would not cause significant harm to
daylight to the living room of that property and while there would be some
effect on the garden area, this would be less significant than to the habitable
room. Accordingly, while I have given this some weight, it does not outweigh
my conclusion in relation to the main issue above.
16. The pruning of trees outside the appellants’ control is beyond the scope of this
appeal. Any alterations previously made to the pedestrian access to the public
highway are also beyond the scope of this appeal. Noise insulation for the
proposed extension would be principally a matter for the current Building
Regulations. I note the concerns about incidents relating to a blocked main
drain in the road. However, there is no firm evidence before me that it would
not be feasible to adequately drain the proposed development. The submitted
plans show that it is proposed to retain the existing off-street parking at No 1.
While some additional parking relating to construction vehicles would be
probable, this would be a temporary effect that may be inconvenient but is
unlikely to be severe. Therefore, these matters can only attract limited weight,
which also does not outweigh my conclusion in relation to the main issue.
Appeal Decision APP/A2280/D/16/3159647
4
17. Representations were also made to the effect that the rights of the adjoining
occupier, Ms Janet Wood, under the Human Rights Act 1998, Article 1 of the
First Protocol, would be violated if the appeal were allowed. I do not consider
this argument to be well-founded, because I have found that the proposed
development would not cause unacceptable harm to the living conditions of Ms
Wood. The degree of interference that would be caused would be insufficient
to give rise to a violation of rights under Article 1 of the First Protocol.
18. I note the appellants’ suggested fallback position that the rear part of the
proposed development could be implemented separately with the benefit of
permitted development rights. I also note that an application for a certificate
of lawful development has been submitted to the Council in this regard and
that the Council advises that the property is subject to a condition removing
permitted development rights for rear extensions. However, it is not a matter
for me, in the context of an appeal made under Section 78 of the Town and
Country Planning Act 1990, to determine whether the appellants might be able
to rely on permitted development rights as a fallback. I have therefore
considered the proposed development before me on its own merits.
Conditions
19. In addition to the standard three year time limit for commencement, I have
imposed a condition requiring the development to be carried out in accordance
with the submitted plan, as this provides certainty. I have also imposed a
condition relating to external materials as this is necessary to ensure the
satisfactory appearance of the development.
Conclusion
20. For the reasons given above, and having regard to all matters raised, I
conclude that the appeal should be allowed.
Catherine Jack
INSPECTOR
£
Costs decision section
Costs Decision
Site visit made on 28 November 2016
by C Jack BSc(Hons) MA MA(TP) MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 28th December 2016
Costs application in relation to Appeal Ref: APP/A2280/D/16/3159647
1 Embassy Close, Gillingham, Kent ME7 3EN
The application is made under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, sections 78,
322 and Schedule 6, and the Local Government Act 1972, section 250(5).
The application is made by Mr and Mrs P Dudley for a full award of costs against The
Medway Council.
The appeal was against the refusal of planning permission for a single storey side and
rear extension.
Decision
1. The application for an award of costs is allowed in the terms set out below.
Reasons
2. Planning Practice Guidance (PPG) advises that, irrespective of the outcome of
the appeal, costs may only be awarded against a party who has behaved
unreasonably and thereby caused the party applying for costs to incur
unnecessary expense in the appeal process. The relevant paragraphs of the
PPG replaced Circular 03/2009.
3. The application for costs essentially relied on behaviour by the Council in
considering the planning application. This included that it did not consider the
applicants’ fallback position of an extension under permitted development
rights, which the applicants considered would result in the same daylight
scenario for the neighbouring property, 2 Embassy Close, as the proposed
development. It was also put to me that the Council was erroneous it its
assessment of the BRE rule of thumb 45 degree test. The applicants
considered that the relevant point fell outside the line in elevation form and
that the test requires the relevant point to be inside the line on both the
elevation and plan forms of the test to indicate the possibility of poor daylight
conditions prevailing. As a result, they consider that the reason for refusal is
not precise and relevant and cannot be substantiated by evidence.
4. The PPG states that examples of unreasonable behaviour by local planning
authorities include failure to produce evidence to substantiate each reason for
refusal on appeal and vague, generalised or inaccurate assertions about a
proposal’s impact, which are unsupported by any objective analysis1.
Furthermore it states2 that costs can only be awarded in relation to
unnecessary or wasted expenses at the appeal, albeit behaviour and actions at
the time of the planning application can be taken into account.
1 Paragraph 049 Ref ID: 16-049-20140306
2 Paragraph 033 Ref ID: 16-033-20140306
Costs Decision APP/A2280/D/16/3159647
2
5. In itself, the reason for refusal set out in the decision notice was complete,
precise, specific and relevant to the application. It clearly stated the policy of
the Medway Local Plan 2003 that the Council found the proposal to conflict
with. The Council’s Officer Report was then provided by the Council to support
its position in the appeal. The appeal was carried out under the expedited
‘Householder Appeal Service’, whereby the Council may provide its Report to
support its position but there is no opportunity for it to comment on the
grounds of appeal or provide a further statement. In these respects, I
therefore consider the Council did not act unreasonably.
6. The Council was also not unreasonable in seeking to assess the proposed
development using the ‘45 degree test’, which the accompanying text to the
relevant development plan policy refers to. This test originates from the
Building Research Establishment’s ‘Site Layout Planning for Daylight and
Sunlight: A guide to good practice’ (BRE). The most recent version of which is
the 2011 second edition. In principle, the Council was not unreasonable in
using the 45 degree test, which as the applicants note is expressly a ‘rule of
thumb’, to aid its assessment of the effects of the proposed development upon
daylight to 2 Embassy Close.
7. The Council has accepted that it misapplied the test when considering the
application. It provided another version with its response to the costs
application, which indicates that the test was passed. Nonetheless, the test is
not intended to be definitive and should generally be used flexibly, factoring in
any relevant circumstances of each case. The more marginal the outcome of
the test, the more pertinent these other factors might be. The Council states
that its decision was also based on a site visit and information submitted with
the application. However, the Council has provided nothing significant by way
of objective analysis or substantiation for its decision in its report,
notwithstanding that it had anyway incorrectly applied the test.
8. The Council’s Report stated only that, “The 45 degree test in plan and elevation
form shows a detrimental harm to the amenity of the occupier of no. [2] due to
the loss of daylight”. Thus it failed to consider the wider context pertaining to
the potential loss of daylight indicated by its undertaking of the rule of thumb
45 degree test. Thereby, the Council failed to fully substantiate its reason for
refusal. Given that the Council appears to have applied the test in black and
white terms for decision-making purposes, i.e. the test was failed therefore
there would be a harm impact on terms of daylight, it seems likely that had the
Council’s original elevation test been carried out correctly, indicating that the
test was passed as the Council’s subsequent test did, it is likely that the
Council would have reached a different determination of the application. In
such a circumstance the appeal would have been avoided as this was the sole
reason for refusal.
9. With regard to consideration of the applicants’ stated fallback position, I note
that an application for a certificate of lawful development for a rear extension
has been submitted to the Council. However, it is not clear from the evidence
before me whether this application was made before the Council determined
the planning application. Furthermore, the Council states that permitted
development rights are removed by condition for rear extensions at the appeal
property. As a result, the Council considered that there was no fallback
position. The Council did not specifically address this in its report so it would
not have been clear to the applicants why the Council appeared to have
Costs Decision APP/A2280/D/16/3159647
3
dismissed the fallback position they believed was relevant to the case.
However, there was also nothing significant in the planning application
documents to suggest that the purported fallback position was put in detail to
the Council at the time of the application, or to indicate that any such fallback
was particularly likely to proceed. In the absence of this, the Council was not
unreasonable in determining the planning application before it on its own
merits.
10. As a result, I consider that the Council failed to fully substantiate its sole
reason for refusal with objective analysis, principally as a result of misapplying
the rule of thumb test upon which it entirely relied in determining the
application. No further specific consideration or contextual justification in
relation to daylight was set out in the Council’s report to substantiate its
decision. In these circumstances, while I consider that the applicants may not
have been put to large amounts of additional expense in countering the
council’s position on this single matter at the appeal, some unnecessary costs
would have been incurred in making the appeal.
Conclusion
11. I therefore conclude that for the reasons set out above, unreasonable
behaviour resulting in unnecessary and wasted expense in the appeal has been
demonstrated and that an award of costs is therefore justified.
Costs Order
12. In exercise of the powers under section 250(5) of the Local Government Act
1972 and Schedule 6 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 as amended,
and all other enabling powers in that behalf, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that The
Medway Council shall pay to Mr and Mrs P Dudley, the costs of the appeal
proceedings described in the heading of this decision.
13. The applicant is now invited to submit to The Medway Council, to whom a copy
of this decision has been sent, details of those costs with a view to reaching
agreement as to the amount, such costs to be assessed in the Senior Courts
Costs Office if not agreed.
Catherine Jack
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.