First floor extension over existing garage to provide a bedroom
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 1 November 2016
by I Jenkins BSc CEng MICE MCIWEM
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 29 November 2016
Appeal Ref: APP/E0915/D/16/3159261
Kinsale, Harraby Grove, Carlisle, Cumbria, CA1 2QN
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr I Johnston against the decision of Carlisle City Council.
The application Ref 16/0417, dated 11 May 2016, was refused by notice dated
12 July 2016.
The development proposed is a first floor extension over existing garage to provide a
bedroom.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. I consider that the main issues in this case are the effect of the proposal on:
the living conditions of neighbouring residents, with particular reference to
outlook, light and privacy; as well as, the character and appearance of the
appeal property and its surroundings.
Reasons
Living conditions
3. Kinsale is a detached house, which fronts onto the northwestern side of
Harraby Grove. It has a single-storey annexe which projects from the 2-storey
front wall of the dwelling and contains a garage for the most part. This annexe
aligns with the northeastern side wall of the main building and extends part
way across its front elevation.
4. The appeal property shares its southwestern side boundary with South View,
another detached house. The front building line of Kinsale’s front annexe
projects forward beyond the 2-storey front building line of this neighbouring
property by a short distance. The northeastern side wall of South View
contains a number of windows, including a kitchen window at ground floor level
which faces towards the southwestern side elevation of Kinsale’s front annexe.
5. The proposal involves the addition of a first floor extension above the appeal
property’s front annexe to provide a bedroom. The proposal would be sited to
the northeast of South View’s facing kitchen window and so would be unlikely
to reduce the sunlight that it receives. Nevertheless, due to its close proximity,
length and height, the extended front annexe would be likely to limit the
Appeal Decision APP/E0915/D/16/3159261
2
daylight received by that neighbouring habitable room window and greatly
reduce the outlook from it. It would be likely to significantly increase the sense
of enclosure experienced by residents of that neighbouring property when
using their kitchen. I regard it as overdominant and unneighbourly.
6. The proposed bedroom would be served by 2 windows, one of which would
provide views towards the kitchen window of South View. As it is shown on the
application plans, the proposal would significantly increase the potential for
overlooking of that kitchen window, which is not directly overlooked at present.
This would harm the privacy of the residents of that neighbouring property.
However, it would be possible to adequately safeguard the privacy of the
residents of South View, through the imposition of a condition that requires the
proposed side facing window to be glazed with obscured glass and fixed shut.
Under these circumstances, the effect on the privacy of the residents of South
View would not be unacceptable.
7. The appeal property shares its northeastern side boundary with Beech House,
which is similar in design to Kinsale, with a single-storey front annexe.
The 2-storey front wall of that building includes 2 bedroom windows at first
floor level, one of which is positioned close to the boundary shared with
Kinsale. The outlook from that window is likely to benefit from existing views
over the roof of the appeal property’s annexe. Due to its close proximity,
forward projection and height, the proposed extension would noticeably reduce
the outlook from that neighbouring bedroom, appearing unduly dominant when
seen from there.
8. Whilst acceptable in terms of privacy, I conclude overall that the proposal
would cause significant harm to the living conditions of neighbouring residents,
with particular reference to outlook and light. In this respect it would conflict
with the aims of Policies CP5, CP6 and H11 of the Carlisle District Local Plan
2001-2016 (LP), which seek to safeguard residential amenity. This aim is
carried forward by emerging Policies SP 6 and HO 8 of The Carlisle District
Local Plan-Proposed Submission Draft-February 2015 (LPe). Insofar as they
seek to secure a good standard of amenity for all existing and future occupants
of land and buildings, the identified Policies are consistent with the aims of the
National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework).
Character and appearance
9. Due to its single-storey scale, the front annexe of Kinsale is a subservient
feature of the front elevation of the house, the 2-storey element of which is
dominated by fenestration, in common with the frontages of neighbouring
properties, which are otherwise varied in terms of scale, massing and design.
10. The materials used in the external surfaces of the proposal would match those
of the existing building. However, as a result of the proposed extension, the
front annexe would dominate the frontage of Kinsale and due to its forward
projection, beyond the front building lines of its neighbours, it would be a
particularly prominent feature of the street scene. Furthermore, its long
2-storey side walls would be interrupted by only 1 or 2 relatively small windows
and its front elevation would contain a single window, giving this prominent
frontage feature an unusually plain appearance. As a result of the combination
of the siting, scale, massing and detailing of the proposal, the extended front
annexe would have an awkward and obtrusive appearance, which would give
an impression of poor design.
Appeal Decision APP/E0915/D/16/3159261
3
11. I conclude that the proposal would cause significant harm to the character and
appearance of the appeal property and its surroundings. It would conflict with
LP Policies C5, C6 and H11 which, between them, seek to ensure that
development responds to the local context in relation to, amongst other things,
scale, massing and appropriate detailing. These aims are carried forward by
emerging LPe Policies SP 6 and HO 8. Insofar as the identified Policies seek to
promote good design they are consistent with the aims of the Framework.
Other matters
12. In my judgement, the proposal would be sufficiently distant from the beech
tree positioned in the corner of the front garden of Beech House so as not to
unduly reduce the light received by that tree.
13. The appellant has indicated that the Council has approved a similar 2-storey
extension elsewhere, planning permission Ref. 16/0087. However, whilst
consistency is desirable, each case must be considered primarily on its own
merits. Furthermore, although I do not know the full details of that other
scheme, it is described on the planning permission as involving a 2-storey rear
extension and single-storey front extension to provide an entrance porch.
It appears not to be directly comparable to the proposal before me and so I
give it little weight.
14. Whilst I note the appellant’s concern regarding the manner in which he says
the Council has approached his application, it does not alter the planning
merits of the proposed development upon which my determination is based.
15. Neither these, nor any other matters raised are sufficient to outweigh the
considerations which have led to my conclusions on the main issues.
Conclusion
16. In my judgement, the proposal would conflict with the Development Plan taken
as a whole and there are no other material considerations which indicate that
the appeal should nevertheless be allowed. For the reasons given above,
I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
I Jenkins
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.