Construction of new single-storey extension to the east side of the existing three-storey dwelling to form enlarged study area and additional play room
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Policy Weight
Character & Appearance
Residential Amenity
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 8 November 2016
by I Jenkins BSc CEng MICE MCIWEM
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 29 November 2016
Appeal Ref: APP/M4510/D/16/3158346
6 Shoreswood Way, Newcastle upon Tyne, NE13 9AE
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs Baker against the decision of Newcastle-upon-Tyne City
Council.
The application Ref 2016/0870/01/DET, dated 6 June 2016, was refused by notice dated
2 August 2016.
The development proposed is construction of new single-storey extension to the east
side of the existing three-storey dwelling to form enlarged study area and additional
play room.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
2. I consider that the main issue in this case is the effect of the proposal on the
character of the street scene.
Reasons
Character of the street scene
3. No. 6 is a 3-storey detached house, which occupies a corner site at the junction
of Shoreswood Way with Hepburn Avenue. An area of side garden, which
extends from the front to the back of the site, separates the 3-storey
northeastern gable wall of the No. 6 from Hepburn Avenue. This area of side
garden is separated from the rear garden of the property by a tall wall, the
alignment of which is similar to that of the northeastern gable wall. The side
garden is enclosed along the boundary shared with Hepburn Avenue by low
railings. Although narrowed slightly and over a short distance by a 2 storey
projection from the gable that contains windows, the application plans indicate
that the side garden is generally around 4.8 metres wide, between the gable
wall and the northeastern boundary of the site. In contrast, the 2-storey
southwestern gable of No. 8, which is situated to the northeast of No. 6 on the
opposite corner, is set back from Hepburn Avenue by a much smaller distance.
4. I consider that the side garden of No. 6 gives the entrance to Hepburn Avenue
a broad, open appearance, which complements the spacious appearance of
Shoreswood Way and contributes positively to the character of the street
scene. The appellants acknowledge that the ‘locality comprises a very pleasant
new development, with the built form carefully considered’. Furthermore, in
Appeal Decision APP/M4510/D/16/3158346
2
my judgement, the contribution made by the side garden of No. 6 would not be
significantly eroded if the existing railings were to be replaced by a boundary
enclosure falling within the scope of permitted development rights, which would
not be significantly taller.
5. The National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) indicates that whilst
decisions should not attempt to impose architectural styles or particular tastes,
it is, however, proper to seek to promote or reinforce local distinctiveness.
6. The proposal includes the erection of a single-storey side extension, which
would project from the northeastern gable wall of the property by around
3 metres. Whilst it would be set back slightly beyond the frontage of the
existing building, it would extend along almost the entire length of the
northeastern gable wall. In addition, the tall wall enclosing the northeastern
side boundary of the rear garden of No. 6 would be removed and reconstructed
on an alignment which would be similar to that of the northeastern sidewall of
the proposed extension. I acknowledge that the proposed single-storey
extension would amount to a subservient addition to the existing 3-storey
dwelling. Furthermore, it would be possible to ensure, through the imposition
of a condition, that the materials used in the external surfaces of the proposed
structures would match those of the existing property, in the interests of visual
amenity. Nonetheless, the proposal, which would reduce the width of the side
garden of No. 6 from around 4.8 metres to approximately 1.8 metres, would
greatly narrow the appearance of the entrance to Hepburn Avenue, to the
significant detriment of the character of the street scene. In my view, this
scheme could not be said to satisfactorily integrate into its setting with regard
to the pattern of surrounding buildings and spaces.
7. I conclude that the proposal would cause significant and demonstrable harm to
the character of the street scene and it would conflict with the aims of Policy
CS15 of the Core Strategy and Urban Core Plan for Gateshead and Newcastle
upon Tyne 2010-2030 as well as Policies EN1.1, H2 and H4 of the Newcastle
upon Tyne Unitary Development Plan, 1998 (UDP), which, between them,
require high standards of design, including seeking to ensure that development
responds positively to local distinctiveness and character.
Other matters
8. At the heart of the Framework is a presumption in favour of sustainable
development. It indicates that this means, where the Development Plan is
absent, silent or relevant policies are out of date, granting permission unless,
amongst other things, any adverse impacts of doing so would significantly and
demonstrably outweigh the benefits. However, in this case the appellants have
not provided any evidence to show that the Development Plan is absent, silent
or relevant policies are out of date. I consider that the Policies referred to
above are consistent with the aims of the Framework, which also promotes
good design and the need for development to respond to local character.
Based on the evidence before me, I consider that the Development Plan can be
considered as up-to-date. The Framework confirms proposed development
that conflicts with an up-to-date Local Plan should be refused unless material
considerations indicate otherwise.
9. In terms of the provision of habitable accommodation, the scheme would make
more effective and efficient use of the appeal site. In this respect it would gain
some support from the Framework, which encourages the effective use of land.
Appeal Decision APP/M4510/D/16/3158346
3
10. The Framework gives encouragement to development that would improve the
conditions in which people live. However, the appeal property already contains
a substantial level of accommodation, including: 5 bedrooms; a kitchen/dining
room and a utility room; a living/dining room; a family room; a study; and, a
number of bathrooms. It appears to me to provide a good standard of
accommodation which is reasonably versatile in form and layout, so as to
minimise the likelihood of future obsolescence. Although I understand that the
proposed extension would provide space that the appellants want, the need for
it has not been explained. Under the circumstances, I am not convinced that it
would significantly improve their quality of life and I give their desire for
additional accommodation little weight. Nor am I convinced that the proposed
extension of the existing rooms, facilitated by the scheme, would contribute in
any material way to the widening of the choice of high quality homes; an aim
supported by the Framework. The appellants have indicated that the width of
the proposed extension, at 3 metres, is the minimum possible to create a
usable room. However, this is not supported by any compelling evidence and,
in any event, it appears to be of little relevance in this case as the space within
the extension would be laid out as an extension to 2 existing rooms, rather
than as a separate enclosed space.
11. The appellants have drawn attention to UDP Policy H3, which seeks to resist
development in a group or area of large, traditional dwellings where it would
result in a loss to the limited stock of these dwellings. This Policy appears to
me to be of little relevance in this case, which involves the extension, rather
than loss, of a dwelling on a modern, rather than traditional, housing estate.
12. The Letter to Chief Planning Officers- ‘Planning for Growth’, dated 31 March
2011, referred to by the appellants, is amongst the documents identified by the
Department for Communities and Local Government list of Guidance
documents cancelled by the planning practice guidance suite, published in
2014. Nonetheless, the principles relied upon appear to be taken forward by
the Framework, to which I have had regard.
13. I understand that residents of properties neighbouring the appeal site have not
responded to the planning application or appeal. However, in my view, the
absence of any consultation responses cannot be automatically interpreted as a
sign of support, as the propensity of neighbours to object can be influenced by
a number of factors. I give the appellants’ unsupported assertion, to the effect
that no response indicates neighbours do not have a problem with the
proposal, little weight. Nonetheless, there is no dispute that the proposal
would be unlikely to harm the living conditions of neighbouring residents.
14. Whilst construction activity associated with the proposal would contribute to
the local economy, given the scale of development proposed, it would be likely
to be limited.
15. Having regard to the economic, social and environmental impacts of the
scheme, I conclude on balance that the harm caused by the scheme would be
likely to significantly and demonstrably outweigh the benefits and it would not
amount to sustainable development under the terms of the Framework.
Conclusions
16. In my judgement, the proposal would cause unacceptable harm to the
character of the street scene, it would conflict with the Development Plan taken
Appeal Decision APP/M4510/D/16/3158346
4
as a whole and there are no other material considerations which indicate that
the appeal should nevertheless be allowed. For the reasons given above,
I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
I Jenkins
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.