Double storey side extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Parking Provision
Highways & Transport
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 31 October 2016
by Jonathan Price BA(Hons) DMS DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 15th November 2016
Appeal Ref: APP/P1940/D/16/3157316
39 Summerhouse Way, Abbots Langley, Hertfordshire WD5 0DY
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Watford Property Company against the decision of Three Rivers
District Council.
The application Ref 16/0882/FUL, dated 15 April 2016, was refused by notice dated
11 July 2016.
The development proposed is double storey side extension.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
2. The main issue in this case is the effect of the proposal on highway safety, with
particular regard to the adequacy of parking provision.
Reasons
3. The proposal is to extend a semi-detached house; one of four similar dwellings
facing onto a turning circle at the end of a short cul-de-sac. This road is part of
an estate of post-war housing, comprising a mixture of detached, semi-
detached, terraced and flatted accommodation. The turning circle contains a
lozenge-shaped area of communal parking, faced on either side by blocks of
flats.
4. No 39 has no road frontage or on-site parking and is served by a footpath from
the street. It has a very large garden to its south and to the east is open
countryside, forming part of the Metropolitan Green Belt. The extension would
be onto the southern gable of the existing house and be set back slightly. The
additions would almost double the size of the existing three bedroom house,
and provide what would effectively be three further bedrooms, although one
upstairs room is labelled a study.
5. The extension could be conveniently converted into a separate dwelling.
However, the application was not made for this and so the appeal should be
considered on the basis of the description of the proposed works, which is for a
double storey side extension.
6. The Council’s development plan comprises the 2011 Core Strategy1 (CS) and
the 2013 Development Management Policies2 (DMP). CS Policy CP10 requires
1 Three Rivers District Council Local Development Framework Core Strategy - adopted 17 October 2011.
Appeal Decision APP/P1940/D/16/3157316
2
that all developments make adequate provision for car parking and DMP Policy
DM13 applies the standards set out in Appendix 5. These require 2.25 spaces
per 3 bedroom dwelling (two assigned) and 3 spaces per 4+ bedroom dwelling
(three assigned).
7. The appellant refers to the Council officer’s report to Committee that, on the
basis that the existing three bedroom dwelling at No 39 generates a parking
requirement of 2.25 spaces, this proposal to create a 5/6 bedroom house would
generate a need for an additional 0.75 spaces. The officer’s report had
considered that an uplift of 0.75 spaces would not lead to such an increase in
parking pressure in this part of Summerhouse Way as to have a material effect
on highway safety.
8. This housing estate was designed to reflect car ownership and usage at that
time. Car ownership and usage is now much higher. I observed from my visit
to this estate that, whilst some properties with a road frontage have on-site
parking, there is much reliance on on-street parking which, due to the narrow
road widths, was obstructing the footways.
9. The parking within the turning area adjacent to the appeal property was mainly
occupied at my mid-morning visit. The Council’s report advises that the 15 or
so parking spaces this area provides are fewer than the 24 units in the blocks
of flats on either side. It is reasonable to conclude that pressure on these
parking spaces would increase in the evening when more people are back from
work. From the evidence, and from my site inspection, I consider off-street
parking provision in the vicinity of the appeal proposal to be at or below the
capacity necessary to meet demand.
10. The appeal property is within walking distance of the bus route in Tibbs Hill
Road and quite close to the shops and services in Abbots Langley High Street.
However, I share the view of the previous Inspector, who dismissed the recent
appeal3 over the Council’s refusal of a proposed new detached house at No 39,
that these shops and services are not sufficiently close as to discourage car
ownership.
11. The existing three bedroom dwelling does not have the benefit of on-site
parking. To substantially enlarge this property to create a 5 bedroom, or
potentially 6 bedroom, dwelling would materially increase the demand for car
parking in the vicinity. I have taken account of the Inspector’s view in the
previous appeal that any additional vehicles in this area would exacerbate
existing parking pressures, materially impacting on pedestrian and vehicle
safety.
12. This proposal would be likely to generate additional vehicles leading to further
pressure on available parking in Summerhouse Way. This would give rise to
additional on-street parking, further restricting footway and road space and
impacting harmfully on the safety of all users of the highway in this part of the
estate. The proposal would therefore conflict with the aims of CS Policy CP10
and DMP Policy DM13 and Appendix 5 which seek that development
demonstrates a safe and adequate means of access through the provision of
sufficient parking.
2 Three Rivers District Council Development Management Policies Local Development Document – adopted July
2013.
3 APP/P1940/W/15/3132135
Appeal Decision APP/P1940/D/16/3157316
3
13. Weight has been given to the lack of representations from neighbouring
occupiers which might have otherwise supported the part of the Council’s
decision that refers to this proposal having a negative impact on existing
residents’ amenity. However, this would not outweigh the concerns found in
respect of inadequate parking provision.
14. Consideration has also been given to the officer’s report whereby it was
recommended this proposal might be made acceptable through a condition
which withdrew permitted development rights allowing the extended dwelling
to become a small House in Multiple Occupation (HMO). However, the Planning
Practice Guidance advises that conditions restricting the future use of permitted
development rights or changes of use will rarely pass the test of necessity and
should only be used in exceptional circumstances. Furthermore, the appellant
has expressed no intention for this proposal to become a small HMO and, in
any event, such a condition would not overcome my concerns in regard to the
inadequate provision for car parking.
15. The Council’s decision notice also refers to other development plan policies.
CS Policy CP1 is an overarching policy on sustainable development and CS
Policy CP12, DMP Policy DM1 and DMP Annex 2 deal with design. However,
these policies do not deal directly with the issue of highway safety and add
little to my considerations in this matter.
Conclusion
16. The proposal would significantly increase the bedroom accommodation in a
dwelling lacking off-street parking. This would be likely to generate further
vehicular use and exacerbate the demand for on-street parking where the
highway dimensions result in this already obstructing the roads and footpaths.
For the reasons set out above, this proposal would be contrary to the interests
of highway safety. Therefore, having taken into account all matters raised,
I conclude that this appeal should be dismissed.
Jonathan Price
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.